Thursday, January 10, 2019

Book Review: An Absolutely Remarkable Thing

We are now 10 days into the new year, and I've already got some progress to report, and that is I have finished my first book of the new year, Hank Green's An Absolutely Remarkable Thing! I basically finished the thing in three days, with the majority of the reading being done over two evenings.  I was actually so drawn into it that I had no temptation to stop to see the train wreck that was the Oval Office address yesterday, and the rebuttal that apparently neither of which changed anyone's minds. However, I digress from the topic of discussing the book.

So, to start off Hank Green is an internet personality that I've been following on YouTube since he and John did their Brotherhood 2.0 videos back in 2007.  Knowing that, I realize I'm going into it already being predisposed to like what he does, or at the very least giving him a lot of latitude to not criticize too much because I like him and I like his message, and I also like supporting people who do things that I like, even if what they do isn't stellar. That being said, I thought his book was not bad.  I don't think it was life changing in any way, but it had a clear message that I agree with parts of, it was engaging, and I was compelled to continue to find out where the story was going which is a good thing for a book to do.

A brief overview of the context of the book, it's about a girl who while walking through New York late at night finds a pretty neat statue that she's never seen before. She calls her friends and they post a silly video with the statue, and then go home to go about their business.  The next morning she wakes up to find that her video has gone viral and been seen millions of times.  She is skyrocketed to fame, and suddenly has to contend with all the issues that come with that, including becoming someone people are a fan of, having a voice that people respect, having the responsibility of paying attention to how she presents herself and her arguments, power dynamics of fame, and how people talk to each other when they have different points of view.  In reality, these ideas are what drive the book, and the events in the book that spark this are more of a catalyst than the main point of the story.  In fact, it seems to me that the structure and context of the book are just set dressings to allow Hank to say what he wants to say.

Indeed, the main message that he is trying to convey is the way that we have conversations in this country.  While he is telling a science fiction story, it seems to me upon reading his book that this part is the easiest way to have the conversation he wants to have without getting into contentious issues that we are currently debating as a country.  If he were to focus on those issues, say climate change, immigration, race, sexism, equality, opportunity, or any other wedge issue the book would have to take a position on them and thus turn off many readers. However, by creating a fictional issue that he can carefully construct the argument for and create one where you can clearly see that belief rather than certainty drives some people, he is able to point out that no one has the answers and it's important to realize that. By doing this he can make it clear what happens when people demonize "others" and fail to hear them out or understand why they may believe something different form you.

While I think this is a helpful argument, I feel there are some flaws in such ideas.  The first is that it operates on the basis that people are acting in good faith, which unfortunately I don't feel is generally the case in many of the arguments that are being had in contemporary life.  When we discuss some of the talking points of things like "lock her up" or when people cry out about Benghazi these are political arguments crafted for the lowest denominators. These aren't good faith arguments, they are simply playing politics. The other issue I feel is at play here is that some of these arguments can not come from a place of reasonable differences. White supremacy, racism, sexism, and homophobia and transphobia are not really places where compromise can work.  Like, ok you think certain people are inferior, where can we meet on this issue?

What I do agree with a lot though is the movement of people into camps where everything becomes adversarial and you take those positions simply as an opposition to the position that someone else has already taken.  This is very visible when people resist something simply because it was something that the "other guy" did even though previously you supported it.  For example the constant howls about Obama's vacation days who are mum when the Republicans outpace them, to which democrats suddenly want to bring up all the damn time to have that argument that really doesn't matter.

Ultimately, I liked the book, but didn't think it was a genius work of art that was amazing.  It kept me interested and I was able to get through it really fast because I was curious where it was going.  It had a bit of a "to be continued" sort of ending, that I didn't find surprising but does make me want to know what he's going to do next.  However, I don't know that I would recommend it to people who don't follow YouTube community because I feel a lot of the issues are those that are somewhat restricted to that group. That's not saying people outside of that group can't enjoy it, just that they may not find the focus on what happens with fame as compelling and interesting since the science fiction portions really seemed more like a vehicle than the point.

So, one book done on my goal of 55!

Picture(s) of the Day: 
Picture 10
A picture from a few weeks back when we did our family photos at the botanical gardens. They had a small display of bonsai trees, and this one I thought was really impressive.

No comments: