Today for breakfast I decided to have a bowl of Trix. Actually, I decided to have a bowl of Mini Wheats, and I was still hungry because I had been running, so I decided to have second breakfast, and that was a bowl of Trix. As I was walking to my computer with my bowl of Trix, I noticed that now rather than just solid colored spheres of fruity YUM, the cereals now has swirls. It seems like every few months cereal companies are doing some new thing to their cereal. A while back they decided that making Trix into fruit shapes, or some other strange shapes, was the best idea. As I walked looking down at my Trix, I thought to myself, "What is the point in that?" Does it really matter what the cereal looks like. Do swirls really make that big of a difference? Are spheres so boring that the kids won't eat this explosion of color and SUGAR? Does it really have any impact on the cereal what-so-ever??? I mean, someone somewhere must think the answer to these questions is "YES!" otherwise we'd still have little spheres of yellow, green, purple and red, rather than the tie-dye hippy version of Trix that is now available. This led me on to think about how the same thing is around in a variety of different products. You can get your special Cars version of Spaghettios, or your Spiderman shaped macaroni and cheese.
Generally I think this is really kind of a stupid thing to do. Overall, it's still the same product, only in a different delivery system. Why make such a big deal about it? And sure, I do have my own unique tastes in the matter. For example, I only buy spiral mac and cheese because I prefer that noodle to the others. I never buy the shaped items because I think they taste terrible. And I stopped buying Trix when they went to the weird shapes because there was more outside than inside making for an overly "crunch" (for lack of a better word) consistency that I didn't care for. So in some terms the packaging mattered, but only because the content had changed. But, that's not what this is all about.
Last night I went to the local school board meeting. I've been attending as many of these as I possibly can, as of late, because I like to be involved in the community and know what the heck is going on. This is especially important because last year we voted to extend a bond (keeping my taxes higher for the next few years) so that the school can make some drastically needed improvements. These improvements include a fantastic new theatre that I got to see some drawings of last night. Given my heavy involvement in the theatre program, it is a good idea for me to go. On the other hand, being a teacher (who has yet to find a job) I also like to see what the district is doing.
Another bond funded project was discussed that really caught my attention. The school is terribly behind the times in terms of technology in the classroom. We're still talking chalk boards and those dinosaur overhead machines that you have to use transparencies or write on in dry erase marker. The school doesn't have overhead projectors, decent internet access, no Wifi, and overall just behind the times. Well the bond is changing all that in a big way. In fact the school is running a pilot program where classrooms are being provided with iPods and iPads. This is where we go back to the idea of Trix with swirls. A very enthusiastic staff member gave a presentation discussing how everyone is just so excited to have this new technology. It was interesting to watch, and nice to hear what teachers and students had to say about the new technology. However, there was no real discussion about how this was really going to be used to change things. The ONE example that was provided was to create an electronic worksheet rather than a paper one. So, really we're talking the same new content with a new presentation. How is this better? It's still the same old Trix, it just has a fancy color swirl on it.
One of the board members seemed to spot this problem and asked how we were planning to measure improvements, or what data we were going to collect to show that the technology was helpful. The answer was that students would be given surveys before and after. That's like asking kids which Trix they like better, the original or the one with swirls. Is that really a good indicator to whether or not improvements are being made? There was a follow up to say that test scores would also be available to see if improvements were present due to the technology. But, I have to say, going with the Trix analogy, checking the different boxes to see if the nutritional values would go up with a different shaped noodle!
Here's the bottom line. I've been in a lot of classrooms at this school, and the problem is the ingredients. I've seen teachers give up on technology saying "This thing never works right" because they don't know how to use it. I've seen them sit back and assign worksheets at the entire lesson plan. I've seen them literally sit behind a desk and read off of a sheet of notes for the students to copy down. I see the students forced to use a classroom set of books, and then fail standardized tests, then the school wonders why when they don't have appropriate access to resources.
Do I advocate sacking a load of teachers. No, not necessarily. I think training could help some. I think a focus on higher expectations would be helpful from the top down. I think that many things can change to make this improvement. At the same time I think there are some who are not up to such a challenge, and for those who can't then a change must be made. I'm not generally one to be against the teachers, because I am a teacher. However, when I look at these things, and I see what is happening all I can think to myself is, "And I can't even get an interview!" Teachers practically brag that they don't read. Teachers have no idea how to relate to students and spend the entire class fighting about a student wearing a hat or some stupid detail that could be settled individually at a later time. Teachers who seem to have the only expectation of "getting through the day" rather than teaching the students. Mere survival is NOT enough. We need to be more than just alive. We need to do more than just survive.
If that's all our society needs then we'd still be living in trees and eating off the land. We are a civilization. We need culture, we need art, we need music, we need an understanding of how the world works, we need an understanding of who we are as a species and where we came from, we need poetry, we need literature, we need Shakespeare. And we need to, as President Kennedy said, "...go to the moon in this decade and do the other things, not because they are easy, but because they are hard, because that goal will serve to organize and measure the best of our energies and skills, because that challenge is one that we are willing to accept..."
In other news: 60 minutes today. 25 down, 6 to go.