Showing posts with label History. Show all posts
Showing posts with label History. Show all posts

Friday, January 5, 2024

History, Where Everything Is Made Up And The Points Don't Matter

 While going through grad school we talked a lot about this idea of "can we ever really know history" because we can't generalize because there are so many different experiences. At the same time, there are also few sources for average people the further back we go, is it really representative of the past if we're getting such a small slice of information?  Some historians use creative data to try and reconstruct the past, such as looking at census or tax data.  One example was that we have this idea that everyone in the Wild West had guns, but when you look at the tax data, that doesn't pan out because states would tax guns and very few people actually were paying that tax.  Of course, there's the question of tax fraud, but then again, it does give us some kind of window to challenge what we think of the past.  However, with so much uncertainty, it left me just wondering, is it worth teaching history anymore?

If we can't be certain of anything, why bother teaching things?  If we can't generalize, even when it does tell us about the majority of experiences though not all, then what's the point of learning anything?  It ultimately seemed to align with my feelings about disruptive companies, like uber and such. I don't like it.  Sure some things might need a bit of a shake-up, but also it results in some significant losses.  For example, the taxi market might have issues, but Uber does not solve those problems, and just makes the entire industry worse for the workers.  Those Uber drivers don't have regular full-time work, like someone working for a cab company.  They don't get benefits, they don't have guaranteed wages, they don't have a company vehicle to drive. Sure, I'm certain that not every person working for a cab company is full-time with benefits, but I'm sure some people are.  There are also protections because they are an employee for a company, not a contractor where companies like Uber can just treat them like shit and it doesn't matter.  This also goes for places like AirBnB, which has the added benefit that you get all these companies and rich assholes buying up affordable houses to use at rentals making it harder for you (the average person) to buy a house.

This history disruption I think has a similar issue and criticizing the history that represents the majority of people at a time because it doesn't include everyone I think lends the idea that history is "wrong' or that is not worth learning because it's not everything. Sure, there are indeed issues with the majority view of history because it leaves a lot of people out because their sources are not there to tell us what happened.  It seems to be that such disruption that leaves people wondering if it's worth studying history at all is short-sighted and counterproductive.  As a history teacher, I want people to learn history, I think it's important (more on that in a future blog), but if people feel like it's not worth it because it's not "the whole story" then why would they bother?  If we say it's all made up, it's not complete, it's faulty, then it undermines what we have.  Alternatively, I feel the better way to discuss it is to be clear that not every story is told, but that our job as historians is to add those threads to the tapestry, that history is unfinished, and that we continue it.  We've picked the low-hanging fruit, and need to get those from the higher branches before we can say we're finished.  It's still important and it does matter, but we have to think about how we talk about it. 

Wednesday, November 3, 2021

It's Really Not The Nazis

 So, as a historian, here is a pro-tip: if it's not the Nazis (like it's not literally fascist Nazis) then put away the swastikas and stop comparing everything to the Nazis.  It's not the Nazis.

Mask mandates are not the Nazis.

Vaccine mandates are not the Nazis.

Socialism is not the Nazis (it's also not socialism - and Nazis are also not socialist).

Healthcare is not Nazis.

Democrats aren't Nazis.

George W. Bush isn't a Nazi.

There are Nazis.  They are out there marching around, lurking on the internet. Nazis exist. Amazingly, some of the people who scream the most about Nazis are the ones that support actual Nazis. They're also the ones that are most likely to do Nazi like things, like burning and banning books, discriminating against others, being white supremacists, being anti-Semitic, being fascist dickheads.

Really, every time you throw some swastika laden sign or flag every time the opposite party does something you don't like and call it the Nazis you sound like a clown. It just highlights that you have no idea about history, or current events, or really any of it, just simplified caricatures of history and events. It also unnecessarily ratchets up hostility that doesn't exist except in the minds of the people dreaming this stuff up. It's hard to lower the rhetoric when one side streams of Nazis and conspiracy theories, and the other side calls them wackos (which admittedly if you're going on about magnets in vaccines, and Nazis everywhere then I mean, the shoe kind of fits on that one).

The internet makes it hard because half to it is coming from bots, but maybe if we could just stop calling everything the Nazis and Hitler it'd be a small improvement.

Thursday, January 18, 2018

Endless Talking, Forgotten?

As I'm getting back in the swing of things with my history classes (after a far too short break), I've had some thoughts regarding how the world we live in today will be remembered. Looking back at history we use primary sources to tell us what happened. Going way back we get proclamations, legal documents, maybe some histories written by the king's hype-monk (you know what I'm talking about King Richard!). As time has progressed we've got a lot more documents appearing. It's not just old stone tablets that have royal decrees and laws. Now we have letters and diaries as people learned to read and write, and as time went on we then see photos and videos being added to the historian's toolbox.

That then opens up the world today. Specifically, we were reading articles about politics during the Civil War, and as I watched my n00b classmates go back and forth trying to decipher the motivations of those long dead using the few primary sources available, it occurred to me that historians looking at the modern dumpster fire of politics will be overwhelmed with evidence. Or will they? That is the question that popped into my mind. How much of the stuff we are producing today, the mounds and mounds of primary sources, will be preserved? Will tweets be preserved? Viral facebook posts? YouTube vidoes? What about things like the 24 hour news stations? Are all their shows archived in a way that 150 years from now historians will be able to get a real feel for what the public thought about things? If preserved a historian may look at the various news shows and in essence relive the same process those today are. They could then pull tweets or posts on social media to see how average people were responding. Or, will all of this be lost as it is electronic data that can easily be lost?

I considered this as I thought about how I taught more modern events like 9/11. There are a few sites out there that provide access to all the major networks coverage of the day. I pulled up the video of the Today Show, and let them watch as I checked homework. They got to listen to some mundane interview, they saw them talk about the weather, meet with the people out on the street, but then saw how everything changed. How information slowly trickled in, and how no one knew exactly what was going on. They witnessed it unfold in much the same way that people on that day did, only they had some idea of how it all ended.

It's an interesting thought to consider, or at least it's interesting for a historian. Everyone else may not care all that much, but it was on my mind.

Picture(s) of the Day: 
Picture 18
Sal got to go to the store that sells all sort of like scrapbook type stuff. A lot of it seems like industrial leftover kind of stuff, like leftover stuff that they usually use to pack some things for shipping. Basically you get to fill a bag for a flat rate. She clearly got quite a haul, and is enjoying her craft time.

Tuesday, August 2, 2016

Extreme Makeover: Presidential Library Edition


To start, I have to praise Sal for her sleep in the hotel.  We were a bit concerned with her sleeping in the pack and play, and we didn't know if she'd even sleep with us in the same room.  We kind of thought she'd want to party a bit and not actually sleep.  Well, quite to the contrary, after crying for a few minutes, which wasn't much difference than usual, she fell fast asleep and stayed that way the entire night.  Not only that, but she also slept quite late.  I woke up at 6am on account of the shittiest mattress ever created, and she was moving a bit. I assumed that she was going to wake up at any moment just like she does at home.  Turns out, she slept for another three hours.  Crazy! Also, she's been a real champ in the driving area too.  Despite some mild boredom fussing, she's been great for all the travel!

This morning we got up and resumed our trip with a pitstop half way at the Franklin Roosevelt home of Springwood, and the presidential library.  When we arrived the guy at the counter told us he could get us into the 1:30 tour of the house that was just about to start.  However, Sal decided that she had no interest in being inside the visitor center and started to scream.  The guy at the counter was very nice and let us know that if we need to cancel or change the time they'd be happy to allow that, and that she could be in a stroller except for inside the house, but the rest of the tour she was fine and in the library she could be in the stroller.

We decided that we'd try to put her in the baby backpack and went out to the car and got it.  It calmed her a bit, but I wouldn't say that it helped completely.  She stopped screaming for the most part, but was very chatty as they showed us around the grounds and the outside of the house.  However, when we went to enter the house she was not having any of it, so Becky took her outside while I looked around again at the house (I wanted to be quick since we'd done the tour before but it took longer than expected).

I was a little surprised that when we entered the house they let us know that we were welcome to take as many pictures as we wanted as long as we did not use the flash as it can damage the paintings and the rugs.  Last time we were here they had a policy of no photos allowed in the building at all.  I didn't plan on actually taking any photos because it was so busy, however they had to split the group up and I got stuck waiting downstairs while the first half got to tour the upstairs, so I snapped a picture of the library since I was the only one in the room.  I love this room, it's surely been host to King George VI, Winston Churchill, and who knows who else.  It's also a freaking beautiful room.

Also, I don't recall them telling us this last time, but along the front of the house to the right is where FDR also had his private study that he worked out of as President when he was in Springwood.  I was able to look through the window and get a good look at the room, which the guide said a lot of important meetings and planning of the war took place between Roosevelt and Churchill.  It was pretty  neat to see and I wish they had told us about it the last time we were visiting the house.  The downside was that this time of year the roses in the rose garden were mostly dead due to the weather.

After our time in the house we decided to go to the library to see the renovations and the new exhibit on Pearl Harbor.  When we walked in the place still smelled like fresh paint, though the renovation was a few years old.  Perhaps it was from the Pearl Harbor Exhibit.  We headed to the exhibit first and started going around and looking at everything.  I probably could have spent far more time there than I actually did, however Sal was getting quite impatient.  After going around the loop I realized I had gone the wrong way around and was going through it backwards chronologically.

After that we toured the renovated permanent exhibit, and let me just say that they did a fantastic job.  The old exhibit was rather boring and was just a bunch of trinkets and things with boring plaques with a short write up of what it was all about.  The new exhibit does more to tell a story starting with the beginning of his presidency and going chronologically using items, exhibits, documents, and all sorts of pictures to tell the story.  It's a fantastic renovation and does so much more to explain his presidency and give visitors a lot of great information and visuals including a really neat set up of FDR's desk with all sorts of items and a little screen that you can use to identify all the items on the desk and tell you about them.  I was quite amazed by the transformation.  It's certainly worth a visit.

Another nice addition was a sculpture between the house and the museum that was made out of pieces of the Berlin Wall by Winston Churchill's granddaughter.  It has to do with fighting against oppression, and there is a companion piece in Missouri of the wall parts that the figures were cut out of.  This clearly means that I'm going to need to take a trip down to Missouri to see the companion.  I actually didn't know there was a Churchill museum down there, but it makes sense as it's where he made is big speech where he declared that, “From Stettin in the Baltic to Trieste in the Adriatic, an iron curtain has descended across the continent.”

Nearby there are some busts of Churchill and FDR that were kind of facing each other on either side of the entrance to the main sculptures.  The area around it seemed to be falling apart a bit, but I'm not sure if that was intended or not. I can't imagine they'd let it go to ruin, especially since it hasn't been there that long as we visited a couple years back and it wasn't there yet.  I also noticed that some of the concrete that seemed to be chipping off was near by on the side walk.

After our time there we headed on our way to New England.  We planned to visit the Vanderbilt mansion as well, however time did not permit because we spent too much time at the FDR site.  We made it to Rhode Island it pretty good time, and ended up having dinner and visiting with Jim, Wendy, Jenna, and Josie.  Sal seemed to have a good time and got to play with the stuffed Pooh Bear that she called "Poop!"  So, day two and we're doing pretty well! Sal and Jenna seemed to get along well, though Sal wasn't sure about it at first.  But, they quickly started getting along and had a really great time playing boo at the end of the night.

