Tuesday, July 19, 2016

Some Additional Comments

Yesterday I was rather critical regarding the idea of a third party that I think require some additional commentary because as a whole the idea of multiple parties is not a bad idea and there are many benefits to having additional parties.  However, the reason I am critical of that idea is because of the political landscape that we live in.  Unfortunately our political system is where the person with the most votes wins.  That seems to be a great idea when you first think about it, because if you got the most votes then you should be the person that wins, right?  Well, the problem is that if you have multiple parties this means the person that gets the most votes could easily be in a position where a minority elected them.  Say you have three parties where one party wins 40% of the vote, one gets 35% and one gets 25%.  In that situation you have 40% voting for the party that "won" but 60% of the people voted for someone else.  This is why I'm critical because the only way that it works well is if there are two parties, and people then compromise a lot and choose a party they want to win rather than what they believe in.

However, that's the system we have and that is why I'm very critical about voting for a third party.  Because of our most votes wins system a third party will never work out well, and will in the end make sure the viable candidate loses because votes were redirected to the third candidate thus making the opposition win.  Because of this a third party is self-destructive until we alter the system we have, and there are some far better ideas out there, for example there's the alternative vote, which is like a runoff election where you get to vote and put the candidates in the order you'd prefer, and if your first choice doesn't win and is eliminated then your votes will go for someone else.  So in the current situation say you voted for the Green Party, but put the Democrats as your second choice.  The Green party loses (as we all know they will), but in the Alternative Vote model you didn't waste your vote and your vote gets transferred to the Democrats.  This makes a lot more sense because it can be more reflective of people's beliefs, but you don't have to be afraid of voting for your beliefs because if in the end your person doesn't win, you can make sure your voice still is counted.

Multiple parties could be better for democracy, and my criticism of them is because of the system that we are currently in.  It should also be noted that this wouldn't help solve the problem of corporate and financial control and influence because it doesn't address the way we fund elections or the insane idea that money is the same as speech and that corporations are people.  This is a different set of worms, but the alternative vote would be a step in the right direction.

Picture(s) of the Day: 
Picture 181
This is slightly cheating because this is the sunset from Sunday not today, but it was pretty and I wanted to use it. Sometimes we get some really pretty sunsets.

No comments: