Ten years ago today was a big day, because Hamilton tickets went on sale for the Detroit tour, and of course Ticketmaster was horrible and didn't load well, but also they wanted over $200 for obstructed view tickets. As I said at the time, and to quote the show, "You must be out of your goddamn mind if you think..."
All of this is actually true, however, the other thing that happened ten years ago today was that the morning before the tickets went on sale, I had an interview for a full time, permanent teaching job, and it would be teaching 7th and 8th grade history. It was a pretty long interview, as I remember it and it wasn't the horrible panel ones where they ask you canned questions with no deviation, follow ups, or anything. Those are the worst possible interviews, especially if they make you go through the song and dance of doing a mini-lesson, which is such a bullshit thing to do at an interview. At the end they said that they had to interview a few more people and they'd let me know, but then not three hours later I got a call back and I got the job.
It was a long journey to get to teaching, six years of looking while at jobs I hated trying to get to what I wanted to do. 15 years ago I had the curse of having the best experience during my student teaching, that then led into a long term subbing job at the same school, followed by yet more subbing and then long term subbing at the same school the following year. It was a great experience, I enjoyed the people I worked with, the students were fun and were engaged in the lessons. Sometimes I think about them, they'd be in their 30s now, but so many of them were awesome students. The hecklers (who wanted to know how my wife felt about my sassy attitude), the one who was a challenge, the one who always had a crazy YouTube video to share, the one who was like the life of the class when he arrived (that whole class was like a family reunion daily), the kid who told off the "bad kid" in class for making an inappropriate joke, and of course the "bad kid" who was not really a bad kid at all, the kid who was slacking because his parents were enabling it, the one kid of color that I had the entire day and was so jovial and charismatic, the transfer kid who got stuck in a freshman class as a senior because schools in Texas have different years for the subjects, the weird nerdy kid who acted like I was a bud but was amusing so I wasn't a jerk about it. The kid who gave me attitude for their uncommon nickname that I mispronounced. The kid that I had to come up with more challenging lessons for because he was so smart and such a reader that he was almost insufferable to other students because they weren't on his level. The two standard issue white boys who I could never remember their names because they never spoke and they both sat in the same chair on opposite sides of the room and never talked and had the most generic names like Chris, or Steve, or something like that. So many experiences in those first years teaching, and it was so much to live up to, and then the six years in the wilderness looking for a place and meeting rejection after rejection, but today is the day ten years ago that it all changed.
It's a really weird thing, because it at once feels like I've been teaching so long and yet can't possibly have been a decade. That first year teaching in my own class feels like a lifetime ago, another world, another planet even. It was pre-Covid, it was middle school, it was a pretty challenging groups of kids (though nothing to what I've had since), but it was also often fun, and some great kids, and some silliness, puns, jokes. There were students who dreaded the idea of being in my homeroom, only to then be so happy that they were. There were students who drove me up a wall, who I saw later on high school visits who apologized and appreciated what I was trying to teach them. There were students who came back to visit, I got to go watch graduate high school, and who have sent me little messages from college to say how they're doing. But since Covid, there's been less of that. It's been less fun, it's been more of a struggle, it's been less fun and jokes. But it's also been different districts with more challenging students.
This year there were more glimmers of those years at the beginning. There were more jokes, more fun, there's been more students popping by to say hello and say how they're doing. More students who say hello to me in the morning as they pass in the hall to their first hour. It's not quite the same, but it's reminiscent of the past. There were far more "OH! I get it!" or connections to the world today. More recognition of the importance of the topic. At the same time there's been more phones, more AI, more cheating, more slacking, and that's so hard to overcome.
Phones have becoming the overwhelming force in classrooms now compared to when I first walked in a classroom in 2009 and 2010, and from those first days in my own room in 2016. They are everywhere, they are the main focus, and so much time is spent trying to avoid their disruption, their distraction, and their ability to try and circumvent the learning process to achieve the "right answer" without having to learn anything. Not to mention the attempts to text, to always have availability to the distractions of social media, to always have entertainment through games, videos, and music. The energy to hide phones, bypass rules, to not get caught and argue when you do. It's tremendously exhausting, and often times makes it feel like the majority of my time is spent waging a war against technology rather than teaching my subject, and trying to find ways to deter and police technology.
It's a far different world from where it was 10 years ago. As of late, it's felt really disappointing because it feels like more often than not I'm spending very little of my day teaching. Last year we went to the graduation of our foreign exchange student. The keynote speaker was the school's art teacher, and in her introduction the principal said that walking into her room was like going to your favorite aunt's house and described the collaborative and peaceful environment. It's stuck with me, because often it feels like my room is a battle field where I'm fighting to get them to engage, learn, and understand, and the students are doing everything in their effort not to do that. This year, my 6th hour felt more like that room of fun and collaboration, but even still, it's hard to have 57 minutes of a 415 minute day that is peace and 228 minutes of active battle against learning. Every day and every school year feels more like me trying to plot how to get students to learn agains their will. How can I trick them into it? How can I combat their avoidance? How can I isolate the resistance and inspire curiosity? How can I help them see the value in the subjects, in learning, in the investment in their future. I'm sure I'm not alone in this struggle, and it's likely why so many teachers are so utterly and completely drained by the end of it. It's why so many walk away from the profession. It's hard, often demoralizing, stressful, and exhausting.
It also can be disheartening to have sought so long to get to where I am, and to feel like it's morphed into something this hard and to wonder if it's worth it to continue. It often doesn't feel like anything you do through a day matters. That you understand the vital role understanding this material is to each individual, and to the community and society as a while, but that it feels like you're achieving nothing. The feeling of fighting to get students to learn, when that was your whole point, and those days when they do is so invigorating can be overwhelming. To feel like nothing you're doing matters, and that it comes at the price of constant conflict, stress, and disappointment can become overwhelming. Furthermore, to share these feelings and struggles and be met with "well you picked this job" compounds the anxiety about it all. The idea that because you picked it you have no right to complain about any aspect of the challenge (despite the fact that everyone has the moments at their job they complain about). The message is, be happy or shut up because this is the field you wanted. Perhaps that's more an issue of low quality friendship, but it does cultivate this feeling that you have no right to be disappointed that your career expectations have not matched the reality. That the environment is different as are the challenges and conflicts. You have no right to be disappointed, anxious, or let down.
All of this doubt became more pressing following Covid, because when faced with such uncertainty and at the time the feeling of real danger, you begin to question what you're spending your time doing. You wonder if it's worth the tradeoffs. It's clear that time is limited and that every moment away from the things that matter in your life is time lost and that loss became more in focus when a crisis like Covid illustrates how limited time can be. It used to feel like it was a worthwhile exchange. That the benefit justified the time away. However, sometimes that question gnaws at the back of your mind, "Is this really worth lost time in your life?" If you feel like you're not making a difference, then that calculation starts to become troubling. Those questions marks about is this worth it becomes bigger, and it takes more to feel like your time, effort, and dedication are worth it. But this also may be compounded by larger issues.
Sometimes you can feel that hope out there on the margins. You'll have those little moments that provide a glimmer of validation, that little bit of fuel to keep you going and to excite you. That feeling of trying something new to get the attention and understanding. It becomes like the New Deal, where you keep throwing out new ideas and new methods hoping something will stick and that you can make a difference. So you walk away form the edge of the abyss and start brainstorming new ideas, planning new ways to try to make a difference. You evaluate the methods, the procedures, the things that having worked and try to figure out how to morph it into something more successful. You become excited again for another chance to build something that was better than the last iteration. Maybe it's just Charlie Brown and the football, or maybe it's actually going to happen.
So, after 10 years of doing this you can see how much it's changed, and how much it's still some of the same obstacles and challenges. I can see how it's been disappointing, but also how it's been rewarding. I can also say, that the end of this year was the most positive and hopefully I've been in a long time, yet being so close to that edge of despair at times. I've felt the shadow of doubt and at the same time felt the optimistic hope of a new way forward. Today, seeing the reminder of the person from 10 years ago, and the excitement of finally achieving my goal perhaps will be a good motivation to try and tap back into that person. To knock off the rust and repair the weathered down edges. What will I have to say after the next 10 years? I guess we'll have to wait and see.