Wednesday, July 22, 2026

What The Hell Just Happened?




As part of my job the past two days I've spent at a summer PD where went and visited a private school.  The school was built under the idea that they were going to create this great school, bring in the best and most passionate educators, and have teachers from all over visit the school to see what they are doing there and go back to their schools and bring that knowledge to create better schools.  To their credit, their teachers are nationally recognized educators who have had tangible results.  They are also passionate and engaging people, I've heard the two founders of the school as well as some other staff speak before ever visiting the school, and they are fun to listen to and clearly love what they're doing.  

I'd say after yesterday I felt completely overwhelmed and overstimulated.  Everything was just so loud all the time.  For one, there are hundreds of teachers on this visit and so there's always a lot of people talking when we travel to room to room to watch.  However, the rooms themselves also are like this.  During each transition the teachers are blaring music as students (and as we) enter the room.  In one room in addition to the music they also had these like fog machines that shoot our fog/mist, but not like a theater sort of way, but if you've ever seen these jets at like a basketball game or sporting event where it loudly shoots out smoke.  Many of the rooms were rigged with theater style lighting, and in one class when they got enough problems correct the teacher smashed a green button on the wall and the result was like a rave in the classroom.  It was a lot of stimuli and by the end I basically wanted a sensory depravation chamber to recover from it all. Today, the second day was a lot less insanity.  Perhaps part of it was that the shock and awe had worn off, or perhaps they toned down their Operation Shock and Awe so that it wasn't so over the top.

In the end it was a lot to digest and I don't know what to think about all of it.  I felt like there were a lot of broad sweeping generalizations but I didn't feel like I walked away with any real specifics on what I'm supposed to do.  Like, it seems like the sentiment was generally "be more passionate" and "make sure you keep your arms above your waste most of the time."  Which, I don't know if that's all that helpful.  I feel like a lot of it hovers around the idea of "do more, think of the children!" It makes me think of this really shitty motto I've seen that says "A good teachers is like a candle, who consumes itself to light the way for others."  Like, these people have made this their whole life it seems, and put every waking moment into this job.  That's commendable I suppose, but it's not sustainable.  The quote basically is saying to destroy yourself for others until there is nothing left of you.  This is absolutely absurd because that's not a way that you can live if everything is going toward this and you end up with people feeling like they have to burn themselves out (and if they do they're a failure) in order to do this job.  I personally love teaching (despite the fact that I feel like I do very little teaching anymore, but that's a different rant) but I've got kids, a family, and basic human needs, and so I can't burn myself out for a job regardless of how much I love it.  So walking away from an experience where the answer seems to be that you need to have 150% energy all day every day isn't workable on a systematic level.

There were also a lot of focus on making this fun.  The special, super awesome, buzz word "engagement" is the underlying thing with making it fun.  Students are drumming on things, they're doing all these dances, call and response, and all sorts of other things, but in the end it left me feeling and wondering what they've actually learned.  Do they know and understand anything, and if I tried (not that I would because that kind of thing does not fit my personality) would my student learn anything.  Or would it be kind of like how birds can mimic words and sound.  They're just repeating the slogan, they've learned the word by heart but what it means is not there.  Now, for them maybe it works and maybe they do understand what it all means.  But it was like when I had this dentist years ago always try to upsell me on procedures like screenings, whitening, etc. because they wanted to "max my benefits" to get my money's worth.  They were always just selling me and I lost trust in what they were suggesting because I didn't know if I really needed it.  In the same way, I walked away today wondering how much of what I saw was real, and how much was a show for all the teachers that showed up.  They do these visits twice a month, so do they all know the script?  It felt like a performance.

But again, these people have tangible results in public schools before they got to this private school.  However, now I'm watching them in this private school.  This school where people are trying to get in, where many are paying tuition, where parents have to meet a required number of volunteer hours.  And of course, walking around the school I can see why kids would want to go there.  I spent the past two days taking photos to send to my own daughter because I knew she would love it there. Sure enough, when I spoke to her after getting home she was like "why can't we have a school like that back home?"  It is clearly a place students want to be.

In the end, I don't know what I just went through and what I can take from it. All too often it feels like I'm trying to teach people against their will.  They don't see the value in my subject, but some don't see the value in school at all.  It feels like being on a battle field, whereas this felt like being in a joyful space.  I suppose that the very least I can take the feeling of optimism and that motivation of what teaching could be and why it's important because those feelings came through after this visit.  I still don't know what else to take from it, but it certainly was an experience.

No comments: