As background the issue came up as a result of a political cartoon showing a recent graduate having to move home with his parents. His parents sat on the porch and made comments about how lazy he was having to move home and when they started out they had nothing. The response was that the graduate which he started with nothing as he carried a huge sack on his back labeled with "five figure student loan debt". For reference I put this above.
Clearly this comic is pointing out the huge burden that is being carried by college graduates. Student loan debt is a huge issue and there are a lot of things I could say on them, and perhaps will save that as a part three of my discussions on education. However, the "debate" that I want to address began with a short discussion on government funded education, and went to a position that basically said that the student was to blame for the debt because it was their choice and they could have just gone to a trade school or that there are a lot of jobs that don't require a college degree. Later the discussion turned to the idea that the person could have joined the military to get the GI bill rather than taking out loans, or worked. One idea being that a poor person should have to risk their life to get an education, the other showing a completely out of touch idea that you can work and pay for college when tuition alone will cost you nearly five figure just for a single year.
The first idea I want to discuss is the idea that instead of debt if people can't afford school they should just get a trade or find a job that doesn't require a degree. This idea enrages me. The idea that someone who doesn't come from means should simply not go to school makes me want to punch someone in the face. In this country we are based on the idea that anyone, regardless of means, race, religion, or whatever else, can be whatever they want if they're willing to work for it. The suggestion that a poor kids from the slums, a kid of a single mom living in a trailer park on welfare, the child of an immigrant family who has nothing but moved here to make a better life for their kids,or a middle class kid who has a family that barely makes ends meet should be told "sorry, college is expensive go find a job that doesn't require a degree" is outrageous. No one anywhere should be told that they should just go to a trade school or be a receptionist that pays well enough if they want to be a surgeon, a teacher, an engineer. The idea that the solution to the burden of student loans is to just not go to college is short sighted and foolish.
The question then becomes, who then should we start telling not to go to college. The notion that not everyone needs to go to college to get a good job, and that we need to stop pushing the idea that everyone should go to college means that we therefore would only tell certain people to go to college. So who are we then going to tell not to go to college? The answer is obvious, and that's everyone who can't afford to pay outright for it. That means we're basically telling a boat load of people that they should just go to a trade school or find a job that doesn't require a degree. That because they came from a family that couldn't put them through college then they don't get to take advantage of a college education and instead get to go down the second tier path. Financial status should never be a prerequisite to a college education. Money should not define the opportunities to improve oneself or be a barrier to opportunities that are afforded those with a college education. Education is the greatest equalizer in this country, and to suggest that socioeconomic status should be a required prerequisite is a despicable, elitist, and un-American position.
This idea also hits my buttons on the veins of my post yesterday regarding turning a college education into a commodity. Taking a position like that basically says that the only benefit to going to college is to get a job, and if you don't need a degree to get a "good middle class job" then you shouldn't bother with college and avoid the debts. This passes the buck and excuses the fact that college is too expensive and that a graduate should have to leave college saddled with crushing student loan debt.
Continuing along the lines, this idea creates a barrier to those that already have enough obstacles to overcome. It's easy to sit and tell people who are stuck with student loans that it's "their choice" and they could have done something else when you have the luxury of being able to afford to pay for it, live at home and not worry about living expenses, is ignorant to the fact that millions of people don't live that life and don't have those opportunities. They sit on their throne of privilege and lecture others for being worse off because it was their "choice" to take out those loans and suggest they should have just taken a job that doesn't require a degree or a trade that only requires a few classes at a community college. The prerequisite to a job you're passionate about, or the chance to pull yourself up by your bootstraps shouldn't be to already have money, or go into crippling debt to achieve it.
I'm not even arguing that college should be free, simply that the cost is out of hand and creating an undue burden on those that already have it harder. I'm saying that when you start to go on about some people don't need to go to college because they have to take out loans you set up a second tier system to people who don't come from means. A poor kid who wants to work for NASA shouldn't be told to find a trade school. I'm also not saying that everyone in the country should be required to go to college, but that they should have affordable access should they decide that is something they want to do. Obviously I believe many would benefit, and as a society there are huge advantages. I think the current rate of less than 40% with a college degree is far too low.
However, with this debate once you begin down the path with the idea that not everyone needs to go, you end up at a position of who do we educate. This is a dangerous path to take because the questions begin to answer themselves. In the end a college education translates into higher lifetime earnings, more stable employment as seen during the great recession, higher political participation, and a slew of other benefits. Many of the best jobs require a college degree, so by creating a system where some are denied the opportunity to go to college, the door closes on all the opportunities that come after that. That's not the American way, or a policy that goes with our most basic ideals. College should be available and affordable to anyone who wishes to pursue that path, and the outcome shouldn't be crippling debt that hurts us as individuals, but also hurts our economy and keeps graduates from moving forward with their lives.
Picture(s) of the Day:
Picture 312
Drove out to lovely Chelsea yesterday. The colors on Main St. really pulled me cute small town life button. I almost could imagine living on a street like this. However the overwhelming power of my "I literally hate everyone in the world" reminds me that I prefer to not have neighbors too close.
1 comment:
100% agree. I can't even add any of my thoughts here because you so perfectly said everything.
Post a Comment