Sunday, March 29, 2009

I'm Not Listening! LALALALALALALA!

Here's the deal: I'm currently taking a class on argument and debate. It's no big deal, the professor is really laid back, so there's not a lot of pressure with the speeches we have to do. The process is, we pick a topic come up with two arguments, and then do a debate. For example, my last speech was on school funding. So, the other day a girl decided to do her speech on gay marriage. She had very good arguments for allowing gay marriage, which was good. So, after a speech you have a student cross examine you, trying to poke holes in your argument, and you have to defend. So after the designated person asks their questions the whole class is open to ask questions as well. Now, we have about three ultra-conservative bible beaters in our class. And they all decided to pipe up and started asking bible based questions.

So, eventually the professor cut off the argument and decided to give his thoughts on it. He was very polite about what he thought and said that he feels that the message of the bible is love etc. So therefore a lot of hateful views held by those who proclaim themselves christians are contrary to what the bible is all about. And that in this world we need to love each other and be kind etc. Pretty much he said he feels the bible is about being nice, caring for you neighbor and not being a total asshat.

Well, apparently this was not ok with one girl. She starting snarking to her neighbor about how it's not ok for him to tell her that her beliefs are wrong. And that she's not paying to take a class to listen to his opinions. Then she got all red in the face, and stormed out of the class.

Ok, I'm not really irked by the debate. I understand that not everyone in the world agree. I also understand that issues like this get kind of heated. But here's my problem. People freaking out so much that they have to storm out because they don't want to hear what someone else has to say. I'm sorry, but you have to listen to other points of view. And you need to shut up and deal with it because you can't just storm out on someone every time they disagree with you. I've listened to a few speeches that I totally disagreed with, but we have to listen to what others have to say and then have a logical argument to oppose it when we disagree. We can not just throw a bitch-fit and act like a child. When we start to do that we end up at a point where things get really bad and nothing can get done because there's no dialogue.

Plus, the guy was being REALLY calm and nice about it. He wasn't yelling or screaming or being a total dick about it. He was just saying "looooooooooovvvvvvvvvveeeeeee" becuase he's an old hippy. So, really when you look at it, she was saying "no, love is wrong, I believe in hate and it's wrong to tell me otherwise." Dude... that's a bad argument. But hey, we all listened to you spew trash and didn't storm out on you, so perhaps you should grow up and join the big kids table and realize you're going to have to listen to other viewpoints and you can't just storm out when someone disagrees with you.

No comments: