Last night was the drama club's final group sale for this school year and we were at the lovely Fisher Theatre to see Beauty and the Beast. Now, I enjoy this show, I always loved the cartoon, and this is pretty much the same with the addition of some songs. LHS did it a few years back, and Milan did it just a few weeks ago that I got to see. I even got a chance to see it in New York about 10 years back and thought it was just delightful.I'm sad to say that I'm feeling quite disappointed in the Broadway in Detroit series. The last show we saw was Shrek, and I mentioned in a previous blog that I was a little disappointed in the transition they did. Well, I was highly disappointed in this one. See, with Shrek I wasn't aware of some of the changes until after when I saw some bootleg YouTube from the Broadway version. With Beauty and the Beast, I'm already familiar with the show, so the changes I noticed as I was sitting there.
To begin, they again decided that it was necessary to cut songs from the show. This time it was two songs. In act I Belle and her father sing a song called No Matter What, which is really sweet and quite enjoyable, but they decided to just cut it and jump to her dad heading off to the fair. Incidentally, his contraption was odd, and I didn't even understand what it was supposed to do. Second, in act II they cut the Maison Des Lunes song from the show. They decided that rather than singing the song, they added a scene where they spoke all of the information that was in the song. WHAT IS THE POINT OF THAT!?!! That's like saying, I'm going to cut the peaches from this recipe and replace it with canned peaches! The song takes about as much time as it took to do the absurd scene.
I also have to say that the sets were really not great. I expect more out of a show done in this type of venue. They were very minimalistic, and nothing at all what one should expect. I give them credit because I do have to say the costumes were nice (though I've always hated the talking cup bit, with the kid's head sticking out of the cart to make it look like he's just a cup. SUPER LAME). I was just totally underwhelmed by the entire set. It also was extremely cartoony and not in a good way, but in a gaudy way that lacked any realistic qualities. Furthermore the magic was just awful. Pretty much they pulled some of the same tricks that we pull at LHS. Oh, need someone to appear? Flash some lights end in a short blackout, and then bring them back up! WOW! MAGIC! It was like watching a community theatre only paying Broadway prices (well, we got a hefty discount, but still...). The theatre is fully equipped, so I don't understand why they couldn't put the proper "magic" into the show. It isn't technically hard, it's actually pretty easy and would have been totally impressive.
I guess the last thing that really got me the most was how bafoonish they made the whole thing. When I've seen it everywhere else, they haven't made it out to be a giant load of BS. They have taken it seriously. Not like this is a somber type show, but this is for real, these are real people. Kind of like when you work with the Muppets. You need to to take it seriously, and it was just so over the top and stupid. Lame sound effects, over exaggerated reactions, unrealistic characteristics. It was just a let down. To me it was as if there was no emotion with any of the actors, there was no heart to the show. I was quite sad.
I think the worst thing was during the title song where Belle and Beast waltz about the stage, except they weren't even waltzing. They were just... moving. Seriously? We can't even manage a proper waltz? It's almost like laziness! Seriously! LEARN A PROPER WALTZ IF YOU ARE GOING TO HAVE TO DO ONE ON STAGE!
That being said, I paid very little, but I'm starting to feel disappointed in these touring productions. Why is it that Les Mis could tour, bringing their full turntable and barricade and Beauty and the Beast can't even manage decent set?
So there you have it. Hopefully next season will go better, but we shall see.
No comments:
Post a Comment