However, this conversation isn't about being right about those things. It's about what we're doing going forward, and I have to say that the political immaturity of a lot of these "or bust" people is kind of absurd. I mean, I get it, they are young so they are immature. I don't hear older Sanders supporters promoting the "or bust" mentality. It's mostly the Gen-Y group that is somewhat fresh to this whole election thing. They want things done their way, they don't want their feelings hurt, and they don't want to compromise. They're strongly idealistic, which is all well and good, you need ideals of what they want, however they also need to be pragmatic.
One of the things they're all on about now is how we need a third party. Now, in all reality we have at least four parties that are regularly heard form when elections come about. There are the two main parties, Democrats and Republicans, but you also have the Green Party and the Libertarian parties. So right from the start I'm not really buying the "we need a third party" argument because we already have more than three parties.
The next argument is that the problem is that the two main parties are too big and we need a third big party. However, there is where the trouble lies. These third parties don't do well because the two main parties cover enough that it speaks for the majority of Americans. The reason these other parties are small is because the people advocating other parties are on the fringe of things. The green party is far left, the libertarians are far right. They aren't bigger because more people aren't down with those beliefs. Most people are more moderate. There could be a case for a moderate party that takes the independents from the main parties but even that doesn't seem necessary because moderates (or independents as they are preferred to be known) aren't bound to any party and will switch (i.e. Reagan Democrats).
A third party is not going to solve the problems we have today. A third party isn't magically going to be immune to "corporate control" because the election system we have now with gerrymandering, Citizens United, super pacs, and the cost of elections all works the same regardless of the party. A third party has to work in the system that is already present, and that's the real problem. A corporation could just as easily influence a third party as it could one of the current parties. A third party also isn't going to magically get people working together. We can't get two parties to agree and work together, a third party to the mix isn't going to change that. Imagine how hard it is to find somewhere to go out to eat, and then think about when there are more people involved in the decision. It becomes more complicated and even less likely to get it sorted out. A third party isn't going to change that. A third party isn't going to make the Republicans move on liberal issues any more than it's going to make Democrats shift on conservative issues. A third party would just be a wing of one of the parties which would dilute their power and benefit the other party.
This all just comes down to math, and unfortunately Americans are terrible at math. A third party will draw voters out of the party that it is based in. For example when people talked about Bernie Sanders running as an independent, that would not have benefitted anyone except the Trump camp again because it would split the liberal vote while the conservative vote does what it always does, and sticks together. They all lined up right behind Trump. The "Never Trump" movement quietly and quickly disappeared. This is what a third party does in the sense that these people promoting the Green Party are talking about. It will siphon away liberal votes from the Democrats which is basically giving votes to the Republicans.
I often see these graphics on Democratic causes that quote Elie Wiesel about staying silent in the face of oppression only benefits the oppressor. Well, effectively that is what all of these sour grape Bernie or Bust supporters are doing. They are silencing their voice by voting a third party. Their voice will not matter because they are throwing their vote to a party that has zero chance of winning. Thus, they are saying silent in the face of the oppressive and disgusting Republican platform and their racist leader, Donald Trump. This does nothing but help the oppressor. They want to hold their nose and act like Clinton is this terrible, unrcontionable evil, but it's really just some bologna. She's too moderate on a few issues, but so is Obama. What's the difference?
In the end, I'm not overly concerned. This wing is a fringe of the fringe, and they couldn't even get enough people out to vote for him in the primary. I think in the end enough mature people will do what they need to and make sure that although their ideal candidate didn't win, there is a clear distinction and path that these two candidate will take us. Third parties are unpopular because they are fringe groups with very specific beliefs that aren't mainstream enough, which is why they remain small. This is why they've never been a major player in politics, and generally won't except in rare circumstance.
Picture(s) of the Day:
Picture 180
Sal was enjoying the view of the falls. When we first looked over the edge of the gorge before the falls were in sight she said, "oooooooooooo!" Very adorable.
No comments:
Post a Comment