The first thing I'll address is the casting. It seems that no one is happy with Carrie Underwood's performance. Twitter and Facebook has been full of snark, and pretty much everywhere is giving her shit about it. I'm not going to necessarily do that. I will say that her performance wasn't great, but I will say she isn't trained for that sort of performance. She's not a Broadway singer, and she isn't an actress, so I can't really give her too much shit. She got on national television and did a LIVE performance. It wasn't easy and she did the best she could do (or at least I assume she gave it her all). So I have to say good for her for doing it.
However this gets to the larger issue, and that is the person who cast this show really screwed the pooch on it. Clearly they were after ratings and they got that, but surely there could have been other actors that could have brought viewers and been right for the part. It's not the actor at fault when they are miscast. You should never put an actor in a situation where they are in over their head, it's just not right to do to the show, or the actors. I don't think this just goes for Carrie Underwood. I wasn't very impressed with any of the acting, except perhaps for probably Laura Benanti as Schrader.
I think this goes into a secondary problem with the direction. I feel that surely they could have had some better results if they perhaps had a better director. The captain seemed like all he was doing was yelling all the time. There was no movement of his character, he was always pissy looking and at the same level. Maria... well, was flat and had some terrible delivery and surely could have been asked "try saying it a different way". Everything was just flat, and perhaps part of that is doing a show without an audience. This carries over into the choreography which was boring and looked more like something you'd see on a high school stage rather than on national television. Also, the ballroom scene was way over the top with the big movements and dancing. What was that.
I think the biggest issue I have is that NBC couldn't seem to get their technical issues under control. The sound levels were terrible. Quite often you couldn't hear the singers on account of the music. There was definitely background noise/hiss that surely with their technology they could have cleaned up. There were times that I saw someone hiding behind a piece of set, or where they really could have used a better stedicam. All these issues should be easily addressed when you have a huge company like this producing it.
In summation, I was very disappointed by this. About a third of the way through I considered just turning it off and popping in the DVD instead, but I felt I needed to watch the whole thing and give it a chance. I like that we get some Broadway on television, but I wish they had done a better job with it. If this is your ambassador to those who don't usually see a Broadway show then you're totally missing out. I've seen this work, for example we saw Daniel Radcliffe in How to Succeed In Business Without Really Trying and he was amazing. They didn't skimp on the choreography he worked his tail off, and it worked great and he was doing 8 shows a week for months. So surely they could have done better with a one time performance with a big name. It was underwhelming and sad.
Picture(s) of the Day:
Picture 279
So, I've had this issue of Time on my desk for months because I don't read on my break anymore. I just don't feel like doing it. I really am behind, I think this issue is from much earlier in the year. Which means all the ones since it are sitting around my house. On the other hand, I did read some of the Book Thief last week, so that's happening at least.
No comments:
Post a Comment