Showing posts with label Education. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Education. Show all posts

Friday, January 5, 2024

History, Where Everything Is Made Up And The Points Don't Matter

 While going through grad school we talked a lot about this idea of "can we ever really know history" because we can't generalize because there are so many different experiences. At the same time, there are also few sources for average people the further back we go, is it really representative of the past if we're getting such a small slice of information?  Some historians use creative data to try and reconstruct the past, such as looking at census or tax data.  One example was that we have this idea that everyone in the Wild West had guns, but when you look at the tax data, that doesn't pan out because states would tax guns and very few people actually were paying that tax.  Of course, there's the question of tax fraud, but then again, it does give us some kind of window to challenge what we think of the past.  However, with so much uncertainty, it left me just wondering, is it worth teaching history anymore?

If we can't be certain of anything, why bother teaching things?  If we can't generalize, even when it does tell us about the majority of experiences though not all, then what's the point of learning anything?  It ultimately seemed to align with my feelings about disruptive companies, like uber and such. I don't like it.  Sure some things might need a bit of a shake-up, but also it results in some significant losses.  For example, the taxi market might have issues, but Uber does not solve those problems, and just makes the entire industry worse for the workers.  Those Uber drivers don't have regular full-time work, like someone working for a cab company.  They don't get benefits, they don't have guaranteed wages, they don't have a company vehicle to drive. Sure, I'm certain that not every person working for a cab company is full-time with benefits, but I'm sure some people are.  There are also protections because they are an employee for a company, not a contractor where companies like Uber can just treat them like shit and it doesn't matter.  This also goes for places like AirBnB, which has the added benefit that you get all these companies and rich assholes buying up affordable houses to use at rentals making it harder for you (the average person) to buy a house.

This history disruption I think has a similar issue and criticizing the history that represents the majority of people at a time because it doesn't include everyone I think lends the idea that history is "wrong' or that is not worth learning because it's not everything. Sure, there are indeed issues with the majority view of history because it leaves a lot of people out because their sources are not there to tell us what happened.  It seems to be that such disruption that leaves people wondering if it's worth studying history at all is short-sighted and counterproductive.  As a history teacher, I want people to learn history, I think it's important (more on that in a future blog), but if people feel like it's not worth it because it's not "the whole story" then why would they bother?  If we say it's all made up, it's not complete, it's faulty, then it undermines what we have.  Alternatively, I feel the better way to discuss it is to be clear that not every story is told, but that our job as historians is to add those threads to the tapestry, that history is unfinished, and that we continue it.  We've picked the low-hanging fruit, and need to get those from the higher branches before we can say we're finished.  It's still important and it does matter, but we have to think about how we talk about it. 

Wednesday, October 6, 2021

What Happened to the Original Plot of the Movie?

I am a history teacher, so therefore it would be safe to assume that I teach history. I mean, you would think that would be the case, but really I'm not so sure. This year I was excited to make the leap to high school, and pleased that I would be teaching U.S. history as well. I really wanted to get into a public school, but that wasn't going to work out. Luckily, my company merged with a company that runs high schools, so I had the opportunity to move up. This all seemed like good news going into the summer, and my biggest worry was that the drive would be a little bit longer.

We are about to finish the fifth week of school, and the entire thing has been a huge disappointment. There are a number of reasons that this job has been a giant let down. There was a lot of chaos at the beginning where there were constant changes, poor communication on those changes, and just a general lack or preparation somewhere in the process of starting a school year.  All of those things are well over my pay grade to worry about why they happened or how to fix them, but they contributed to the massive disenchantment with my job.  

However, the biggest point of friction and dissatisfaction has been with the thing that I thought I would be doing every day, which is teaching history. In that area of my job I feel like our system is a complete failure.  The system fails students, it fails the goals of social studies education, and it fails the teachers who want to teach their subject, but the system has led to huge incentives for students to not do any work whatsoever and no incentive to worry about the content of our classes.

When I first met with my principal she told me that we used standards based grading.  This didn't worry me much because at my last job we had something that I thought was similar in that each assignment was linked to a state standard in social studies. It's a more intentional way to track progress. I knew that students had multiple opportunities to take assessments to show growth and learning. This all seemed fine and I would just have to get used to the new tech systems and adjust a little bit here or there, but a pretty minor transition.  However, that is not what I've experienced. The standards that they are being graded on are not social studies standards. For example, in the first semester they have two standards, standard one is perspective, standard two is cause and effect.  Basically, the entire class is based on being able to interpret sources, generally primary sources. Can they identify the perspective of an author. Can they identify the main idea of a source. Can they explain what a specific key word or phrase in a source means, and explain how that key word or phrase supports the author's argument or main idea.  

This is not a social studies required standard. I could do this with Harry Potter. I could do it with a comic book. I could do it with the script to the Karate Kid.  In our instances, we are using speeches generally, but the point is, this skill does not require any real history do learn to do these things. Sure, we're using historical documents, but it doesn't need to be that.

