Friday, July 15, 2011

Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part II Review

Well, as you all know (at least if you know me at all), last night I was at the midnight opening of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows part 2. Actually, we got tickets to a double feature, so at 9:00 we got to see part 1, and then at 12:01 we got to see part 2. It was nice to see part one, then have about a 45 minute break to get refills, stretch, and then be ready for part 2. It was also nice to not have to wait in a killer long queue of people for the 12:01 showing, because we got to get our seats for part 1, and keep them, so really it was pretty stress free.

Going into part 2, you know it is going to have to be full of action, because the second half of the book is where all the action takes place. Part 1 probably would have been better titled "Harry Potter and the Deathly Exposition" or "Harry Potter and the Deathly Camping Trip" as not much happens. In contrast, part two of the film is where everything that's really important happens.

The movie did not disappoint, because the majority of film takes place in Hogwarts. You open to get the great sequence of breaking into Gringotts, which stayed pretty true to the book. The Dragon was excellent, and the escape was exactly how I pictured it. All in all, very well done. However, that only took the first 15-20 minutes of the movie (or perhaps it only felt like that), so that means the rest of the film is devoted to the final part of the book, which is the battle at Hogwarts.

I have to say that I was sad not to get much about the Dumbledore history, but they hit on a few points, and all in all I'm not that bent out of shape because it's a movie, and they need to keep the plot rolling. Of course, there were also some deviations from the book, but again, it wasn't anything that I thought was inappropriate (such as in movie 4 where you had a waste of time dragon chase when they could have added more important plot). So, I wasn't displease with any of the additions, or really about any of the parts that were left out. In the end I felt they did a perfect job putting in all the scenes fans would have wanted to see.

The final battle was excellent, mixed some humor with loads of sadness at the death of favorite characters. The Prince's Tale was excellent, and had all the elements that I loved from it, and even added a few shots that I thought were perfect, such as Snape entering the Potter's house after the attack. The scene in the forest before Harry's "death" was wonderful, pulling lines right out of the book. The scene in King's Cross with Harry and Dumbledore was just about perfect. Even the epilogue was great, and for me I was thrilled to hear the composer go back to the ending music from movies 1 and 2 for that scene.

As a movie, it was action packed, and well done. As a fan watching the movie, I couldn't have been happier with how it turned out. It had everything I wanted, it was missing virtually nothing that I really wanted to see on screen, and was a wonderful end to the series. My rating is see it. I saw it opening night in 3-D. If you like 3-D then go for it, if you don't, it really didn't have any of those cheap 3-D tricks in it, so I actually had no issues for it. I plan to see it again sometime soon. So, that's a Full Price, IMAX, 3D Ticket rating. It's worth the money.

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

I agree, fans will be happy with this ending to an amazing series. I did wonder a few times if the "movie audience" would be lost at parts where the "book audience" would know what's going on. Like the whole Snape subplot. It went very quickly, although I really liked it (adding Snape after the attack was genius, and makes sense).

I was kind of glad they left out almost all of the backstory on Dumbledore, even in the books I was getting kind of annoyed with that stuff. (Is he trustworthy, is he not.) A change from the books I really liked in the movie was the Hermione-Ron kiss. Very dramatic movie moment!

Although I know the ending at Platform 9 3/4 was kept the appropriate length, I kinda wish there was more dialogue there. Maybe having the kids interact on the train more, or saying how Teddy Lupin is Harry's godchild. Maybe I just wanted to hold on to the ending more. I do wonder if non-readers will pick up on everything implied at the end.

Anyway, yes, GREAT movie!! Fun to read your review!

Jason said...

It also gave a bit more emotion to the whole Snape story to see him there, and i think it really made sense. Generally I've not been a fan when they add stuff, but this was good. The other thing I absolutely loved was the story Slughorn told in movie six about his fish.

As for the Dumbledore thing, I think that she was going for that "should we trust him" idea. The entire series he's kind of been this perfect, wise, wonderful character who always does the right thing, but the back story changes that. By learning about that he becomes a person who is just as flawed as everyone else, but who still tries to do what is right and learns from his mistakes. By doing this you also get the choice of trusting him or thinking he's a bad guy who was manipulating people the whole time.

As for the ending, I think it did a nice line between readers and non-readers. For a non-reader you get that they're married with kids, and that things are nice. For the readers you get to take what you know of the books and see it there, even if it isn't spoken, and you get the implications. So, I liked it.

Anyhow, fun discussion!

Becky said...

I think what I loved is that by giving Dumbledore flaws in his back story, it made him the embodiment of his own preachings, that is is our choices that show who we are, far more than our abilities. No one was given more natural ability than Dumbledore but it showed that through his choices, he was able to rectify some previous wrongs. I dunno. It just brought things full circle for me.

Anonymous said...

That's true. Not only does it make Dumbledore more of a human character (not just words and description on a page) but wouldn't the wisest person get that way because they had gone through trials and made bad decisions? I guess it was important to have the backstory. Otherwise he becomes a god-like character (although he REALLY looked like one in the King's Cross scene). He looked like a "hoooly ghost, hoooly ghooost!" Sorry, Eddie fits everywhere.