Now, I don't have a huge friends list on social media, so I don't have a large mass of people flooding my news feed. I also don't have a lot of total right wing nuts on my friends list, and even the more conservative people are more reasonable and not the Polly Parrots of the Glen Beck types. However, there is one that every so often will repeat something that is clearly a Fox talking point, and I got to see that this morning. Basically the post was, "Why are we talking about this, these people are bad and deserve it. Why should anyone care what happens to the bad guys?" Now, first I find it kind of ironic that this is coming from a super religious person who is part of a group that has a torture device as their symbol and their savior was treated inhumanely, but hey, what do I know.
However, the point of the post was asking why it matters and anyone should care what happens to the "bad guys" as they clearly deserve to be punished. Ok, well the first point I'll make is that the report revealed that a number of the detainees were being wrongfully held. So how about justice for one. It is not just to hold the wrong person, and therefore even more unjust to physically abuse one wrongfully held (and clarification, it's wrong to do that to anyone, but to someone wrongfully held it's even worse).
The second point I'd make is that it's against the law. We signed an agreement that said we wouldn't' do things like that. We, along with 192 other nations, agreed that torture is wrong and no one should be subject to that. We should care what's happening because our word is on the line. Our word that we would live up to what we say we are going to. We said we don't want to live in a world with torture, and we signed on to make sure that happens, so we should care because we're going back on our word (which is illegal).
We should care because it's also ineffective. The CIA before 9/11 said as much. They said, "You know what, torture doesn't work, it doesn't produce anything, it produces false information, so it's totally ineffective." So why are we doing it? It gets us nothing, but we're still doing it. In fact, I'd say that the only thing it's sure to do is to make our citizens more in danger because of a desire for revenge, or have us seen as monsters who do those sorts of things. It serves no purpose and we should know that it's happening so we can protest it and urge our representatives to take action.
Finally, how about some compassion for other human beings. I don't care how nasty they are. Yes, some of these guys planned terrible events that led to many deaths. They are responsible for murder, absolutely. However, no one deserves to be tortured. It is below our values and a disgusting act that puts on on the level with who we are fighting against. That's not who we are as a nation, it's not the values we're founded on, it's disgusting. Regardless of who these people are we are a nation of laws and these people can be subject to those laws and punished accordingly. Torture is not one of those laws and to dehumanize people, regardless of how terrible they are, is wrong and leads to poor decisions.
Americans like to think of themselves as the good guys. We have this World War II image of ourselves as coming to save the day fighting against tyranny and for freedom. If that's the way you want to see us, then torture doesn't fit into that picture. We should care because it matters, and if you're listing to anyone defend this and are agreeing with them, then there's something wrong with you.
Picture(s) of the Day:
Picture 367
Picture of the day... the darkness of a theater. Haha! I thought that was amusing. Went to a movie tonight, of course there will be a review of it posted tomorrow.
No comments:
Post a Comment