Monday, April 8, 2013

Holocaust Remembrance Day


Today is Holocaust Remembrance Day, which seems appropriate because if I were still teaching this week we would be covering the Holocaust.  As we get further and further away from World War II we are quickly losing the witnesses of these events.  Soon the people who fought the war, lost family, survived the camps will all be gone, and their voices will be left only to memory or documentary film.  As such we are also getting more detached from the events, and it's becoming more of a story for history books and less an event that people we know experienced.  This of course happens with all history, as the generations go on. 

I notice a change in the way people talk about the Holocaust, where now there is this push to point out that other groups were murdered too.  Political dissidents, gypsies, homosexuals, the mentally disabled, the handicapped or anyone else the Nazis decided were undesirable.  While I think it is important to note that just as many people were killed during this time that weren't Jews, it should be noted that these other groups were not hunted and eradicated in the same way.  They are all small slices of the pie, where as the majority of the pie was Jewish.  It's almost a subtle form of Holocaust denial to try and lessen the magnitude of the event by saying, "Yeah, but these people died too."  It's as if to say that the focus is too much on the Jewish deaths and no one acknowledges that others died too.

I'm also reminded of an interview I had at a charter school for a teaching position.  The interviewer asked me how I was going to deal with events such as the holocaust, and in a round about way asked me how I was going to teach it as an opinion.  Let that sink in.  A school administrator asked me how I was going to teach the Holocaust as an opinion not as a historic fact. I won't say where this school was, or what type of demographics populate the school, but I was shocked that I was being asked and didn't know how to even respond at first.  I believe that perhaps my answer may have kept me from getting the job, but I told them that while the justification and reasoning behind some events may be up for debate, there are somethings that are facts and can not be taught as an opinion.

Today I think it important to remember history, to remember the events, and to push back on any kind of denial even when it is subtle.  General Eisenhower at the time visited the camps so he could relay his own personal accounts, so there would be no questions about how severe and terrible the conditions were.  He then had as many people as he could visit the camps, both from nearby towns and US and Allied soldiers.  He knew that first hand accounts would be necessary to keep people from denying it later.  If you'd like to read some of the primary documents, I suggest you visit the Eisenhower Presidential Library collection found here.  There are many documents that have been scanned for you to read.  Also, visit in person or online the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum here.




No comments: