As of today a few issues have started to be discussed. The first being the decision by the administration not to release the photos of Osama after being taken down. The argument is that this could be used as a rally point, propaganda, or just inflame public opinion in that region of the world if the photos were released. For the most part I feel that the decision not to release the photos is probably the right choice. I think that those photos should remain classified for an adequate number of years before being declassified at a time when it will not be detrimental. I don't think it's a "trophy" as many from the left are accusing, but rather proof. While I'm sure that certain groups would use it as such (hence why it should remain classified for a good deal of time), I think in general that's not what people want. At the same time, living in a democratic republic, it may be something that should be released. I think in the long term perhaps something that is released many years in the future. I think members of Congress should be allowed to view it, and report back (as some have). If my Senator or Representative says, "I've seen it, and it's true" then that is enough for me. But for the CYA of it all, that is what should take place. Congress should have oversight, and to review the evidence. As I said, I have no shred of doubt, but that is how a republic should work.
The second issue that is coming out is the quick disposal of the body. Apparently there are also photos of the body being put into the sea. I've already had to have a discussion with a student about the conspiracy theory that he really isn't dead and that this is some sort of political ploy. I think that's really stupid, and I understand why the body was disposed of in the way it was. To have a location that could become a pilgrimage site or shrine. At the same time, being so hasty and secretive doesn't help things. Before you know it we'll have the Birther-Truther morons have something new to jump on and spew bull shit about.
Next we have the fact that this guy wasn't in a cave, which isn't something I thought, but in a mansion in Pakistan. The problem is that he was in a town that is very busy with Pakistan military, and right close to a major military academy. So, that means they knew, or they didn't knew and were incompetent. Somehow I feel the first option is the more logical one. Someone had to know, someone had to have an idea, and someone should have said something. I'm wondering what that will mean for the future relationship with that country.
Finally, the thing that's starting to bug me is the news that he was unarmed. It's easy to sit on a couch and second guess a situation I wasn't involved in and didn't know the situation at the time it was, however at the same time I'm not entirely comfortable with how things are forming. Personally, I'd prefer him to be brought in chains and stand trial for his crimes. I believe in the rule of law, and feel that justice is best served in a court room.
Now, I'm not sad that he's dead. I'm not backing away from the feelings of relief and closure that I felt on Sunday. I've seen a lot of Facebook posts about "not rejoicing in the death of your enemy" sentiment, but I have no problem with that. The life of EVERY American was changed as a result of what this bastard did. His actions have prompted many to support policies that have worn down our civil liberties, that have brought out the terrible side of people, and not to mention the death of thousands of our fellow citizens on a sunny day in September. I have no qualms with celebrating the death of a person like that.
I think good has the right to celebrate the destruction of evil.
In addition, this is truly a point of "Mission Accomplished". I have always supported the war in Afghanistan. I supported the increase in troops to Afghanistan that the president went with. After the attacks on September 11th, we went in after this guy. He was the reason we are there, and now that he has been captured and killed, the goals have been met. Ten years of war in Afghanistan have finally been concluded, and being able to close a chapter in American history that changed all our lives is very satisfying. What does this mean for that war? It's hard to say. Part of me says it's time to come home. The goals have been met, there's nothing more we need to do. At the same time, I worry about what the power vacuum will result in. I worry about the rights of the people in that country, specifically women. At the same time, I don't think staying there another 10 years will really change anything.
We're also starting to hear the debate about torture, rendition, and things like Guantanamo Bay, however that is an issue for another blog.
So, just some thoughts I've had now that I've had a chance to think about things and we've had time to review the course of events.
No comments:
Post a Comment