In fact, what I just said, could be on the test. Ok, pardon me a moment while I pull out my soap box…
Here’s the deal, people. Education is not about going down a checklist and marking things off the list, however that seems like the way that everything is going these days. I’ve been in a classroom for just about two weeks and I’m starting to notices a few things about the students, though they are things I should have suspected from the way society has been moving in recent years. It seems to me that we’re turning into a civilization of Pavlovian Dogs who are becoming conditioned to just do the bare minimum, to do only what’s expected, and to resist being asked to do anything more than that.
Today, a student asked me, “Can’t you just tell us exactly what subjects to study so we don’t have to worry about all the other stuff that doesn’t matter?” My initial desired reaction was to yell, “EVERYTHING I SAY COULD END UP ON THE TEST! In fact, what I just said could be on the test.” I even considered adding a bonus question that said, “What information could show up on your test?” I also wanted to say, “Just because it’s not on the test doesn’t mean it doesn’t matter.”
The whole system is set up that if it’s not on the test, it must not be important, and therefore I don’t need to know it. In addition, the system is set up to be like some poor teenager with an eating disorder. Consume and purge. OUR SCHOOL SYSTEM IS BULIMIC! That’s right, we eat the information, we spit it back up, and then it’s gone and we don’t need it anymore. But, that’s leading down a different path and therefore I digress.
The point is there’s this movement toward only doing things that are “relevant” and ignoring things that are seen as “unimportant”. You see it all the time when people say, “I’ll never use this in my ‘real life’ so why do I have to learn it?” I had a conversation with a family member who said, “Why do we teach so much math to all students when really all people need to know how to do is balance their checkbook.” What’s wrong with this idea? Well, first, who still uses checkbooks? Second, who balances them now that we have online banking. Third, we need to learn a variety of things because we need to be able to find out what our interests are, because we need to do more than just specialize in one area and three BECAUSE WE NEED TO BE MORE THAN DUMB MONKEYS!
Dumb monkeys know how to do what they need to do. They can find food, find places to stay, some even have learned to use “tools” like sharp sticks or rocks. So, why do they need to learn anything other than that, they have what they need to live, right? Well, the simple answer is, if we only did that, we’d still be living with chimps because we never would have learned anything new that we “need to learn”. It irks me to no end when people talk about how certain subjects aren’t needed, from Math, to Music, to Art, to PE. Maybe I’m too set in my ideas of classical education, but people need ALL of those things in order to be members of a vibrant civilization. Math is important because it provides students with and opportunity to learn logic; the arts are a necessity for a culture that’s more than just utility; and physical activity is important so that we aren’t all giant fat-ass people who can’t walk up a flight of stairs without getting winded.
I mean, I’m not going to say I didn’t hate certain classes. Gym class was a daily chance for me to be ridiculed and taunted, however those fade away and I’m able to look back and appreciate it and see the value in it.
We have to get away from this insane idea of excessive specialization. No one sits around and says, “Why do I need to learn to walk when I’m going to sit at a computer all day and type. Shouldn’t I only do things that exercise my fingers and make me a better computer user?” No, because that’s STUPID.
So, no, you don’t get to find out what’s on the test because I’m not teaching you to take a test, I’m teaching you about the history of our societies and what I want you to learn to do isn’t something you’re going to be able to show by simply filling in a bubble on a scantron.
No comments:
Post a Comment