Thomas Jefferson to James Madison, December 20, 1787
Thomas Jefferson talks a lot about the need for people in an democracy to be informed and educated. He felt that those in power will turn badly if the people don't have the sense enough to take care of them, but the only way to make sure people had any sense was to make sure they were educated. He worked in education at the end of his life, and many discuss his views regarding education and the need to make sure citizens are educated to avoid the republic falling victim to tyranny.
During my time teaching I realized that this is very true, and nothing illustrated it more than in my unit on World War II and specifically on Executive Order 9066, which relocated U.S. citizens into concentration camps simply because they happened to be Japanese (even though the same wasn't done to German-Americans). In this unit I had a test question asking them to discuss 9066, and I was shocked to find that many agreed with the order. They thought that the imprisonment of American citizens who had done nothing wrong, there was no evidence of wrong doing, and no indication that criminal activity would happen was perfectly acceptable.
I was reminded of this earlier in the week when talking about the cannibal cop who was arrested and charged with planning to kidnap and eat someone (apparently, I haven't read much on this case, but that's the facts as I know them). Speaking with a student they questioned why this person hadn't been locked up, and why we need to wait for someone to do something bad before we lock them up. Of course I pointed out that under than argument that everyone would be in jail for thought crime. But that got me thinking, what are schools teaching? Are they reading 1984, and discussing thought crime, are they studying our founding documents, reading the words of the great thinkers?
How can a republic survive when the citizens are uneducated, and willing to give up a little freedom for a little "security", and then more freedom for more "security", when does it stop? Does it stop? Or will we all end up in chains? Sure that may be hyperbolic, but illegal wiretaps went unpunished, the Attorney General argued that "due process" is not the same as "judicial process", the government can kill its own citizens with little overview, corporations buy power, and citizens sit home and ignore their civic duties.
Is this a failure of education? A failure of families to instil values necessary to preserve a republic? A failure of the media to develop good citizens? A failure of corporations by treating each person as a potential profit source and ignoring anything but the bottom line driving citizens to desire only things and entertainment? Or perhaps it's the entire system failing.
No comments:
Post a Comment