There's a lot that we still don't know about why this all happened, but it doesn't seem to take much to figure out why this company and these people would be attacked. The suspects that are being searched for had a clear motivations. The way it's all sounding is that it has to do again with the class of civilizations and cultures. In the end it's kind of a tough situation for someone of a more liberal mindset where you believe in people being free to practice their religion and their beliefs, and being aware of the discrimination that minorities have to deal with. At the same time when you have these sorts of things take place it becomes hard to determine where the line is between respecting the cultures of others, and still maintaining your culture. How do you balance when one side believes that speech must be free even when it's something you disagree with, and the other believes that there are no exceptions for some kind of speech.
France has made news in recent years in their harder line on cultural assimilation and what is and is not allowed in France. There was a controversial law about overt religious displays which would make it illegal to wear head scarfs in schools (though also would do the same for other religious clothing or jewelry to my understanding). Their position seem stop be that they believe that those moving to France should assimilate to French culture and conform to the value of the French people rather than maintaining their own culture from where they come from. Is that the right way to do it? Is that inconsiderate of minorities? Which is right?
The next portion of the agreement that will come will be that we can't paint with a wide brush when these sorts of things happen. It will be framed in the context that just because some fundamentalist groups did this doesn't mean that is indicative of the religion. Not all Muslims would do this, which instantly makes me think of the #notallmen trend recently when the discussion of rape was the big news story. There is also the question of while not all people who follow Islam would do this, and a large portion do not agree, at the same time there is a very high rate of those that while they wouldn't carry out such attacks agree with the idea and feel that the cartoonists got what they deserved for depicting the prophet based on information from the Pew Trust. This is much the way that perhaps while not all people owned slaves they supported the institution, or further they may not all have bene in the clan but felt that people like Martin Luther King, Emmett Till, and Malcolm X (not to mention many others who were victims of lynchings and violence), got what he deserved.
That being said does that mean that Islam is bad? Does that mean that everyone believes that these things are OK? No, of course not. Pointing these things out is not in any way saying that Muslims should be discriminated against, nor that the actions of some are what most would do. However you do have to acknowledge that we are experiencing a clash of cultures where we have very opposing views.
In the end, freedom of speech, expression, and the press is the most important cornerstone of our civilization. The ability to call out hypocrisy, to criticize those in charge, to be critical of our government, religious institutions or corporations is what makes our form of government possible. The ability to call out whatever we feel is unjust is the most important part of our way of life. Being able to exchange ideas to engage in debate, to say things that others may find distasteful is the the reason we have been able to progress. Being able to criticize our government was what allowed us to form a better way to govern. Being able to go against the ideas of the church allowed us to better understand the universe. Progress has been made by speaking out and calling for change.
In the end the actions were an example of exactly why we need these freedoms. There are those out there that want to silence things they disagree with, and that is not who we are as a culture. We believe that people should be willing to live how they see fit and allow others to do the same even if it is different. Is a hard thing to balance in a world that's more connected where people can come and go in ways that they couldn't in the past, but these are our basic values and my hope is that these people who wish to censor others and intimidate us won't win. That like the image above the attack will result in us defending that belief and doubling down on that. It seems that may be the case given all the images I've seen and the sentiment of those defending the pen and holding to the saying that the pen is mightier than the sword.
Picture(s) of the Day:
Picture 7
This is one of the gifts that we got and it's freaking great. It's so easy but so wonderful. You just put them where ever you want and then they are easy to get to and they dry very well. It's such a simple ting but it's so helpful! Plus it looks kind of cool.

No comments:
Post a Comment