Now, this isn't necessarily the worst activity to teach students. In fact, I've been doing variations on this for years. Reading and interpreting primary sources is important, and a skill to practice.  So, if that's the case why are you crying like that person who wanted everyone to leave Brittney alone?

Well, here's the first problem, reading and interpreting primary sources is REALLY HARD. It's also not every fun. We are reading things from two hundred years ago, and teenagers generally really struggle trying to understand what they are saying, much less being able to figure out their main idea.  Does this mean they shouldn't do it? No. Like I said, I've been doing it for years.  However, the problem is that the entire class revolves around this. This is what they are being graded on the entire semester. This is the skill they are trying to practice every day.  This is the central activity, and the history becomes secondary to all of that.

This brings us to the second problem.  In order to be able to do all of the analyzing of these sources, you must know the context.  Ok, so that means you must teach the history in order for them to understand the documents. So I see how this plan can work. You create a skill to repeatedly test, you teach the context, then they perform the skill.  In theory, this could work. However, the way things are set up 80% of their grade is based on doing the skill, 10% of the grade is "moral focus" which is their participation in the class.  The last 10% is on the content. There is no real immediate incentive to actually learn the material, to learn the history. If you think you can do the skill, there's no need to do the work, no need to do really participate too much because 80% is enough for most people to be happy with their grade.  Further more, no assignments get grades, it's all just feedback. You grade it, but it doesn't affect their grade at all, except perhaps their moral focus participation grade. Further, those moral focus grades come later, it's a long term planning thing, and I'm not sure if you were away, but teenagers aren't the best with long term planning. In fact, we've been told that multiple times in our summer PD sessions that the brain of a teenager is not fully developed to be able to judge those type of things and plan that far ahead, yaddayaddayadd. Yet, we have a system where students have to think about the long term implications of not doing their work and how that will effect them in January when the semester is over?  This is lunacy.

We've created an entire system where there is no incentive to bother learning any history as long as you can identify perspective, or the main idea of a document.  If that's the case, why are we hiring any social studies teachers at all? This is a literature/reading skill. An English teacher would just as easily be able to do this. Yet, it seems to me giving the world and the way that our society has no idea about anything historical or civics related, that the teaching of history and social studies is more vital now than any time in living history. Meanwhile, every day I have to try to overcome the massive incentives students have to not bother worrying about my class or the content I'm trying to teach them. The content is secondary, the consequences are months int he future. 

I try to remember that I'm not in a public school, where nonsense like this isn't the standard. However, I feel more and more like schools are actually failing. Not because they can't do the job, but because they are choosing to do absurd things like this.

Saturday, January 26, 2019

Burn Out

In 2015 I started my grad program. At the time I didn't think that I was ever going to get a teaching job, so I though that I could get my MA and then teaching at a community college. That was the plan when I signed up, and then after the first week in the program I ended up getting a long term sub position, which took me to another long term sub position, which then took me to a full time permanent teaching job. I've been teaching ever since, and I'm much happier than I was. I like my job, despite some annoying features and requirements that are just kind of absurd and over the top, such as standardized test (and not like state standardized test, these are unique to my school system).

However, all through that I've been continuing my MA program, because after the first semester who knew if the sub thing would lead to anything, so I still needed to continue what I was doing.  As I've mentioned before I've now come to the end of my program, and had the decision on if I should go the thesis or the exam route. I ultimately decided that the exam route probably made the most sense, though it has been excessively annoying to the point that I have questioned my choice. As I mentioned previously I have to have 45 books read by April so that I can take the exam. I wonder if it's really necessary or if it's just a procedural for show kind of a thing. Though I have heard some people have had to take the text more than once. Since Tuesday I have finished two books, which is a lot, but also. not as much as I need to keep on target. I'm reading the books I haven't first, and leaving the books I've read for class as the last section of reading since I have already covered them and will just need to have a refresher, which means I should be able to go through them more quickly.

That being said, I think I've reached burn out. I don't really want to do it anymore. I'm sick of school. I'm sick of always being chained to a book. I'm tired of not being able to do normal things on weekends. I'm tired of doing basically nothing except school work. That makes it really hard to slog through some of these books. I literally spent the entire day today reading. I walked on the treadmill reading for three hours. I mean, that's great for my health goals, but also I don't love it. The thought of reading more just makes me groan, and I'm only 2 of 45 books done. I've got something like 63 days left, so to stay on track I need to read four books a week, which as of right now I"m on track to do, however I know in my next set of 5 books two of them are 800 page monsters (though I have read one and I'm just going to skim that one as a reminder).

I just want to be done with all of this so that I can be somewhat of a normal human again.

Health Challenge Tracking
AHA Recommended Sugar: 55g
Week Before Start of Challenge: 114.8g
Goal By End Of Challenge: 86.1g
Daily Average Week To Date: 103.5g

Picture(s) of the Day: 
Picture 26
Sal has been touchy about her leg all day, but apparently seeing the Target dog made her forget all of her pain. She loves that freaking thing. I probably could make book of just pictures with her and the dog.

Monday, January 14, 2019

Strike That!

Today for the first time in 30 years the teachers of the Los Angeles school district went on strike. Tens of thousands of teachers walked out in protest of privatization, over teacher pay, and over additional staff.  One thing that's remarkable about this is that most states don't allow teachers to strike, which is absurd that they are not afforded the right to collectively protest. However there are only 12 states in the country that allow teachers to strike, and California is one of them.  The police estimate that 20,000 teachers and supporters marched on city hall and then on the unified school district offices. While this is all going on the school district is saying open but I can't imagine how that is going to work with that many teachers on strike, and the district announced that only around half of the students attended school today.

One of the big issues that is in focus is that California ranks near the bottom of the country in per pupil funding, bet it currently is sitting on a surplus of $9 billion. When the state has this much money, it doesn't make sense that class sizes have grown to 42 students per classroom.  That is an impossibly large classroom, and with classes that size it becomes impossible to actually provide helpful feedback to students. Even when class sizes are close to 30 it is still far too large to provide any helpful feedback. Just the management and time that it would take in order to process work makes for a terrible condition for the teachers and the students.

It's nothing new to see the struggle that teachers have to deal with, or the conditions of schools where we don't provide the resources that they need.  Students deserve better.  They deserve teachers that are paid appropriately for the work and effort that they give that is well beyond their pay.  They deserve teachers who have enough time to actually plan, grade, and provide feedback with students without having to spend hours at home getting it done.  Students deserve to have schools with enough librarians, nurses, and resources so that they can be in an environment that fosters learning.  Yet, we as a country do not value education, we try to treat it like a business where we try to cut every corner with a focus on the bottom line, as if we are trying to make a profit rather than educate students.  Education is not a for profit enterprise, and when we treat it like it is we end up with poor outcomes.  We end up saying that we can't afford books, or technology, or we see our class sizes balloon to 42.

Teachers are overworked, they are underpaid, they are not respected.  Our schools are rundown, they lack the resources they need, and they are treated as competing corporations with ideas like "school of choice."  We give parents the right to take their students to a better school through ideas like "school of choice" rather than making sure EVERY school is good enough that parents don't need to find something better.  We create charter schools to help this happen, taking much needed funds to schools already are lacking.  We pass law after law about teacher accountability, insisting that we have the most "highly qualified" teachers, but then we turn around and we don't give them what they need to be successful. We give teachers the constant task of proving that they are qualified to teach, but when do we actually give them time to be effective teachers? We give them 40 minutes, or maybe 45, maybe 70 minutes of prep every day, but then fill those times with staff meetings, IEP meetings, paperwork to prove we've done our job, and then maybe there's some left over time we might get to do a little planning.  If we want to improve test scores, we need to make sure we are providing the solid foundation through teachers who have time, through schools that have every resource they need be it books, libraries, technology, or school nurses.

As we watch this strike unfold, and we see these teachers demand better for themselves, so that they can be better for their students. We need to support these teachers, we need to support our kids, and we need to make sure that every kid has a school so good that they don't need another choice.

I stand with those Los Angles teachers, I stand for all educators and students, and I know we can do better.

Picture(s) of the Day: 
Picture 14
A while back while trying to get my head around how much stuff I had to do I jotted down this quick list of all the things that I had to get done because they were past due and late. It's really an absurd list, and it illustrates the issue that teachers don't have enough planning time to get done all the work that they have to.  This is why teachers work 12 hour days or more, and this is just the "must have" list, not the "it would be nice" list.

Wednesday, January 24, 2018

We Have Flat Earth Society Members Around The Globe

Ok, America, we need to get it together. Like, seriously, this isn't funny and we need to stop. There has been a very obvious attack on science and knowledge over the years, mostly due to the issue of climate change, that those in power want to stop us doing something about because it will lose them money. It's not new, the church also wants to chime in on such things because science often pokes holes in the mythology. Well, it's gone too far because we now have a uptick in the flat earth society. Now, I thought this was just an internet thing that gets you wound up because how can people be so stupid. Well a while back some basketball player decided to tweet a bunch of nonsense about how the earth is flat, which was brought to a large audience. I mean, if we can't trust a man who makes a living by throwing a little ball into a little hoop, what kind of future do we have right?

In the end I thought this was something that no one really believed, and then I had multiple students inform me that the Earth was flat. They repeated all the nonsense that the basketball player said, and earnestly believed it. How does one respond to that, because I don't suffer fools gladly. We can't question things so basic, and the fact that so many people believe this level of nonsense is really astonishing. Why in the world should I be defending the idea that the Earth is round to students that are months away from being in high school? Further, if the Earth is flat, why is it that no one has found the edge, what's on the other side of it, and how is it that you can go around the world in a ship or a plane? I really can't deal with this. The internet is making us all stupid.

I know ultimately that this is a small and localized kind of a thing, but the fact that it's wide enough that I have multiple students who believe this is enough to make it seem huge.  Perhaps we've gone too far on the anti-bullying message that such fools haven't been ostracized enough to feel shame in their utter incompetence. I kid of course, but then again...

Picture(s) of the Day: 
Picture 24
The hope of the future, a child who loves books, libraries, and hopefully knowledge. Let's hope that we don't have to convince her that the Earth is round.

Thursday, May 26, 2016

Once More Unto The Breach, Dear Friends

Being back at the school I'm at really highlights the philosophy and standards that are in public schools.  This is especially true when it comes to lunch room behavior.  I've talked about that extensively so I won't go over it again, but basically it's like a jungle of wild human, yelling, screaming, and just being rude and disrespectful.  It's amazing that this week is not even done yet and I feel like I've been back at this school for ages, and perhaps that I never even left it.  I don't mean that in a good way, it's a draining sort of thing that makes the days seem longer.  I think there are 14 days left for me there, and anyone can survive something for two weeks.

The problem is less that I'm back in the environment and more that it just pisses me off that this is what our schools are like.  It makes me want to start a new school that isn't like some institutional jail but more like a temple to learning.  Where it's treated not like some budget line item that should be as low as possible, but as a physical symbol to the commitment to education that we have.  The problem, of course, is that this would be very expensive and I don't have that kind of money.  Plus you add in the issue of public schools being forced into testing, which in turn leads to focusing heavily on those testing subjects. That leave private schools, which excludes those that don't pay.  There is no good solution here.  I feel like something needs to be done rather than the nonsense that's been happening since W. passed No Child Left Behind.

My time here has me becoming more and more fired up.

Picture(s) of the Day:
Picture 145
In one of the local gardening shops they had a big garbage can full of this.  So clearly someone cares. Good job, Jimmy.

Tuesday, May 17, 2016

Where To Invade Next

Apparently something weird has happened to our Netflix queue because we ended up getting Where to Invade Next, which is the latest documentary by Michael Moore.  This was on our list but I didn't think it was so high up.  At the same time I didn't think that it was out on DVD yet as I thought it was still in theaters.  Either way we got it, and ended it watching it recently.  It was not what I was expecting.  With the title I really thought that it was going to have to do with the military and war and all that sort of things.  However, the premise of the film isn't about war or the military at all, but rather than invading and occupying countries perhaps we should be "invading" them and using their ideas that seem to be working pretty well for them.

Basically Michael Moore went around to countries like Italy to talk about vacation time, France to talk about school lunches, Scandinavia to talk about education and so on.  From these conversations he highlights some of the excellent programs these countries have and ideas that the United States could take notice of and emulate.

The result of this movie was that I ended up furious, and the biggest thing that hit me was when they looked at education and specifically school lunches.  To see the comparison on what students in France eat with what students in the United States eat is disgusting.  It highlights this absurd mass produced assembly line cog system that we have in education.  The fact that French schools have a chef who prepares fresh meals and we have people who reheat prepackaged slop is outrageous.  This really underscores how little we care about our schools and how little we fund them.  I mean, I work in a good schools, with good parens, good teachers, good students, and they still eat things that I wouldn't categorize as food.

At the same time it is lightyears beyond the literal slop that I saw when I was at a public school earlier in the year.  There were days that I would ask students walking past me with their trays what lunch was and their response was, "I don't know" and then to kind of show me what they had.  Some sort of nugget formed something.  Is that really the best we can do?  Is that the level of quality that we find acceptable for our children?  What's worse, the French spend less per student per meal and they're having meals that would put to shame any mainstream chain restaurant.  The food I saw in this documentary looked more like something I'd get on one of the Main Street eateries like Gratzi or Brew Co., or other similar somewhat swanky places.

I ended the movie just steamed about our education system, and at the same time feeling helpless to change it.  What the fuck is wrong with us as a nation?  Why do we stand for this?  Schools are indeed failing, but not because of teachers, because we are letting them fail.  We are failing to see these students as people and investing in them.  We want to cut funding, cut costs, and slash our way rather than paying what we should be paying to ensure our students have a good school, the books and technology they need, and food.  Yet, the local district here spends $500,000 a year on the sports budget why they can't pay for books, where they lay off teachers, and where they take away teacher prep hours and cut their pay because they can't make ends meet all because they need to keep programs otherwise students will go to charters or school of choice options thus losing the district even more money.

This is bullshit and I'm pissed.

Picture(s) of the Day:
Picture 136
Sometimes I get pictures sent to me throughout the day, and this is one that I got today.  It looks like she's making a shopping list or something.  What a little cutie.

Thursday, January 21, 2016

Failed Schools

Related to yesterday’s post, in the news recently has been the situation going on in Detroit Public Schools.  For those who don’t know what’s going on a brief summary is that the school system has been in shambles for quite some time.  There is very little money, there have been numerous schools closed and consolidated as the city has experienced severe population decreases which only compounds the issues as it removes tax revenues and creates this downward economic spiral.  The schools have for a long time been in a bad state.  Even ten years ago I toured and worked in schools for my teaching certification where I saw buildings far from being in tip-top shape. 

Well, recently the teachers have been calling in sick in mass numbers, in what is being called a sick out, to draw attention to the terrible conditions (which I have included pictures of).  The response has been that some politicians have thrown a fit because it’s illegal for teachers to strike, and they are calling this a strike.  However, that’s missing the point that these schools are literally falling apart.  The buildings are in ruins and look like something more out of a war zone or a post-apocalyptic setting than a major U.S. city. 

A local leader (I believe it was the mayor of Detroit, but I can’t find the quote so I’m leaving this disclaimer) basically said in a press conference that lack of funds can’t be an excuse for this sort of thing.  However, it seems to me lack of funds is exactly what led to this and will always lead to this because there is no money to allocate to the kind of maintenance and upkeep needed for these buildings.  We’ve been shortchanging our education system (especially in areas where minorities are the majority like Detroit Public Schools), for years and can’t be surprised when this happens.

Further, we need to support the teachers in their actions to raise awareness, not criticize them.  The reason they have been pushed to this action is because the issues have gone ignored.  The people in these buildings are doing all they can with little support, and so it’s time to raise the discussion.  Thankfully they have shown exactly what is happening in these schools and shining a light on the issue.  These issues need to be addressed and solved.  People aren’t going to continue to allow this sort of thing forever, and eventually they get angry and take further action.  We should know that, as we are a nation born out of revolution and are taught the virtues petitioning our government regarding grievances and taking action.  Clearly we need to be doing better.

Picture(s) of the Day:
Picture 21
Got lunch with Becky and Sal the other day and she thought it was the greatest that she got to play with some crayons.  She also kept waving at the older gentlemen at the table across the way becuase they weren't paying attention to her.  She tends to wave at people when they aren't looking, almost like "hey, look at me!"

Wednesday, January 20, 2016

Failing Schools?

 My current job brings me to yet another school district, which means I’ve been in most of the schools around the county and see a large array of systems and levels.  From some of the most affluent schools in the area, to some of the poorest, from public schools to charter schools, I’ve seen a lot of what’s going on in the area, and in schools in general.  I’ve been in music classrooms, I’ve seen the theatre productions that schools put on, I’ve been in cafeterias and gymnasiums, I’ve taught everything from Spanish, to history, to computers. I’ve seen rich students, poor students, forgotten students, struggling students, excelling students, diverse students, sheltered students, and everything else you could think of.

Often times it’s impossible to hear about schools without hearing someone pipe in with “schools are failing our kids” and a ranting on teachers unions, low test scores, and the like.  I’ve often held that schools as a whole aren’t failing, but agreed that there are some schools that are.  I’ve generally maintained that the problem isn’t teachers and that they are out there day in and day out giving it their all.  At the same time I agree there are teachers out there who have no business in the field.  Many I’ve seen first hand as they call their students “dead behind the eyes,” “losers,” or watch as they sit behind their desk reading from notes that look to be 20 years old lacking all engagement with the students or the material.  Clearly teachers like this are failing, they count down the days to the weekend, the next break, and the summer vacation. They do as little as possible and resist all change.  However, this group in most schools is a stark minority. 

Overall, I will reject the idea that the school system if failing.  I will acknowledge the weaknesses and I will agree with efforts to change it for the better that make sense.  However, my time, and specifically when looking at my most recent assignment in contrast to my last assignment tells me that perhaps the schools are failing in a different way that aren’t graded on a test and aren’t readily available for inspection from the public. Perhaps even some of these areas are causing issues that spill over into other classrooms and maybe is part of the reason so many young people seem so stressed out, burned out, and just plain exhausted.

The first area to look at where I’ve seen some stark contrasts is the area of teaching students to be decent, respectful, and responsible students.  I think this is most evident at times where students are less regulated, and something I’ve seen in the cafeteria.  The students fool around and are loud and somewhat obnoxious, however that’s to be expected and not what I’m talking about.  The issue I have is their behavior in regards to just leaving their trash, not respecting their facility, dumping food and just leaving it.  There is no level of responsibility and respect for their facilities or for the people who maintain them.  In contrast, my last position the behavior would not be tolerated, and students are responsible for cleaning their areas and following specific procedures.

Part of that are clearly the expectations of the environment.  From what I can tell the goal is simply to make it through the 30 minute period and then move on.  The adults expect and accept the behavior and don’t try to fight against it and improve it.  So in that sense these adults are failing at teaching these students that their mess doesn’t magically disappear, in fact even in Harry Potter a house elf had to do the cleaning.  However, we see this in the adult world too where people just throw their trash on the side of the road (it’s the worst at the end of winter when the snow melts leaving a field of trash everywhere). There is a total lack of ownership of our areas and acceptance that we are all responsible for it and need to respect it and keep it clean.  I’ve often hear people talk about other areas and I believe Japan is given as an example where the students are responsible for the janitorial duties in the school because it’s their school, their mess, and therefore their responsibility.  The adults expect them to do this and there is a sense of responsibility and respect that they are trying to instill on their youth.  It seems to me schools could do better by following that model and focus on these non-academic areas despite the extra organization that it would require.

Related to this idea of “non-academic” learning, perhaps is also an issue that many teachers may see in their classrooms related to student behavior.  By this I mean in many schools there are very few offerings other than the required “core” subjects that test scores monitor.  Schools more and more are moving to block schedules where instead of 45 minutes to an hour classes are now an hour and half, and the day is filled with academic work in language arts, science, math, social studies, and foreign languages.  There may be a short elective in there for music, art, or the required physical education or health class.  However, the day is packed with heavy classes and the day is devoid of something to break up these huge blocks.  There’s not a class where you can just go into a kitchen and learn to cook, or an hour of physical activity to help clear your mind.  Art can be taken, but if you have only a few options for electives you have to choose between that and perhaps choir, or band. 

These ‘soft’ courses develop very important skills, as evident from so many young people who have no idea how to cook, have never used a tool, or who become adults and realize they have no idea about how to pay taxes, open a bank account, or do many of the things that the adult world requires.  Students need to learn about these areas, but they also need a break from the heavy academic loads.  Sure, these classes are graded, however there is very little pressure and are a chance for students to slow down for a period.  Additionally, perhaps it would help students to calm down in other classes and focus more on their content because it’s not one high demand and perhaps “boring” class after another.  I know when I’m only working and doing schoolwork I get burned out and need time to do something that I actually like to do, however all too often the options are severely limited and the time allotted to those limited choices are equally limited.

A large portion of that comes down to the issue with funding.  Sure, we’ve allocated far more time to the “core” subjects, and we’ve added test upon test to ensure these core subjects are being learned, however at the same time we’ve also been cutting from the other end by eliminating funding.  In many schools the buildings are barely maintained, art teachers are buying their own supplies, and music, theatre, and other classes are constantly fundraising to ensure they have the materials they need.  So, imagine having to actually maintain a home economics classroom like the one I had, filled with sewing machines, as well as five fully functional kitchens.  Or imagine stocking, servicing, and maintaining a fully functional wood and metal shop for students to work in.  What’s further, each of those classes require an additional teacher that the school would have to pay.  We barely fund schools as it is, teacher pay is low, and to offer these types of classes would cost even more money.  The simple fact is we don’t fund schools accordingly, but then complain that they are failing.

This funding issue also cuts in to the experiences and enrichment opportunities offered at schools.  How often to students go on field trips anymore?  The districts are reluctant to pay for the bus services and clubs or teachers are left trying to fundraise to make it happen.  However, this puts more work on teachers who are already working sometimes 10-12 hour days or even longer.  Plus, a field trip takes students away for those other important classes putting those students behind and leading to more work to catch up (and students are already perhaps overloaded on homework).  In the end, these pressures create a lot of disincentives to arrange these types of experiences, especially in the upper levels.

Overloaded teachers bring about another issues that many teachers understand, and that is the massive amounts of work and the few resources and time that they are given.  Where I’m at now I work as a resources, for example if a teacher needs help grading, or wants a grade analysis they call me and I take care of it for them freeing up time for them to plan, meet with students, communicate with teachers or anything else they may need to get done.  Teachers need more resources and assistance to allow them to focus on other activities.  In any other industry people at this level have administrative assistance to delegate work like that to.  Why is a teacher spending time at a copier and collating, stapling, and organizing papers?  Is that the best use of their time?  In this day and age is there really no good resources to help analyze grades, or provide statistical information on how students are doing?  Quite often it seems very piecemeal and some teachers have resources but they have to share it and then other teachers have to understand how to use it, which sometimes seems problematic. 

The final area has to do with what is offered to students, and this specifically came to mind as I was in the lunch room the other day and watched the students walk past with their “food” that most ended up throwing most of it in the trash.  To call it food is probably a stretch and perhaps would subject you to investigation for false advertising.  I’m not saying that all food needs to be gourmet, and we don’t need a Wolfgang Puck or Emeril in every school kitchen, however, how about some actual food.  There are times where students walk past and I’m not even sure what the food on their plate is.  In fact I made the mistake and said something like “Oh, chicken nugget day, eh?” only to find that it wasn’t chicken nuggets at all.  The same is true of our classrooms where I see outdated or destroyed books, computers that are laughably old, equipment for gym class or art class that is broken, or situations where there are not enough to get students the materials we need. 


As a society there is no reason that with our economy and our values that we should have schools systems anywhere in the country that are like this.  We expound on the greatness of America and pat ourselves on the back for our own superiority while schools around the country scream at our hypocrisy.  We act as if education should be treated as shopping at a value discount store where we settle for 50 pounds of no-name near expired mayonnaise because the price is right.  I’m all for efficiency and doing what we can at a reasonable price, but we don’t treat other budgets that way because we see the need.  We can’t get out of this through a business model where we cut and cut to achieve profits (though education is not a profit industry, but the idea is the same where we want to devote as little money as possible to it).  We can do better than that, and are negligent if we don’t.

Picture(s) of the Day:
Picture 20
It was very difficult to get a picture of her because she kept trying to get the phone or just wasn't interested in doing what I wanted.  But, here we have Sal wearing her Keely shirt.

Wednesday, August 5, 2015

Don't Stay In School?

Today I saw a video called "Don't Stay in School" buy Boyinaband, at first I heard the title and thought, "Oh jeez, what is this idiot going to have to say?" However, once you watch it you see it's not about dropping out of school, but rather a critique of the school system in general.  Reading up a bit I found that there was a hope that things like this would open up the discussion about what is taught in schools and to a lesser extent the discussion on how the focus on testing had caused damage because it means there isn't a focus on other things.

Basically, for those who don't want to Google the video and watch it (though it's worth a watch I suppose), the artist goes on a bit of a rant about all the things he learned in school, and more importantly all the things that he didn't learn in schools.  For example he says, "I wasn’t taught how to get a job. But I can remember dissecting a frog." or “I was never taught the laws for the country I live in; but I know how Henry VIII killed his women.”  Basically his thesis on the matter is "Don’t Stay in School’ isn’t inferring students shouldn’t stay in school, it’s saying topics which aren’t practically useful shouldn’t stay in school."

At first I was grossed out by the title of the video, but then I was like "ok, yeah I can see a point here" however as I've thought about it more, I am swinging back around to the idea that this guy is a moron.  Basically, this goes down the path of thought that is turning education into a commodity rather than an expansion of your mind and understanding of the universe, and I don't agree with that.  The idea that school has the goal of getting you a job is true to an extent.  You must be able to think, speak, understand, but the sole purpose of school is not to get you a job, it's to get you an education.  That education will help you get a job, but if we boil down schools to being only about getting a job then what is the point of anything anymore? 

I've heard this argument a lot before and have blogged about it in the past.  From family members and friends who say things like "why do you have to learn algebra if you're never going to use it" or younger friend posting things about how "stupid school is because it doesn't teach you anything important."  It really grinds my gears because this kind of thinking is why we are getting into this nonsense testing mentality.  It's why everything is focuses on the "useful" subjects and everything else is ignored, cut, and reduced because it's not as important.  So, keep that up and then you end up with an education system that creates little drones that only know what it takes to get a job.

Further, some of the arguments in here that the artist claims that schools should be teaching such as how to get a job, how to understand stocks, how a mortgage works, etc. I have to questions because why is that the job of a school?  Now some of these get close to economics, a subject that I can teach and would enjoy teaching. But on a broader level, why is that something that a school should teach.  Should the more practical subjects like getting a bank account, paying bills, etc. be lessons that are learned in the home and taught by the parents?  Or if it isn't taught that way, isn't it something that people can learn themselves?  Do I need to take a class in high school to understand what a mortgage is and how it works?  Isn't that something I can research when the time comes?  Isn't that pretty much what people have always done?  In this day and age the internet is a wonderful source for those day to day items that parents should be teaching, or people should be seeking out if it's something they need to learn.  Those are situations that people learn through experience.  I fully support the idea of having an elective available for those who wish to learn them, or feel they need it, however is that the point of schools? 


Better, is this really even something that you can teach through schools?  You can simulate a "family budget" but it's not the same.  It's play money with no consequences.  There is no motivation other than to get the grade, so it will not be the same when you have few options and need to find a way to figure it out.  This is something I've run into a lot working with teenagers.  Try to get them to think long term and plan ahead.  It's an uphill battle and something that they will learn very quickly when the real world gets in their face and they actually have to start thinking about it.  Look at things like 401K or Health Insurance.  Part of the reason the mandate worked was because it forced young people to get insurance, otherwise they "think they're invincible and don't need it" because it's not something that they face, it's something they can ignore.  So, I could set up lessons, but until you have to figure out how to pay your bills, feed yourself, balance your work/school/social schedules, then you are not going to see real learning.

That being said, I think there should be a larger emphasis on economics and civics.  These subject (if they are taught at all) are short little half a year sort of courses, and really to produce a good citizen they should be more regular.  Perhaps not even a full hour course, but something that is touched upon every single day, so it's in their face every day and something that they have to deal with.

Anyhow, something I saw today and it's now turned into a little rant.  Feel free to comment and continue the discussion.

Picture(s) of the Day:
Picture 216
A few seconds later she was quite interested in the fake flowers sitting next to this chair in Pier 1. She's getting quite good at sitting up and balancing.


Thursday, June 11, 2015

Grad School

Well, I just got an e-mail telling me that I've been accepted into the grad school program I applied to.  It was very quick, and I thought it would take a bit longer, at the very least a week or more.  Though, I imagine that since I did my undergrad there they are keen to keep me and plus they already have all my academic information.  So, there you have it, been accepted.  Should this count as a new experience?  Perhaps I'll just broadly say that I became a graduate student, since that covers a variety of experiences I will have this year with starting classes.

The program is only expected to take a few years, depending on how many classes I take, etc.  I should be done by 2017, which on the one hand seem so far away, but then again on the other hand is not that far.  There are a few travel classes that I would love to do, though I'm not sure if it'll work out.  Being gone for a week I don't think would be easy, especially since I have a cute little baby that I'd hate to leave.  At the same time, it'd be really cool to learn the history of a location from an expert while at that location.  Would be pretty cool.

Anyhow, at least I'm working toward something.  I'm not sure it will bring many job prospects, but I think it's something that I'd like to have regardless.  I'm also considering down the line after that and perhaps getting a Ph.D. so I can teach at a university.  I'll have to start looking for jackets with patches.

Picture(s) of the Day:
Picture 162
A coworker went to Hawaii recently for vacation and brought me back a thing of coffee.  I don't drink coffee, but it was the thought that counts.  I gave it to Jasmine, so it will still be put to good use.  It's nice when some people appreciate the work you do for them and acknowledge it, in this case in the form of coffee.

Tuesday, November 18, 2014

Fight The System

I follow an education blog, and this week they reported on an interesting turn of events in Colorado where students organized a protest and opted out of the state standardized test.  Out of the over 500 students at the school only seven ended up taking the test.  The test has no stake for the student and is just something the school uses like so many other standardized test.  So they decided to not only opt out but to fight for what they actually believe in.  They weren't just fighting against something, but they are fighting for something.

They cite that the text is worthless to their personal lives at a time when they have to worry about college applications and SATs, they cite that the test doesn't align with their curriculum and that they are tested on things they haven't learned, or on things that were learned years ago and that they haven't really used since.  One of the most powerful arguments, in my opinion, was that they felt that at a time when subjects like the arts are being cut, class sizes are growing, and resources shrinking, it's irresponsible to be using that money for testing that could be used to actually improve schools.

I'm really impressed by this, and I hope to see this kind of thing grow.  The testing craze is out of control and I think people are starting to rise up.  I also like that students are standing up and taking control of their education.  They are losing education time to these tests and if the outcomes aren't useful then it's wasted time.  I'm glad to see some level of resistance and questioning of the status quo, especially from young people who participate far less than any other group in our society.

Picture(s) of the Day:
Picture 339
Today's picture is simply somewhere I'd rather be because it's freaking freezing outside.  It was about 19 degrees when I got dropped off at class.  That's way too cold for the middle of November.  I thought I was going to freeze to death walking the dogs.  Screw that.

Wednesday, October 22, 2014

Who Pays For College

I guess I'm going to continue my series on college and discuss my thoughts on who should pay for college.  Yesterday I did a blog about the high cost of loans and how that is a barrier to opportunity for those that don't come from means.  I said yesterday I wasn't even saying that I thought college should be free, but that it was too expensive.  However today's argument I'm going to say from the start that a college education should be free.

Individually there are a lot of benefits to a college education, however an educated society has a lot of wonderful benefits for a nation on the whole, and therefore investing in education is not only good for individuals but good for us all.  You also tend to get more participation in civic matters with a higher educated populace, so that is another push that I think makes it a wise investment.  It would cost a fraction of the amount we currently spend on other things in this country to fully bankroll education.  A recent article said that rather than the piecemeal programs we currently have, if we eliminated all of them and instead put the money toward just paying outright for college we'd be able to just cover the costs outright.  Rather than subsidies, and grants, and scholarships that we currently offer through the various agencies and programs we could just cut them and then re-purpose the money to cover the costs.  First, that's insane, second why are we not doing that?

Education is good for individuals, good for society, and it makes sense to do it.   In my recent "debate" the nut who was saying that not everyone should go to college also said that "if the government starts paying out right I don't trust them to choose who pays and who doesn't and don't want them making that choice for my family."  Other than being nonsensical since if the government is paying then there would be no paying from the individual, it also is illogical as no one dreams of making the same argument about public elementary and secondary education.  They are provided and the only people who pay are those that elect to go to a private school. 

The fact is that the cost of education is a weight on those that have to use credit to get an education.  Student Loan Debt is now the second largest debt in the country.  Imagine the jump start to the economy there would be if millions of people no longer were spending hundreds of dollars a month on their education and could spend it on other things.  Personally, I could use a new car, but I spend twice as much a month on my student loans as I did on my last car payment.  I'd love to travel more and have over two weeks saved of vacation time,  but between my wife and I we spend as much in two months as it costs to go on a week long cruise.  Not to mention that for many rather than a mortgage payment they have to live with parents and spend the equivalent on their student loans.

We should be investing in the future by giving anyone who wants an education, an education that doesn't stunt their economic futures for a decade or more.  We should be sending anyone who wants an education to college so they can get out there and become entrepreneurs, doctors, teachers, engineers, the next great inventor, not someone who is living in a basement unable to take chances because they have to pay a student loan.  A free education is good for people, and good for the country and we need to wake up and stop passing the costs on to students and start investing in things that will improve the lives of everyone.

Picture(s) of the Day:
Picture 313
While out on my walk I saw this very yellow tree with the sun shining right behind it and thought it was lovely.