Saturday, May 7, 2011

Tortuous

The other day I did a blog entry on my shifting feelings about the Osama bin Laden assassination. I'm not going to go to much into that issue again, but I will say that the more details that come out about the event and how things "went down" I'm becoming increasingly uncomfortable with it. The original story was there was a gun fight and he was killed. That seemed perfectly reasonable then that he was taken out instead of brought in. Then it was, well some people were firing, but he didn't have a gun. Still, that's probably fine because for all I know he was trying to get one and just didn't have one as he was shot. So, again that seemed reasonable but required some justification. Well now it's gotten to the point where no one in that building was armed and it looks like the order was "take him out". That is where I'm finally lost completely.

The problem is that if you take someone out while trying to bring them in, then there's some level of understanding. However, the police don't go in with the goal of killing the bad guy. If the police broke down the door of a house and killed a guy who was unarmed we wouldn't stand for it. I know the argument is that "well he's a super bad guy" and the President even said "well if you think otherwise then you should have your head examined." Well, I say my head is examining the information. The information is that we are a country of laws, not some mob that takes people out. We bring them back in chains, put them on trial, and punish accordingly. Why do we do this? We do this because we are civilized people that believe everyone goes to court so they have a chance to account for what they did, and for people to see that we are better than those who hide in the shadows planning the murder of others. After the second world war we put war criminals on trial, and we can't put one guy who killed far less people on trial?

Well, the other argument that is starting to come out with this situation is that if it weren't for torture then we never would have got him. NO! What is wrong with us? Why are we allowing this to happen. First, it's already been said that No, actually torture had nothing to do with it, and that in fact the information that was giving thanks to torture made things worse. But none of that debate is important, in fact there should be no debate. The United States DOES NOT TORTURE. Torture is illegal, we don't do illegal things. When we do things that is illegal then we should be held accountable. That is a sticky situation for the Bush administration because they did some bullshit, and the current administration has covered their asses for them and said, "we need to look forward not backwards." After a murder, or perhaps a rape, or a robbery, that those people need to look forward not backward. No, when a crime is committed we don't "look forward, not backward" because we would be insane to not work to bring criminals to justice.

For a second I thought I would say "We are better than that," but, really I have to say that we should be better than this, but perhaps we aren't. Perhaps we've lost that noble belief in government, laws, and holding all people to the same standard. Now, we just shoot them in the eye because that's easier. Perhaps the world is "a little safer", but it seems to getting a little more tyrannical. That light that served as a beacon to the world, I fear, is slowly burning out. Can we rekindle the fire, or is it too late?

No comments: