Well, today was the last day of rulings from the Supreme Court, and it was a bit of a mixed bag. The first case involved lethal injection. I don't believe in the death penalty. I know for a fact that if someone did something to someone I loved, I would want their head on a plate. I understand hate and anger, but I also don't believe that it is the right of anyone to take the life of another person. I don't like that we kill prisoners, no matter how terrible the crime and feel that we should be taking steps to be a more enlightened civilization that can find a better way. However, that's getting more into the whole concept and set up of our corrections system, not about this case. In this case I really didn't care about the outcome because it wasn't going to change anything really except what drugs they use for lethal injection. The ruling came down that the state of Oklahoma could continue to use the drugs that they are using and said there really wasn't any proof that there was a better alternative.
However, the thing that I did approve of was the dissent by Justice Ginsberg and Breyer who went further than saying that they shouldn't be allowed to use the drug and argued that it's entirely possible that the death penalty violates the eighth amendment which bans cruel and unusual punishment and that they feel that should be looked into. Of course, just like in the cases last week, Justice Scalia (who is apparently an old timey, angry elf) lost his mind and made some outlandish comments. Basically he's a garbage person and it will be a better day when he is no longer on the court.
The bigger win was that the court upheld Arizona's independent district drawing committee. Basic story here is back in like 2000 the legislature decided that to better represent the people the congressional districts would be determined by an independent non-partisan committee. Fast forward 10 years when you have republicans in control and it's time to redraw congressional districts and you have them angry that they can't do it the way they want. So they sue saying that it a committee violates their rights because it's their job to make the districts. Well the court ruled that the committee was legal (which is good news for other states that use them). My favorite part was about how it would allow the voters to pick the representatives rather than the representatives picking their voters. Which to me is far more democratic. I wouldn't mind more states going to that policy because gerrymandering is out of control and does nothing good for the republic.
The final case was regarding the EPA and their regulation on emissions from power plants. At first glance it seems like it was bad news because the court ruled against the EPA. However, when you look at the decision they didn't out right say that the EPA couldn't regulate these emissions, just that they had to consider the costs before they required action. Further, the regulations have been in place for quite some time, so most plants have already made the changes so it's doubtful that they would revert after already making the change. Further, the EPA could still mandate even after considering cost, though it would not probably be a little more work.
So over all it was a mixed bag today, but the past week has seen some pretty exciting rulings. The court is now out until the fall, and we'll have to wait to see what cases they take up, but I'm sure some of them will be pretty big.
Picture(s) of the Day:
Picture 180
Here is one of Misty and my grandpa Falcon. People reading my blog know that I've been researching family history and that he had quite an interesting assignment during World War II. It was only during looking at this photo that I realized on the wall in the frame is actually information about his unit. It was always right there and I never noticed.
No comments:
Post a Comment