Thursday, March 21, 2013

Insulated

Yesterday I spoke about a report I read discussing schools and accountability.  It was a very interesting report and if you didn't get a chance to read my blog or the report and you're interested you can find it here.

One thing from the report that did stand out to me was a quote from a parent.  The section of the article was on parent involvement and how some parents may not be involved enough and prepare their students for school.  The report also discussed the idea of society values, and the disruption individual students could cause in a classroom if they haven't been taught how to act, to be respectful, etc.  However, the quote in question really jumped off the page when I was reading.  A parent said, "I personally don’t like [my son] going over to friends’ houses. . . . I’m personally not ready for him to be at other people’s homes. As I said, they might not have the same values as I do"

Now I'm totally giving this parent the benefit of the doubt, that they are a good parent, they do all the right things to help encourage their education, to support their student, all that jazz.  However when you have a discussion about education, talk of values, and say you don't want your kid around other people because they don't have the same values, well that just makes my head start ringing.  That's a lot of what you hear when the crazies pull their kids out of public school for home schools.  Then the next thing you know it's field trips to the creationist museum, attacks on science, reason, and logic, and dinosaurs with saddles.

I'm not necessarily talking about the comment, or the situation here, but rather the sentiment that you don't want your kid around other "values" that are different from your own.  Now maybe it's just me, but if you have instilled the values in your children, you really shouldn't be afraid that the values of someone else will override yours.  That is, unless perhaps you are insecure about your values?  I don't know, I'm just very much against that sentiment.  I am not in any way a supporter of home schools, in fact I don't really even like the idea that they're allowed, especially on ground of religion.  I'm all for your hokey religions and going to Sunday school, etc.  But I don't think you should have the option of putting your head in the sand and insulating yourself from things that are different.

The world is full of people that are different, and teaching children the lesson that you should stay away from things that are different, and shield those from things that aren't like you is half the reason we have so much bullshit in the world.  STOP! THAT  PERSON IS DIFFERENT! BEAT THEM TO DEATH WITH A TIRE IRON!  SHUNNNNN! SHUN THE NON-BELIEVER!!! SHUNuh-nuh-nuh-nuhnnnnn! 

Seriously, the world is a place full of different beliefs, ideas, opinions, cultures, etc.  You can't insulate yourself or you children because you're doing a huge diservice to the kid as well as all of humanity because you're perpetuating an idea that different people are a problem, and giving a bad example of how you deal with diversity.  While the original quote doesn't necessarily explicitly say this as it is an out of context quote, the ideas set off all sorts of stuff in my head.  I'm just saying that we can't hide from things that are different, everything is different. You need to learn to deal with that otherwise you'll probably grow up to be a giant cockface.

Wednesday, March 20, 2013

School Accountablity

Last week I had a number of blogs on schools and discussed that I felt education was in a critical failure.  I then discussed troubles I've seen working in public schools, and my general grumpiness related to how things are versus how they could be.  Today I was reading through some of my normal blogs when I came across this report on accountability in schools.  

The study was done by The Kettering Foundation and Public Agenda, and it focused on the idea of school accountability which has been a bit of a topic since No Child Left Behind passed in the early years of the Bush Administration.  The idea that schools should be more accountable is surely not a bad idea, however this report discussed how different groups view accountability and where leaders and parents both agree and diverge in their opinion of it.  I will say that a lot of the information from the research didn't surprise me, but I wasn't necessarily expecting some of the views that were also presented from parents, which focused a lot on their role in the system and how they too needed to be accountable.

One thing that immediately jumped out was the statistic that only 29% have a good deal of confidence in public schools today, this is compared to the 58% that held these views in the 1970s.  I think this is really an important part of the puzzle because I don't really think that the school systems have really gone in such decline since the 1970s, if anything the increased focus on schools could only increase performance.  Perhaps this has more to do with the perception of schools than the reality.  For years now we have heard people hammer the schools as failures, terrible, awful, not preparing students for college.  What has really changed in schools since the 1970s, especially given that the argument has been "we can't do it the way we've been doing it."  So, if the old way was so bad, why did so many people have confidence in schools?  I'm not saying the old way was better, but I am saying the constant attacks on education, educators, and public schools I believe have pushed people to this negative perception, and I don't think it's an accurate view of the schools.

I absolutely agree that schools need to do better.  I am a huge critic of our public school, I don't believe it prepares students for college properly, I don't believe it challenges students, I don't believe it provides the best education available.  However I do have confidence in the system, and I do believe it can be improved.  Just because I have high standards about what the school should be, doesn't mean the system itself is a failure, it merely has opportunities to improve and provide a better education.  In all reality students graduate, they can read and write, they can do basic math, they are aware of science and history.  They may not be perfect, but they are not completely uneducated.

I also agree with the finding that parents feel that their role has a huge impact as well.  I think that is a huge argument and wedge issue in the entire reform movement.  Teachers are attacked, they are judged by how a student learns, their jobs and livelihoods are in jeopardy and a lot of the variables are outside of their control.  Yes, I completely agree that an effective teacher can do great things, and an ineffective teacher should either improve, or be removed.  However, this method often will lead to tension because it creates an adversarial stance because teachers feel they are being judged for things they don't have total control over, and those who do have a good portion of the control can't be held accountable.  Though it seems that perhaps many parents agree with that and there is room for some bridge building.  One mother in Detroit said, "I think so many people depend on the school to do everything.  There's a lack of accountability... with parents...  [They] feel like "I'm just going to send my kid to school from 8:00 to 4:00 every day" and let the teacher deal with it.  You know what?  The teacher has 30 other students."
Another mother from Detroit also commented on other items that our outside the control of a teacher, stating, "What about the rest of the stuff going on in the school? . . . I mean it depends on what they came into. How are the books? How are the—how are the—what’s the class sizes?  I mean there are so many other things other than test scores."
Other parents focused on the things I talked about last week. They felt that society had a part to play in the current situation because we don't value education, but rather we value money, things, fame, rather than hard work, doing what you're supposed to do, and being a good person.  One parent from New Orleans noted that he, "blame[s] the society more than the individual teachers [for not preparing
kids] because we have a culture that doesn’t honor hard work, reading, exercise, and all of those things [that] I think interact"  The report summarized that, "many believe that they face an uphill battle trying to raise children in what they see as a toxic culture—one that glamorizes materialism and
self-indulgence. Many parents seem to be looking for answers and looking for allies.  How can educators, parents, and other adults work together to instill the values that will help children flourish in school and beyond?"

I think this highlights the important fact that perhaps both sides of the discussion have far more in common than it seems.  That perhaps the wedge that is being driven for what I feel are political purposes, is damaging to schools, teachers, parents, and students.  Education can be better, and I think both sides need to find a way to communicate and build bridges.  Communication is key, and from my experience one of the skills that is severely lacking, and causes a lot of damage, distrust, and lack of confidence.  


Anyhow, I thought it was an interesting report and thought I would share it and my thoughts on some of the findings.
 

Tuesday, March 19, 2013

Potter Musical!

Nothing special today except on Friday A Very Potter Senior Year was posted on YouTube. So here you have it: Part 1. And the other two if you haven't seen them. The First one: The Sequel:

Monday, March 18, 2013

Music Video Monday

The other day I did a blog on the music videos that were popular back in 1999.  It was a lot of fun, and since I like music videos, I thought that perhaps I'd post some more that were popular back in  THE LAST CENTURY!  Hey, technically it's true people, it's from the last century.  Get with it, you're old.

So, here we go in no particular order what so ever.

Harvey Danger - Flagpole Sitta
Really, I think I just like the song, because there's nothing all that special about the music video, but either way here it is.


Barenaked Ladies - One Week 
This is a case where I like the song and the video. Thought watching the video I have to conclude that surely they were on drugs, because WTF!? But still, it's weird, it's fun, it is peppy, and there's a sweet car hood slide, and everyone loves that. So, all around a fun one.


Aerosmith - I Don't Want to Miss
A Thing Ok, this one gets super high marks on the cheesy factor, but what do you expect with Steven Tyler, he's so over the top. But you also get the cheesy boost with the clips from Armageddon, which is a silly move, but what do you expect it was a summer action flick, and it did its job by blowing things up and was all around entertaining. The song is meh, but I remember this was on MTV ALL the time.
 

The Goo Goo Dolls - Iris
I really like the Goo Goo Dolls, and this was probably the first song I heard from them, as prior to that my music tastes were a big different.  I loved the video for this one, I liked how they hinted at the movie that the song was connected to, but did blatantly highlight it.  I think it worked well for the song as well as the movie.
 

