Well, I have to say that I thought the movie was really well done. When I look at the way they adapted the book to movie form I have to say they were probably the most true to the original content than most other adaptations. Does that mean it was 100% the book? No, of course not. A book has far more time to develop things, more room for details, and a just more opportunities to flesh things out. A movie on the other hand needs to make sure it doesn't drag ass, and keeps the interest of the viewers in a way that a book doesn't.
So the good first. As I said it was an adaptation that I found really good by comparisons. They added a few things, but I felt they helped propel the story along in a way that didn't distract. For example you didn't have a pointless dragon chase in the middle of the movie like Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire did. Or, strange details like weird Jamaican talking heads. Instead they were additions that made sense in the scheme of story telling and getting information to the audience that they couldn't get otherwise. For example, you had added commentary during the games where they explained things like the Tracker Jackers, or conversations between Snow and Seneca, or Seneca and Haymitch that logically could have happened, and explained why certain plot points took place.
On the opposite end, I didn't feel the cuts that were made were detrimental to the story either. You had unnecessary characters cut, such as the mayor's daughter, the fashion crew, or the avox. While these were nice stories in the book, the movie doesn't need them to take the plot along. In fact, from a movie standpoint they slow down the story and add extra unnecessary people. While the characters were nice touches to the world of the book, in a movie they weren't needed.
I enjoyed the feel. I think that district 12 looked exactly as I pictured it. A kind of mid-Atlantic state, with the hills and that kind of depression era look to things. People weren't happy, things weren't nice. It served as a wonderful juxtaposition with the clean modern plentiful world of the capital that we see when Katniss is taken from her district by a luxurious train filled with all the food one could want.
There were some minor issues that I didn't enjoy. For one, I felt that Haymitch wasn't quite fleshed out enough. You had one main drunk scene but other than that he seemed a bit too likable and a bit to ready to get down to work. You didn't get to see that switch that flips where he goes from drunken ass to helpful mentor. While that's probably not necessary for the story, I think it would have been more helpful since in the opening scene it's not clear why he's a drunkard or what it is that sobers him up.
I also felt the relationships between Katniss and Rue, and Katniss and Peeta weren't developed enough either. They were kind of flat and lacked the growth needed. However the books much of the narrative of what's going on takes place in Katniss' head, so it's hard to transpose that to a movie as it's kind of campy to have her constantly saying her thoughts. They weren't bad, but I think they could have done a better job.
Casting, I didn't like the choices of Woody Harrelson, Lenny Kravitz or Liam Hemsworth. Woody didn't quite have the look or demeanor that I pictured, Lenny seemed kind of aloof and unconcerned by anything, and Liam was too much the eye candy to propel the BS love triangle (which as I mentioned in my book blog, should have been cut entirely). Perhaps I'm bias because I hate Gale so much. Character wise he was a disappointment, plot wise he made things unnecessarily complicated, and really someone should have cut him out of the final story. I feel they were trying to pull a Twilight by adding unnecessary drama do a situation that could have been far more compelling in other ways.
Overall, I liked the movie and walked away happy. I think they stayed true to the original text while making a movie that is going to appeal to many. I'm interested to see what the final take is on the box office for the opening weekend. Mostly I hope it beats Twilight. I like it when anything beats Twilight because it's a festering bot of boiling shit.
No comments:
Post a Comment