Wednesday, January 20, 2016

Failing Schools?

 My current job brings me to yet another school district, which means I’ve been in most of the schools around the county and see a large array of systems and levels.  From some of the most affluent schools in the area, to some of the poorest, from public schools to charter schools, I’ve seen a lot of what’s going on in the area, and in schools in general.  I’ve been in music classrooms, I’ve seen the theatre productions that schools put on, I’ve been in cafeterias and gymnasiums, I’ve taught everything from Spanish, to history, to computers. I’ve seen rich students, poor students, forgotten students, struggling students, excelling students, diverse students, sheltered students, and everything else you could think of.

Often times it’s impossible to hear about schools without hearing someone pipe in with “schools are failing our kids” and a ranting on teachers unions, low test scores, and the like.  I’ve often held that schools as a whole aren’t failing, but agreed that there are some schools that are.  I’ve generally maintained that the problem isn’t teachers and that they are out there day in and day out giving it their all.  At the same time I agree there are teachers out there who have no business in the field.  Many I’ve seen first hand as they call their students “dead behind the eyes,” “losers,” or watch as they sit behind their desk reading from notes that look to be 20 years old lacking all engagement with the students or the material.  Clearly teachers like this are failing, they count down the days to the weekend, the next break, and the summer vacation. They do as little as possible and resist all change.  However, this group in most schools is a stark minority. 

Overall, I will reject the idea that the school system if failing.  I will acknowledge the weaknesses and I will agree with efforts to change it for the better that make sense.  However, my time, and specifically when looking at my most recent assignment in contrast to my last assignment tells me that perhaps the schools are failing in a different way that aren’t graded on a test and aren’t readily available for inspection from the public. Perhaps even some of these areas are causing issues that spill over into other classrooms and maybe is part of the reason so many young people seem so stressed out, burned out, and just plain exhausted.

The first area to look at where I’ve seen some stark contrasts is the area of teaching students to be decent, respectful, and responsible students.  I think this is most evident at times where students are less regulated, and something I’ve seen in the cafeteria.  The students fool around and are loud and somewhat obnoxious, however that’s to be expected and not what I’m talking about.  The issue I have is their behavior in regards to just leaving their trash, not respecting their facility, dumping food and just leaving it.  There is no level of responsibility and respect for their facilities or for the people who maintain them.  In contrast, my last position the behavior would not be tolerated, and students are responsible for cleaning their areas and following specific procedures.

Part of that are clearly the expectations of the environment.  From what I can tell the goal is simply to make it through the 30 minute period and then move on.  The adults expect and accept the behavior and don’t try to fight against it and improve it.  So in that sense these adults are failing at teaching these students that their mess doesn’t magically disappear, in fact even in Harry Potter a house elf had to do the cleaning.  However, we see this in the adult world too where people just throw their trash on the side of the road (it’s the worst at the end of winter when the snow melts leaving a field of trash everywhere). There is a total lack of ownership of our areas and acceptance that we are all responsible for it and need to respect it and keep it clean.  I’ve often hear people talk about other areas and I believe Japan is given as an example where the students are responsible for the janitorial duties in the school because it’s their school, their mess, and therefore their responsibility.  The adults expect them to do this and there is a sense of responsibility and respect that they are trying to instill on their youth.  It seems to me schools could do better by following that model and focus on these non-academic areas despite the extra organization that it would require.

Related to this idea of “non-academic” learning, perhaps is also an issue that many teachers may see in their classrooms related to student behavior.  By this I mean in many schools there are very few offerings other than the required “core” subjects that test scores monitor.  Schools more and more are moving to block schedules where instead of 45 minutes to an hour classes are now an hour and half, and the day is filled with academic work in language arts, science, math, social studies, and foreign languages.  There may be a short elective in there for music, art, or the required physical education or health class.  However, the day is packed with heavy classes and the day is devoid of something to break up these huge blocks.  There’s not a class where you can just go into a kitchen and learn to cook, or an hour of physical activity to help clear your mind.  Art can be taken, but if you have only a few options for electives you have to choose between that and perhaps choir, or band. 

These ‘soft’ courses develop very important skills, as evident from so many young people who have no idea how to cook, have never used a tool, or who become adults and realize they have no idea about how to pay taxes, open a bank account, or do many of the things that the adult world requires.  Students need to learn about these areas, but they also need a break from the heavy academic loads.  Sure, these classes are graded, however there is very little pressure and are a chance for students to slow down for a period.  Additionally, perhaps it would help students to calm down in other classes and focus more on their content because it’s not one high demand and perhaps “boring” class after another.  I know when I’m only working and doing schoolwork I get burned out and need time to do something that I actually like to do, however all too often the options are severely limited and the time allotted to those limited choices are equally limited.

A large portion of that comes down to the issue with funding.  Sure, we’ve allocated far more time to the “core” subjects, and we’ve added test upon test to ensure these core subjects are being learned, however at the same time we’ve also been cutting from the other end by eliminating funding.  In many schools the buildings are barely maintained, art teachers are buying their own supplies, and music, theatre, and other classes are constantly fundraising to ensure they have the materials they need.  So, imagine having to actually maintain a home economics classroom like the one I had, filled with sewing machines, as well as five fully functional kitchens.  Or imagine stocking, servicing, and maintaining a fully functional wood and metal shop for students to work in.  What’s further, each of those classes require an additional teacher that the school would have to pay.  We barely fund schools as it is, teacher pay is low, and to offer these types of classes would cost even more money.  The simple fact is we don’t fund schools accordingly, but then complain that they are failing.

This funding issue also cuts in to the experiences and enrichment opportunities offered at schools.  How often to students go on field trips anymore?  The districts are reluctant to pay for the bus services and clubs or teachers are left trying to fundraise to make it happen.  However, this puts more work on teachers who are already working sometimes 10-12 hour days or even longer.  Plus, a field trip takes students away for those other important classes putting those students behind and leading to more work to catch up (and students are already perhaps overloaded on homework).  In the end, these pressures create a lot of disincentives to arrange these types of experiences, especially in the upper levels.

Overloaded teachers bring about another issues that many teachers understand, and that is the massive amounts of work and the few resources and time that they are given.  Where I’m at now I work as a resources, for example if a teacher needs help grading, or wants a grade analysis they call me and I take care of it for them freeing up time for them to plan, meet with students, communicate with teachers or anything else they may need to get done.  Teachers need more resources and assistance to allow them to focus on other activities.  In any other industry people at this level have administrative assistance to delegate work like that to.  Why is a teacher spending time at a copier and collating, stapling, and organizing papers?  Is that the best use of their time?  In this day and age is there really no good resources to help analyze grades, or provide statistical information on how students are doing?  Quite often it seems very piecemeal and some teachers have resources but they have to share it and then other teachers have to understand how to use it, which sometimes seems problematic. 

The final area has to do with what is offered to students, and this specifically came to mind as I was in the lunch room the other day and watched the students walk past with their “food” that most ended up throwing most of it in the trash.  To call it food is probably a stretch and perhaps would subject you to investigation for false advertising.  I’m not saying that all food needs to be gourmet, and we don’t need a Wolfgang Puck or Emeril in every school kitchen, however, how about some actual food.  There are times where students walk past and I’m not even sure what the food on their plate is.  In fact I made the mistake and said something like “Oh, chicken nugget day, eh?” only to find that it wasn’t chicken nuggets at all.  The same is true of our classrooms where I see outdated or destroyed books, computers that are laughably old, equipment for gym class or art class that is broken, or situations where there are not enough to get students the materials we need. 


As a society there is no reason that with our economy and our values that we should have schools systems anywhere in the country that are like this.  We expound on the greatness of America and pat ourselves on the back for our own superiority while schools around the country scream at our hypocrisy.  We act as if education should be treated as shopping at a value discount store where we settle for 50 pounds of no-name near expired mayonnaise because the price is right.  I’m all for efficiency and doing what we can at a reasonable price, but we don’t treat other budgets that way because we see the need.  We can’t get out of this through a business model where we cut and cut to achieve profits (though education is not a profit industry, but the idea is the same where we want to devote as little money as possible to it).  We can do better than that, and are negligent if we don’t.

Picture(s) of the Day:
Picture 20
It was very difficult to get a picture of her because she kept trying to get the phone or just wasn't interested in doing what I wanted.  But, here we have Sal wearing her Keely shirt.

No comments: