Today I saw a video called "Don't Stay in School" buy Boyinaband, at first I heard the title and thought, "Oh jeez, what is this idiot going to have to say?" However, once you watch it you see it's not about dropping out of school, but rather a critique of the school system in general. Reading up a bit I found that there was a hope that things like this would open up the discussion about what is taught in schools and to a lesser extent the discussion on how the focus on testing had caused damage because it means there isn't a focus on other things.
Basically, for those who don't want to Google the video and watch it (though it's worth a watch I suppose), the artist goes on a bit of a rant about all the things he learned in school, and more importantly all the things that he didn't learn in schools. For example he says, "I wasn’t taught how to get a job. But I can remember dissecting a frog.
" or “I was never taught the laws for the country I live in; but I know how Henry VIII killed his women.” Basically his thesis on the matter is "Don’t Stay in School’ isn’t inferring
students shouldn’t stay in school, it’s saying topics which aren’t
practically useful shouldn’t stay in school."
At first I was grossed out by the title of the video, but then I was like "ok, yeah I can see a point here" however as I've thought about it more, I am swinging back around to the idea that this guy is a moron. Basically, this goes down the path of thought that is turning education into a commodity rather than an expansion of your mind and understanding of the universe, and I don't agree with that. The idea that school has the goal of getting you a job is true to an extent. You must be able to think, speak, understand, but the sole purpose of school is not to get you a job, it's to get you an education. That education will help you get a job, but if we boil down schools to being only about getting a job then what is the point of anything anymore?
I've heard this argument a lot before and have blogged about it in the past. From family members and friends who say things like "why do you have to learn algebra if you're never going to use it" or younger friend posting things about how "stupid school is because it doesn't teach you anything important." It really grinds my gears because this kind of thinking is why we are getting into this nonsense testing mentality. It's why everything is focuses on the "useful" subjects and everything else is ignored, cut, and reduced because it's not as important. So, keep that up and then you end up with an education system that creates little drones that only know what it takes to get a job.
Further, some of the arguments in here that the artist claims that schools should be teaching such as how to get a job, how to understand stocks, how a mortgage works, etc. I have to questions because why is that the job of a school? Now some of these get close to economics, a subject that I can teach and would enjoy teaching. But on a broader level, why is that something that a school should teach. Should the more practical subjects like getting a bank account, paying bills, etc. be lessons that are learned in the home and taught by the parents? Or if it isn't taught that way, isn't it something that people can learn themselves? Do I need to take a class in high school to understand what a mortgage is and how it works? Isn't that something I can research when the time comes? Isn't that pretty much what people have always done? In this day and age the internet is a wonderful source for those day to day items that parents should be teaching, or people should be seeking out if it's something they need to learn. Those are situations that people learn through experience. I fully support the idea of having an elective available for those who wish to learn them, or feel they need it, however is that the point of schools?
Better, is this really even something that you can teach through schools? You can simulate a "family budget" but it's not the same. It's play money with no consequences. There is no motivation other than to get the grade, so it will not be the same when you have few options and need to find a way to figure it out. This is something I've run into a lot working with teenagers. Try to get them to think long term and plan ahead. It's an uphill battle and something that they will learn very quickly when the real world gets in their face and they actually have to start thinking about it. Look at things like 401K or Health Insurance. Part of the reason the mandate worked was because it forced young people to get insurance, otherwise they "think they're invincible and don't need it" because it's not something that they face, it's something they can ignore. So, I could set up lessons, but until you have to figure out how to pay your bills, feed yourself, balance your work/school/social schedules, then you are not going to see real learning.
That being said, I think there should be a larger emphasis on economics and civics. These subject (if they are taught at all) are short little half a year sort of courses, and really to produce a good citizen they should be more regular. Perhaps not even a full hour course, but something that is touched upon every single day, so it's in their face every day and something that they have to deal with.
Anyhow, something I saw today and it's now turned into a little rant. Feel free to comment and continue the discussion.
Picture(s) of the Day:
Picture 216

A few seconds later she was quite interested in the fake flowers sitting next to this chair in Pier 1. She's getting quite good at sitting up and balancing.