New York decided that they wanted to place an upper limit on the size of "sugary drinks" that can be sold in the city. Pretty much they decided that a 128oz (the team gulp from 7-Eleven) beverage may be a bit too large, and set a limit at 16oz. Now, 16 is actually still a lot, but it's a more reasonable size really because to give you some perspective a 128 oz cup is nearly 4 liters. A judge struck down the law, but the city is appealing it.
Honestly I didn't really care much about the ban, I don't live there and it doesn't influence me, so whatever. But as I thought about it, I don't think there's anything wrong with it. In fact I think I may support it. The sizes have gotten bigger and bigger, and I think people have forgotten what and ACTUAL reasonable size is, so bringing the sizes back to a reasonable level doesn't really seem like that big of a deal. Especially considering that these excessively large drinks are only a few buck, and any kid could afford one and not really think that they are getting more calories/sugar in that drink than they really need in like a week (clearly and exaggeration, but you get it).
Now, the "nanny staters" will say that it's your right as an American, and your freedom to buy what you want and we don't need the government telling us what to do. It's the job of the parent to tell kids what they can and can't buy. First, if you really want 128oz, you can still buy that much, you'll just have to buy 8 large sized drinks to get that much. Yes, that might make you look stupid, but you looked stupid with a 128oz cup anyway, so it's no different. Next, you aren't being told you can't buy something, in fact "you" aren't being told anything. The city is telling restaurants that they can't use the obscenely large cups. So, no one's freedoms are being taken away.
Furthermore, for those who say people will just get around it, etc. People will get around ANY law if they want. Does that mean we shouldn't have any laws? Yes, it's not actually stopping anyone from buying 8 glasses of soda instead of 1 giant glass. But perhaps the bigger win is it will reset what people think of as an acceptable size. If you give people a bigger spoon and larger plate they'll serve themselves more food. It's a subconscious thing. So if you give them a smaller plate and a smaller spoon they'll think a portion size is smaller. Give them a smaller cup and they'll think the correct size is the smaller amount. It probably will do more to reground the image of the correct size, and that will be healthy.
Finally, can we really stop diluting the idea of "freedom" to nonsense like "IT'S MY RIGHT TO BUY A TON OF SODA, STOP TAKING AWAY MY FREEDOM!" It's like calling wolf, eventually people won't realize when their actual freedom is being eroded. If you want to complain about freedom let's talk about illegal wire taps, killing US citizens with drones, the utterly only for show and doesn't really keep us safe pageantry of airport security. There are plenty of ways freedom is being encroached upon, the resizing of soda from comically large to just overly large is hardly one of them.
No comments:
Post a Comment