I'm currently in a long-term disagreement, or perhaps debate, over the idea of people doing their best. Generally, I'm not a fan of the phrase or the idea of "I'm doing my best" because it seems to me that far too often the fact of the matter is that they are not actually doing their best at all. In fact, sometimes they aren't even doing anything at all. The issue I have is that when people say this, it's usually said as an excuse. You can't be mad at me, I was doing my best. You can't complain that I did a shit job, I was doing my best.
Sometimes when this discussion comes up it has to do with some of the students that I have worked with in the past. We discuss how they aren't doing well in school, and I say that they have so many missing assignments, how they don't study, they don't read, they don't do the work in class. But then, who I'm having the debate with says, well maybe they're doing their best. I flatly refuse that they are doing their best, because I point out that they aren't even trying at all, so it can't possibly be their best when it isn't even an attempt being made. We then devolve into discussing how they may have been raised, how they may come from a family who doesn't support education, and the laundry list of other struggles that these students may be facing. Thus coming from those kinds of backgrounds, then maybe they are doing the best that they can. Again, I disagree.
That isn't the only area, there have been other examples that we have discussed about people who have don't a shitty job, and a similar format comes. A list of their challenges, the things that made it hard for them. They grew up with these problems or they had issues with their parents, or who knows what all. So because of that they are not just doing the best that they can. But I don't think that you are doing your best, when there are better things you could have done and that you didn't do them.
I think that it reminds me of the debate I used to get into with the idea of predestination versus free will. I think by saying that all these things in your past means anything you're doing is the best that you can implies that you don't have any agency in your life. What other choice do you have, you are destined to act in a certain way, and what you're doing is the best that you could ever do given the circumstances.
I think too often this is used as an excuse. I'm sorry, but what do you expect, I have all these problems. What else do you expect me to do? I was doing my best. I think in the end it's a justification for not trying harder. Why should I try harder, it's my best. I'm just a victim of my circumstances, you can't be mad at me or hold me accountable for anything, it's not my fault! I don't accept that. We do have agency in our lives, and we make choices, and sometimes those choices are not our best. If we accept this idea that circumstances will predetermine our best, then there is never a need to try harder, or even the possibility of trying harder because whatever shit you do is already your best.
Try harder, be better.