For those of you following the whole Chick-fil-A thing, you know that today is either the "we love your homophobia, lets buy your stuff" day, or the "we hate your homophobia, lets go order a glass of water only because it'll cost you a few cents, and we can quote biblical passages about giving water and food to your enemy thus making you look kind of lame" day. I think it's pretty needless to explain which side of the issue I'm on.
However, I'd like to take a minute to talk about another issue that people are tossing around. You see, some people, like the ever moronic Sarah Palin, are complaining that a boycott on Chick-fil-A on account of what the owner of the company believes "has a chilling effect on our 1st amendment rights." This is very convenient since it has been said that corporations are people, and that the use of money is a way of speech in political races, both ideas she surely supports, that she now has a problem with ACTUAL people speaking with their money and choosing to boycott a place that doesn't align with their personal views.
I'm sorry, but any way you cut this, a boycott doesn't hurt freedom of speech. A boycott is a form of speech, so it could hardly be considered damaging. The owners of Chick-fil-A still have as much right to say whatever hateful and backwards thing they want. They could come out and say they don't support the idea of people owning dogs, or sending children to college, or that they want to add the 10 commandments to the bill of rights. They have every right to say it, and they are protected under the Constitution to say this. However, so am I, and I can choose to say that's a load of horse crap, and that I won't be spending my money at their establishment.
You see my decision as a private citizen to do something in reaction to what someone else publicly says, in no way makes it so that person can't say those things. Perhaps it means it's in his or her best interest NOT to say things like that since they own a business and things like that could influence customers. But it does not have a "chilling effect" except that if you operate a business where you want people to give you their money in exchange for a good or service, then it's best not to offend large portions of your customer base.
Really it comes down to living with the consequences of our choices. If this is the owners strongly held belief, he has the right to say what he wants, but he can't expect that it won't change the minds of some people. Freedom of speech doesn't mean that there are no consequences for our actions, and when those consequences are negative, we can't claim that speech is being infringed or "chilled" because we don't like how things panned out. So he will have to live with the fact that the way he is and the way he operates his business are against my beliefs, and I won't support it with my money.
Freedom of speech is a two way street, and there are always consequences.
No comments:
Post a Comment