Monday, April 15, 2013

Hyperbole

Today, as anyone who isn't living under a rock knows, there was a major incident in Boston.  It's unclear who is responsible, there's also still a lot of incomplete information out that, so we will have to wait before we get a full picture of the events.  It's really unfortunate and these events really are upsetting and terrible.  However, I'm not going to talk about the actual events, or my reaction to what is happening.  I'll give that a few days when we have a better picture of what's going on and it's not just opinions and rumors.





No, instead I'm going to rant for a few minutes on how insane we've become.  I'm not talking about the insanity of someone killing other people.  What I'm talking about is the way we react to things, the things we say about events, the coverage we watch.  More a general discussion on society in general.  You see, as I was watching the news when I got home tonight to get more detailed information on what was happening, I was really just kind of disgusted by the commentators.  Now, I wanted to get the NBC coverage with Brian Williams, who seemed to have a more stable and middle of the road discussion on it.  I kind of scoffed when he was talking about how we didn't know if this was terrorism or what, because really it sure looks like it.  But generally he was the same kind of anchor that you expect from a nightly news network.  He told what he knew, he didn't try to speculate, he didn't get overly excited but tried to stay cool and stick to the facts that he had.  This is what the country needs, and I think this is why we're all crazy.

Instead I decided to flip through the stations to see how the cable companies were handling it, so I watched a bit of MSNBC, a bit of CNN, and a bit of Fox News.  I hate that the stereotypes are true, but within seconds I heard Fox commentators and guests talking about "Arabs" and "Muslims", CNN seemed somewhat behind and not entirely sure what was going on, and MSNBC was over the top in the discussion saying things like how this was a happy day and whoever did this "stabbed at the heart of joy"  and how this was just a happy "lovefest" that was ruined.  THOSE ARE DIRECT QUOTES!  Really?  Stabbed in the heart of joy?  Can we tone it down?  Really, let's tone it down this is just absurd. 

I'm going to sound cold and heartless here, but yes people were injured, and we're at two deaths.  While this is a terrible thing that I wouldn't wish on anyone it's not the sinking of the Titanic it's not 9/11, it's not the 7/7 bombings, it's not PanAm 103, it's not the Madrid bombings, it's not Newton, it's not Columbine, it's not Virginia Tech, it's not even Aurora.  I'm not in anyway saying that it was bad, or that the pain these families are feeling is unjustified, or that it shouldn't concern people.  I'm saying the way I'm seeing it presented on the news is over the top.  We've seemed to have lost track of what things are and we blow everything up beyond the level that they should be.  This was a sick and terrible thing, absolutely.  It was designed to terrify people, absolutely.  But, do we need to exaggerate the reality of the situation?



I see these guests and commentators say things like "No one could imagine such horror."  Well, first off at least one person could, because one person thought up this scheme.  One person decided to go through with this act knowing what would happen when it was executed.  So, right from the start someone could indeed imagine such horror.  Furthermore, I'm pretty sure MANY people in the world, and in this country, could imagine such horror.  The first responders to all the incidents I cited above.  Those serving in the military during times of war, from those serving in the two wars we've been fighting the last decade, to the survivors who stormed the beaches of Normandy, they could imagine such horror.  The survivors from death camps around the world, from the holocaust, to North Korea.  The sad fact of the matter is that MANY people could imagine such horror. 

Every day people are blown away by bombers in countries like Afghanistan and Iraq, some people like pointing out that we're doing the same with our drones in these countries as well as in Pakistan.  But that doesn't mean that people here don't care just because they care about what is happening today.  I absolutely despise the tone of some of the posts I see online that say "well X people died today when a drone bombed a wedding, but no one gives a shit about that."  First, you can care about both.  Second it's always a bigger deal when it's at home happening to people you know, or at the very least you share a national identity with.  That's not even getting into the idea of dealing with countries you're at war with, which opens up a completely different conversation that maybe I'll discuss on a different blog.

The point is, we need to have a reality check.  We need to stop with the hyperbole that spews out of seemingly all news stories.  We need information, we need facts, we need that shared understanding of events, and what we don't need is the endless hours of droning that comes out of these echo chambers on cable news.  You never have to hear the opinion of someone who has a different point of view, and that's a tragedy.  And you get to hear all hype in an effort to keep viewers so cable news can sell advertising time.  The absurd becomes the norm, and we all just go along with it.  The system is broken and we're letting it happen because we're buying into it.  We're blowing things out of proportion to get ratings.  It's disingenuous and disgusting. 

Yes, this was a terrible day for people in this country who lost someone, who were injured, who were there.  We should rightly feel concerned for our fellow citizens.  We should rightly feel disgusted by whoever did this.  We should want the person(s) involved in this brought to justice.  But we should not allow empty headed hacks on television shape this into something it isn't.

No comments: