I like NBC, and I like Brian Williams who anchors the broadcast. A few days back he said something about a helicopter story from 2003 but I was not fully listening as I was feeding Sal so I didn't catch exactly what the issue was but gathered enough that there was an error in reporting. Well since then the story has become more widely discussed and it seems that in 2003 there was a report while Brian Williams was covering the Iraq war, then a few years ago he was on David Letterman and told an exaggerated story about the event from ten years ago, followed by a report later that talked about the original incident, but instead of sticking to the original story it used the embellished story. Basically, Brian Williams lied on the air.
So, what's the big deal? Well, unfortunately he lied on the air about a story. It's a stupid lie, it's a lie that doesn't really mean much in the context of the story itself, however in the broader view of things it undermines the trust of the public who consumes the news. It immediately makes you question what else was lied about, especially in an environment that is distrustful of institutions. You can't be someone who presents the news if you are someone who isn't honest.
At the same time you have Fox News that reports verifiable false information with no remorse and they are allowed to operate and are one of the most widely viewed stations. Or other stations reporting speculation that often it gets wrong. How does that make sense? It's no wonder that institutions aren't trusted when you have constant erosion of credibility?
Right now Brian Williams is on leave while they investigate. I really like him, I like the Nightly News even if it is less than robust, and I wonder how this will turn out. I don't know if he can come back from this because broken trust is hard to regain, or at the very least the image of trust that NBC News will want to maintain. In the end I think it's less about Brian Williams and more about what the news is and the need to be credible after years of failing to do so. It's why shows like The Newsroom really appeal because it is the way we all hope and wish news agencies operated, in the interest of the public and to challenge and report on things that should be seen in a republic if it is to operate properly.
Picture(s) of the Day:
Picture 40
Had to take something over to the UPS box next door, but rather than putting on a coat and going out into the cold I just took the tunnel.
No comments:
Post a Comment