Tuesday, December 20, 2011

Mockingjay and the Hunger Games

Yesterday I finally finished Mockingjay, and thus the Hunger Games series is now over! So, what to think about the series? This series came very highly recommended and I read them all very quickly. But what do I have to say about the series as a whole?

My Rating: A Wonderful Setting, Poorly Used.

Here's the thing I loved the first book. It was fantastic. Then the second and third book started acting like it wanted to be Twitlight, I mean Twitard, I mean that shitty vampire book by the woman who doesn't know how to spell her own name.

The problem is we have this fantastic set up. A post modern world that nearly destroyed itself. An oppressive government that takes all the luxuries and leaves the people to starve and fend for themselves. A cruel government that allows the murder of 23 children every year as "tribute" in their arena that harkens back to the Roman Empire and the Colosseum. A strong girl hero who steps up to protect her sister from being part of the Hunger Games. A moment of defiance against the treachery of the capital during the games. The promise of rebellion and independence from oppressors.

SO MUCH POTENTIAL! And yet, so wasted.

First, after finishing the series I have to say Gale was unnecessary. A tighter story could have been woven together had he been a non-character that was present but not a major player, something like Greasy Sae, there but not vital. But instead we are thrust into an unnecessary love triangle, leading to most of the time our heroine worrying about who she likes. Rather than being a total BAMF, she gets all mopy and stupid. Additionally, but not giving us a clear focus, it turns out I don't really care what happened to either one of them. Instead they muddle around going back and forth between the two of them rather than picking one and writing an actual good story. I don't think it would have been impossible to just go with Peeta and stop all the nonsense. He was perfectly likable, during the games they obviously grew close. It would have worked out fine.

Because of this uncertainty we end up with main character who really needs to read some Harry Potter or something. Really? We have a character who defies the government on a daily basis, who steps up to certain death to protect her sister, who kicks some ass in the arena, who risks her life for someone else, who is ready to commit suicide at the end, thus defying the government, and then turns into a whiny, uncertain, passive, boring protagonist in the second and third books? What happened to that giant pair of balls you had in book one? Oh, I forgot, a sparkly vampire cut them off and you decide you wanted to be a lame girl. That's cool... we can't all be awesome...

As for Mockingjay, I did enjoy it more than Catching Fire. There was less love triangle, chiefly because Peeta was locked away being brainwashed, but we still didn't have that same drive that the first book had. I was also shocked at the death of Prim. It seemed unnecessary, and just a nice way to get Gale out of the way because the author apparently couldn't decide how to do that without killing him. But implying that perhaps his knowledge was used as a weapon that ended up killing Kat's sister, was the only way to lose him without killing him. Which I say, kill him, and keep Prim. I enjoyed the meeting with Snow at the very end, and as soon as that happened I knew how the story would end, which wasn't a bad thing.

So in the end, you have a fantastic backdrop to tell a story in, but I'm sad to say I felt that once you passed the first book, the second two were a disappointment from where they could have gone. Both sequel books seemed rushed, unfocused, and under developed. I believe some better story boarding, or outlining could have greatly benefited the series and could have helped them come to their full potential.

So, I suggest reading them, because they aren't bad, but don't expect too much out of them. If you're a Twitard, you may like them. If you're a Harry Potter nerd, you may find them underdeveloped and lacking.

No comments: