Monday, January 29, 2018

America Without Context

It's interesting to read history from other perspectives, and often you find things that go against the general American idea of itself.  One such example seemed to converge recently, as I began teaching my students about westward expansion and a discussion on the Monroe Doctrine.  In general American history and belief, we often fall into the idea of Manifest Destiny and the idea that we were going to expand and keep Europeans out of the continent. It seems like a logical point, as we did expand and at every turn we seemed to be ending some European power's influence in the region. The Spanish were pushed out of Florida, we took French holdings in Louisiana, Russia sold Alaska, and England gave up claims all over the place in the Canada borderlands.

The problem is that we often teach American history in a way that we don't have time to put our experiences in context. A brief comment about the Louisiana Purchase tied to the fact that it was done during the years of the Napoleonic Wars doesn't really present the idea that we just happened to be in the right place at the right time. It wasn't some bold move by America, but a needed move by the French.  Likewise, when we look at the Monroe Doctrine that called to push out Europeans from the Americas, we fail to acknowledge that the United States military had no ability to actually enforce it. The same week that I begin discussing the Monroe Doctrine with my students, I also happen to be covering the same period in my history of England class. In our reading the issue of the Monroe Doctrine is addressed, and it is noted that the U.S. had no teeth in making such a proclamation, however Britain found it favorable, and had it not been for their vested interests things may have gone a different way. They wished to contain their continental rivals, and so with their navy were able to dovetail onto the independence of the Americas. This allowed the United States to expand, and for Americans to believe in their exceptionalism.

However, we don't have time in our classes to really get into such matters, no do middle school students have the interest in the political minutia of such stories. I have come to believe that perhaps our structuring of history classes are out of whack.  We are teaching vital standards to students unready to learn those lessons. Perhaps a stronger basis of geography, economics, and world history, would set a better foundation for the teaching of American history at an older age. Alas, what can a single history teacher do?

Picture(s) of the Day: 
Picture 29
In an unnecessary temper tantrum Sal went to her room and destroyed a piece of styrofoam. When I went up to see what she was up to she told me to come see what she did, but instructed me to "don't tell mommy so she won't get mad." Oh dear.

No comments: