For example one standard covers understanding Washington's Farewell address, which is very specific, and as such very easy to determine if they understand it. At the same time they have a standard that says: "Establishing America’s Place in the World – Explain the changes in America’s relationships with other nations by analyzing the origins, intents, and purposes of treaties." There are so many different things that could be used to test that, which ultimately doesn't test if they know how America "established its place in the world" but rather if they know the events, and there are so many different events. Do they know the Monroe Doctrine, but not the Jay Treaty? Do they focus on Native American Treaties, or should they pay closer attention to the Louisiana Purchase? Did they forget what the Treaty of Ghent was, and that's the example they used on the test? Can they explain all these events but can't explain how it established America's place in the world? Is the question even asked in a way that asks them to explain that, or does it just ask them what the event was?
That's a nice, specific, example. When you look at the 7th grade standards they get even more vague. "Describe major achievements from Indian, Chinese, Mediterranean, African, and Southwest and Central Asian civilizations." That's a standard that they will be tested on this year, but did they learn about all of those civilizations? Do they remember them? Some of this was covered at best a year ago, but possibly all the way back in 6th grade depending on the school they were at. Do they remember India but not China? What do they mean by Mediterranean? The Greeks? The Phoenicians? The Egyptians? The Romans? the Assyrians? The Babylonians? I mean, it's not like we get to see the test so we can know what they're going to cover on it, though we may get an old test to see what the past has looked like. But, even so, does it show that students learned it, or if they happened it to remember it on that specific day?
Of course, that's not even the only test they have to take. They also have to take tests at the beginning and end of the year in math and English. Add to that the normal unit tests and quizzes that happen regularly. Finally, because I'm at a charter school they have these progress tests that they have to take three times a year. For these tests, they are created by someone at the corporate office, and they push down a calendar of when they have to be taken by, and when they have to be scanned into the system by. The problem is that these timelines are arbitrary and not based on the progress I've made in class. There is then focus on these tests, they want to use them to predict how they will do on the state tests, we're told that these are supposed to help "inform our teaching" yet the tests are pot-marked by errors, and with the inflexible timeline, their scores may not matter if we haven't covered all the content or we have rushed through it so we can test on time. The students don't take it seriously because one they know it's not a grade, two they have no desire to do it, and in my case they only see me every other day (because the state only tests once every three years they figure they don't need social studies every day, which is also true of science), they don't see social studies as an important class.
Of course, that then leads to the push to teach testing skills. Teach the students to take the test, rather than the content they need to know. Spend valuable time on those skills, which also don't show if the student knows the content, but if they know how to figure out multiple choice questions in a way that you can pick the right one without actually knowing the answer. They want us to teach to the test, and want us to think that's a good thing. I disagree with the whole premise of testing, using testing as an assessment of the teacher, and the intended and unintended consequences of that outlook on education. I want my students to do well on the test, but only because they know the material and only because I want them to know the material since it's important.
I'm just saying, don't pretend that this is just a tool to help me decide what to teach if you're going to force me to use it, tell me when I have to use it, and then constantly focus on the data and results. If it's just a tool for me, why do you care so much?
Picture(s) of the Day:
Picture 13
No comments:
Post a Comment