Aaliyah f/ Timbaland - Are You That Somebody? So, this really isn't my normal style of music, but I enjoyed the song. The video was your typical late 90s video where people are standing all facing one direction and dancing at the camera. Just look at any Backstreet Boys or 'N Sync video from the time and you'll see the same thing. It was the style apparently. I don't know what is typical now, perhaps that's still a thing?
 

Third Eye Blind - Semi-Charmed Life
I'm not sure if the video is trying to tell a story or something, or what exactly is going on. I also like how they didn't do the radio edit for the song, but they still edited it, but kind of in a weird spot.  

Everclear - Father Of Mine
This one went with a clear story telling option, but then again the song is kind of a story telling song.  This isn't my favorite Everclear song, but I do like it.  I guess some could say I relate to it as I had an absent father, but not in that "OMG, THIS SONG HITS ME RIGHT IN THE FEELS!"  It's more of a "yeah, I get you." 


The Offspring - Pretty Fly
This one just cracks me up.  I really don't think I have to say much about it.  Though I will say that we made a parody song of this in Drama called Pretty Fly For An Old Guy.  I don't remember any of the words, but I remember the title and that we had quite a few verses to it.  

Madonna - Frozen
The other day Jasmine said "Music Videos from the 90s were weird."  Well, here you go.  This one was weird, but then again Madonna is kind of weird now days too. 
 

Boy Band Meadley
Well of course boy bands were super popular at this point in time.  There were a ton of them and they all had the same kind of music.  So take your pick of your favorite of them below.

Sunday, March 17, 2013

Soda Ban

New York decided that they wanted to place an upper limit on the size of "sugary drinks" that can be sold in the city.  Pretty much they decided that a 128oz (the team gulp from 7-Eleven) beverage may be a bit too large, and set a limit at 16oz.  Now, 16 is actually still a lot, but it's a more reasonable size really because to give you some perspective a 128 oz cup is nearly 4 liters.  A judge struck down the law, but the city is appealing it.

Honestly I didn't really care much about the ban, I don't live there and it doesn't influence me, so whatever.  But as I thought about it,  I don't think there's anything wrong with it.  In fact I think I may support it.  The sizes have gotten bigger and bigger, and I think people have forgotten what and ACTUAL reasonable size is, so bringing the sizes back to a reasonable level doesn't really seem like that big of a deal.  Especially considering that these excessively large drinks are only a few buck, and any kid could afford one and not really think that they are getting more calories/sugar in that drink than they really need in like a week (clearly and exaggeration, but you get it).

Now, the "nanny staters" will say that it's your right as an American, and your freedom to buy what you want and we don't need the government telling us what to do.  It's the job of the parent to tell kids what they can and can't buy.  First, if you really want 128oz, you can still buy that much, you'll just have to buy 8 large sized drinks to get that much.  Yes, that might make you look stupid, but you looked stupid with a 128oz cup anyway, so it's no different.  Next, you aren't being told you can't buy something, in fact "you" aren't being told anything.  The city is telling restaurants that they can't use the obscenely large cups.  So, no one's freedoms are being taken away. 

Furthermore, for those who say people will just get around it, etc.  People will get around ANY law if they want.  Does that mean we shouldn't have any laws?  Yes, it's not actually stopping anyone from buying 8 glasses of soda instead of 1 giant glass.  But perhaps the bigger win is it will reset what people think of as an acceptable size.  If you give people a bigger spoon and larger plate they'll serve themselves more food.  It's a subconscious thing.  So if you give them a smaller plate and a smaller spoon they'll think a portion size is smaller.  Give them a smaller cup and they'll think the correct size is the smaller amount.  It probably will do more to reground the image of the correct size, and that will be healthy.

Finally, can we really stop diluting the idea of "freedom" to nonsense like "IT'S MY RIGHT TO BUY A TON OF SODA, STOP TAKING AWAY MY FREEDOM!"  It's like calling wolf, eventually people won't realize when their actual freedom is being eroded.  If you want to complain about freedom let's talk about illegal wire taps, killing US citizens with drones, the utterly only for show and doesn't really keep us safe pageantry of airport security.  There are plenty of ways freedom is being encroached upon, the resizing of soda from comically large to just overly large is hardly one of them.

Saturday, March 16, 2013

Schools

Being in the field of education I have long supported teachers, argued against things like linking pay to student performance, and other ideas.  I'm generally one to defend teachers, as they are often the punching bags, and having worked with teachers I know the view isn't accurate when people bash teachers and schools. 

That being said, I'm going to bash my school district that I live in.  I have to say without a doubt it does not prepare students for college, and I question if it really teaches them anything.  I'm not one to blame teachers first, but the teachers in that district need to go, and not one or two like most schools, I'm talking the majority.  Having a student in the district and being a teacher I look at the work that comes home, the assignments, and hear how an average day goes in class and I'm appalled.  There is not real learning going on, the questions asked are low level things that don't even scratch the surface, much less get into the meat of the issues that they should be learning. 

When I subbed in this district I was disgusted by the idea of "just get through the day" that pretty much every teacher was telling me about.  I couldn't stand the way the teachers talked about the students in such negative terms.  I heard it with my own ears.  I've sat in staff meetings, ate lunch with other teachers, discussed students after class, but in no way was it what I hear out of our district.  All I hear is negativity, where as in my experience it was all a more positive, "pull yourself up" sort of discussion.  It's no wonder that there is an attitude of "That's Lincoln" when you have teachers telling students they have no chance of passing because none of them are smart enough to follow directions.

It's no wonder students are unprepared when the questions they ask have nothing to do with the themes and topics, but rather simply check to see if they read the material.  Who cares what color the kid's shirt was, or if you answered "town" when the book said "village".  What you should be talking about it how the character coped with something, and how you can compare and contrast that to issues today.  A senior in high school should not be filling out worksheets for every class.  And that's the homework I see every day.  Worksheets.  WORKSHEETS!  How about essays, papers, presentations, group projects, biographies, analysis, labs. 

How can we expect our students to become good citizens, how do we expect them to achieve, how do we expect them to meet their full potential when we are failing them every single day.  They deserve better than this, and we refuse to change it, or don't have the will.  It needs to change.

Friday, March 15, 2013

The State Of Education

Education in this country is in critical failure. However, that comment won't necessary mean what you think it means.  This isn't to be confused with the struggle public education is having right now.  I'm saying education is in critical failure.  I will even go so far to say that school actually do a decent job, as most people in our country know how to read, can do math, have a basic understanding that the earth revolves around the sun rather the other way around, and we know that lightening isn't caused because Zeus has his panties in a bunch from getting herpes from some human chick he knocked up.  I'm not saying schools are perfect, but we'll get to that later.


What I'm talking about is the idea of education, how we approach it and what we think about it.  In a country that is becoming more and more partisan education is becoming a wedge issue that separates "them" from "us".  From the districts that remove undesirables like Thomas Jefferson from curriculum, white wash slavery as simply the middle passage of triangle trade, attack proven science, to disparaging those who are educated as being the "elite" or not like "us" the effect is the value of education is being eroded.  Worse it is almost as if being uneducated is becoming a source of pride in some circles.

Further it is under attack from every person who treats it as a means to an end.  For these people education is there simply for you to get a job, make money, then buy things.  Get a big house, get that fancy car, take those trips, buy those TVs, fancy clothes, jewelry, invest it to make people even better off than you more money.  The job of a schools is to prepare you for the work place, to prepare you for a job, so why take calculus or biology because you're not going to use it in a job ever.  Don't major in anything unless you'll get a job out of it.  Philosophy, English, Theatre, or any other liberal arts majors, hope you enjoy flipping burgers and wasting money on that diploma.

It's become a consumer commodity where people want to be the customer, and fire the "poor performers" based on arbitrary benchmarks from those not even involved in education or who have never set foot in a classroom.  You're buying a product, which is your diploma, not building your mind.  The only thing that matters is the grade, so you can get that diploma, receive the endorsements of being a graduate with "high honors" and once you've unlocked that achievement you can dump everything you "learned".  It's a means to an end, and that end is a product not an experience and an expansion of your understanding.

The very idea of education is under attack and in critical failure because we've politicized, commercialized, and monetized it.  But education isn't about getting a job, or creating political clones.  It's not about earning endorsements and "winning the game" so you can move on to the next level.  Education is about expanding your knowledge, and the knowledge of society and civilization.  It's about learning to think critically, expose yourself to new ideas, understand and appreciate complexity.  Education is about exploring the world and understanding the universe.   It's about improving yourself and society by making you a better citizen. 

We fall behind in world rankings, we attack ideas to expand education programs as being "too expensive", we let our classrooms fall behind, students with no books, outdated technology, crumbling buildings.  We don't value education, which is obvious because we don't fund it.  We spend over 4 times more per inmate in prison than we do per student in school.  We do not value education, and as such education is in critical failure.