Picture(s) of the Day: 
Picture 194
As we were going through all these little towns in New York I saw a few of these hippodromes and it made me think of this NPR story.  The story was talking about all of the buildings around the country that have fallen into disrepair and some of the history, architecture, and style is being lost because they're being torn down.




Picture 195
I decided to have another picture of the day because Sal climbed up on the bench with the statues of the Roosevelts, and it was pretty cute.







Tuesday, January 27, 2015

70 Years

Today marks the 70th anniversary of the liberation of Auschwitz.  There has been a pretty good set of stories on BBC, and a few on NBC talking about survivors and their journey back to mark the anniversary.  Some visiting for the first time since being freed, and with their children and grandchildren. Many talked about how it was necessary for them to return because they were going to a place that was trying to wipe them off the Earth, a death camp.  By returning they showing that they are alive that the camp wasn't able to kill them and instead they were able to live long and full lives despite the best efforts to ensure that didn't happen. Others talked about how they needed to return in order to give voice to all those that were murdered and do not have a voice to tell their stories.  I can't imagine how hard it must be to return to that place given the horrors that they were subject to. 

When we were in Europe we didn't have a chance to visit this place, though in the original plan we had made arrangements to go but that trip ended up getting cancelled all together.  It is on my list of top places to go because as a history teacher I want to go to the places I've read about, to where history took place.  I also relate to the idea that you must be there and know what happened for those that were lost.  Remembering is all that can be done for those that are now gone, and listening is important for those that lived.

I want to attend an event with a survivor and hear their story.  We are quickly running out of time for that as the survivors are getting older and older and soon will all be gone.  The chance to hear first hand will soon be impossible. 

Picture(s) of the Day:
Picture 27
It begins!  The scripts for the summer show have arrived, and plans are starting to happen for our fifth summer production.  This should be a fun one, and one of the better known shows so it may produce some larger crowds than in past years.  Our first three shows were a bit more obscure than last year and last year we saw the biggest crowds we had yet seen.  Next year will be a well known piece as well, so perhaps we will get some even larger crowds.

Thursday, October 23, 2014

No Trade-sies

Helping a friend the other night with a business project there was a comment made to the effects of "ughhh.  I hate money, why can't I just do what I want and someone can just be like 'hey i need that here I have this you take this and give me that."  Basically the idea was that we shouldn't have to worry about money and just barter for what we need and provide things and not have to worry about money.

Now, I know this was just a comment out of frustration with the project and on a real level my friend knows that is unrealistic and doesn't work for a variety of reasons.  But it reminded me of a similar comment a different friend made years ago, but in that case they were actually serious.  Though, that's not surpising as that's the kind of stoner logic that stoners like to go on about and this person was a major stoner.  I hear it from family members of the same variety about how you should just be able to do what you want and not worry about money blah blah blah. 


So that's been going on in my head for a few days remembering those old friends talking about just trading stuff and living without money and that just kind of annoys me.  I'm not annoyed by someone who wants to try and live that kind of life style.  If you want to live without money and grow your own food and live a subsistence life style, sure go ahead.  However your ability to make that choice is because we've moved on from that as a society and the reason for that is money.

Money isn't bad, in fact money is good.  The barter system is great until you actually think about it, and see why money was invented in the first place.  You see money is a universally item that can be traded to anyone for anything.  Basically if you want to think about it, it's the barter system except that you have something that everyone wants and will trade for.  You go to best buy and you trade your little pieces of paper for a television.  You go to Zingermans and you trade your electronic money for a sandwich.  Prior to that you'd need to have something that some one else wanted, and you had to trade that thing for the thing you needed.  The problem is you have to find someone that has what you want, but also needs what you have.  That makes it really hard to get what you need, and also makes it hard to do what you want because you have to offer something to people that they need.

Enter money.  Suddenly you no longer need to find someone who exactly fits your need/offer situation.  You can trade what you have for money, then trade that money for anything you need.  You don't need to offer a service or item to someone just to get something you desire.  You can offer anything that anyone finds valuable and willing to give you money for.  This opens things up because you have greater freedom to peruse things that people may not be willing to trade you for, or that have no trading value.  What use do I have for an actor?  They don't have anything that they can trade to me that I need.  I probably don't have surplus of whatever I have that I can waste on an actor because I need to trade it for the things I need to stay alive.

Further, looking at the world we live in, last night I turned on the heat.  I was able to do that because a company wants my money so I use what they have and give them my money.  If we didn't have money, what would I possibly have to give them in exchange for the gas that runs my furnace?

Anyhow, I'm not sure why that idea stuck in my head so much, but it's been there for two or three days.  It's probably the history teacher in me wanting to explain the world and why our history has put us to the point we are in now.


Picture(s) of the Day:
Picture 314
Someone was super nice and put a scarf on this fire hydrant so that it wouldn't' get cold.  Haha!  Though, it was quite cold this morning, and there was some pretty good frost on the ground, and sadly the car windows.

Tuesday, August 5, 2014

Barking Up The Family Tree

One of the projects this year that I wanted to start working on was a genealogy project.  There's a lot that I don't know about my family and I'd like to now that.  This is added with the idea that someday when/if I have children who become interested in this I will have helped by getting some of the information they would need from the people that had it.  For example I can talk to my gran and find out about her parents and my grandpa's  parents, but 20 years from now that may not be the case (though my gran is pretty young and her mother lived quite some time, so my gran could too).

I wasn't so lucky on all of the accounts, my grandpa died back in 2006, and I really didn't talk to him much about his family.  He once mentioned wanting to go back to a reunion and in passing mentioned that I might have gone with him.  He never went, and looking back now I should have asked more questions and should have gone with him or pushed it so that he would.  My mom actually gave me some things she wanted scanned and one was a copy from his year book.  Apparently he was like a class vice president or something.  I had no idea about these things.

Even worse is the other side of the family.  I know virtually nothing about my father, or his parents.  I know a bit about them, since we did see them a couple times.  I know my grandpa was Jewish, and my grandmother was not.  I heard that her family was originally from Italy, but my grandpa never talked about where his family was from.  Both of them have passed away so that resource is gone.  Probably the last time I saw my grandpa when he wasn't sick he talked briefly about being in World War II.  I don't recall how we got talking about it and how it evolved, but he mentioned he got medals and went and got them to show to us.  He told us he joined the army and told us the story of being in Hawaii on December 7th, 1941 (he was Army, not Navy and was off base when the attack happened).  Other than that I didn't know anything.  My mom said from what she heard he did "suicide missions" but that's about it.  Well, from my initial research I'm finding that it turns out his medal was a Bronze Star from his time in a group known as Merrill's Marauders. They were put behind enemy lines in Burma to try and disrupt the supply routes.  Apparently it was very secret, very dangerous, and a lot of people were killed doing it.

I had no idea about this stuff, and it's really disappointing to know that now when he's gone and not before when I could have asked about it.  We never got to visit much, and when we did I was younger and didn't have the same interest in history.  It's really a shame that I missed out on opportunities like this, from all my grandparents.  So, project one is to get some family stories and history recorded with the resources I still have.

Picture(s) of the Day:
Picture 238
This bell tower is in the area behind my building.  Some days I pass it and I think it looks pretty cool, then other times I pass it and I think it looks like poo.  Lately I've seen it more as a poo variety.

Friday, June 6, 2014

D-Day + 70

Today is the 70th anniversary of D-Day.  It's kind of hard to believe that much time has passed.  It's also kind of hard because as I'm getting older big milestones are now in my actual memory.  So, I remember say the 50th anniversary, and now we're at 70.  When I was little World War II soldiers were what I though of as old veterans, but now soldiers from Vietnam are the age of those I think of as WWII Vets.

It's also moving so fast that each year we're losing more and more of these people and with them their first hand accounts of what happened.  Their stories and experiences will go to the videos they made, and the books they helped write, but gone will be the opportunity to have a conversation with someone who went through all of that.  I don't have any family that I was close with that was on the European front during the war, though my grandfather was a soldier in the Pacific and was in Honolulu on December 7, 1941.  I was really too young to really take advantage of the opportunity that I had to discuss with him his experiences.  I remember only once ever talking about it.  He talked about that day, he showed me a few of his war medals, but we didn't really say too much other than that.  I don't know where he went after the war started, I don't know why he got his medals other than I know that the Purple Heart was for injured in combat.

Today as we remember the events of 70 years ago I think back to how fortunate I have been to visit that place.  I was able to walk the beaches and see what they look like for myself.  I was able to visit Pointe du Hoc to see how the land was potholed and battered from the artillery of ships, and the bombs from the planes.  I walked through the thousands of white crosses and stars of David in the US cemetery and think about those that didn't make it past that day.  It was one of my favorite experiences I had during our trip to Europe, and is something I would like to do again.

Picture(s) of the Day:
Picture 177
This is  the statue in the American cemetery in Normandy France that we got to visit on our trip to Europe in 2011.  It was generally a nice day on our visit, but just as we arrived it started pouring and rained for about 10 minutes before it stopped and then cleared right up again.  There are a few things that hit me when I entered, first when looking out it's almost overwhelming the number of crosses you see.  The second is that the place feels and smells different than the surrounding area.  It was like being back home again, which was kind of strange, especially the fact that it even smelled differently and much more like it smells back home.  If you get a chance I think it's worth it to visit, and I highly recommend it.   


Picture 178
 
A view of some of the rows of crosses and stars of David as we walked through the cemetery.

Monday, April 8, 2013

Holocaust Remembrance Day


Today is Holocaust Remembrance Day, which seems appropriate because if I were still teaching this week we would be covering the Holocaust.  As we get further and further away from World War II we are quickly losing the witnesses of these events.  Soon the people who fought the war, lost family, survived the camps will all be gone, and their voices will be left only to memory or documentary film.  As such we are also getting more detached from the events, and it's becoming more of a story for history books and less an event that people we know experienced.  This of course happens with all history, as the generations go on. 

I notice a change in the way people talk about the Holocaust, where now there is this push to point out that other groups were murdered too.  Political dissidents, gypsies, homosexuals, the mentally disabled, the handicapped or anyone else the Nazis decided were undesirable.  While I think it is important to note that just as many people were killed during this time that weren't Jews, it should be noted that these other groups were not hunted and eradicated in the same way.  They are all small slices of the pie, where as the majority of the pie was Jewish.  It's almost a subtle form of Holocaust denial to try and lessen the magnitude of the event by saying, "Yeah, but these people died too."  It's as if to say that the focus is too much on the Jewish deaths and no one acknowledges that others died too.

I'm also reminded of an interview I had at a charter school for a teaching position.  The interviewer asked me how I was going to deal with events such as the holocaust, and in a round about way asked me how I was going to teach it as an opinion.  Let that sink in.  A school administrator asked me how I was going to teach the Holocaust as an opinion not as a historic fact. I won't say where this school was, or what type of demographics populate the school, but I was shocked that I was being asked and didn't know how to even respond at first.  I believe that perhaps my answer may have kept me from getting the job, but I told them that while the justification and reasoning behind some events may be up for debate, there are somethings that are facts and can not be taught as an opinion.

Today I think it important to remember history, to remember the events, and to push back on any kind of denial even when it is subtle.  General Eisenhower at the time visited the camps so he could relay his own personal accounts, so there would be no questions about how severe and terrible the conditions were.  He then had as many people as he could visit the camps, both from nearby towns and US and Allied soldiers.  He knew that first hand accounts would be necessary to keep people from denying it later.  If you'd like to read some of the primary documents, I suggest you visit the Eisenhower Presidential Library collection found here.  There are many documents that have been scanned for you to read.  Also, visit in person or online the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum here.