Here's my problem, I work with Lincoln, and I have for a number of years. The district isn't a in great shape, with terrible test scores, poor morale, and I think the majority of it is an issue in the mindset than any other actual barrier. Now, most of my work deals with extracurricular activities, however I think the attitudes I see are crossover from classroom attitudes, though that's not what I'm going to talk about right now.
Regardless, the issue I have is that when I see something that isn't working, I have the desire to fix it. To fix it I try to find examples that work, and then see what that example does and determine if it is a reasonable expectation to try and implement it. For example when reforming the NPO I looked at other peer groups and took their best ideas and merged it with our needs to come up with a policy that makes sense.
Like wise, when I look at the district and the problems I compare it to the top in the area and see what can be done. In this case the top district in my opinion would be Saline (and with the recent recognition seems like a good one to look at). However, time and time again I hear things like "Saline isn't Lincoln" or "Lincoln has a much different demographic." Pretty much the argument is that Lincoln is too poor and Saline is too affluent to compare the schools to. Well, I'm sorry but that doesn't work for me, and here are a few reasons why.
1. School Funding
Guess what excuse making whiners? Lincoln and Saline get nearly the same amount of funding per pupil, the difference is $327. Yes that's right, Saline receives $7,473 per student, Lincoln receives $7,142 per student. A difference of about 4% in funding, that's right, they receive about 4% more per student than we do. Yes, that adds up to $1,497,006 in total funding lost, however, in the big scheme of things, that's not a huge amount.
Now, of course one might point to the fact that they're a bigger district so the difference is greater. ($1.725 Million), however you also have to consider they have more student to have to provide services for, thus they need more space, more supplies, etc. etc. So, I don't see this as a valuable marker as to why we can't be more like a school like Saline. I mean if you look at say Ann Arbor with an additional $2,174 per student, you might have an argument as it's a 30% increase in funding. 4% does not a big difference make. While that money would be helpful, it's also not so damaging to explain why that doesn't work. See the graph from this article regarding school of choice on districts.
This next argument instead decides to claim that the students in the school are all poor, and thus we can't compete because our students are so different from Saline and therefore it's comparing apples to oranges. Well, that must mean that we have a huge portion of are students on the free lunch program, so much more so than a school like Saline. I will concede that we have twice as many students on Free Lunch as Saline. However, the actual numbers aren't impressive. According to GreatSchools.org Lincoln has 10% of student on free lunch, while Saline has 5%.
Yes, that's a difference, however it still means that 90% are NOT on free lunch. So I don't think the argument holds that Saline is in so much of a better position because they have 5% difference in the total population. Again, the argument that we can't compare to a great school because of who are students are don't necessarily hold up.
3. Ahh, but the people in Saline are so much better off.
I will give you that the upper earners in Saline are more plentiful than they are at Lincoln, but lets look at those numbers a little more closely. According to data from the 2009 American Community Survey (in conjunction with the Census) Saline and Lincoln have some differences, but in reality I don't think it's as large as some argue.
I won't argue that the mean income for families is higher in Saline than it is for Lincoln, Saline has a median family income of $102,000, while Lincoln's mean family income is $73,000 (though both are well over the national median income of $49,445 according to the 2010 census). However, it's important to look at how those numbers. The median is all well and good, but you have to look at how these families are distributed.
Looking at the data we can see that the distribution has a heaver load of poor and working class at Lincoln, with higher upper class in Saline, but the numbers are not compelling enough to convince me that the problem is demographic. Looking at the lowest group, those making under $15,000 a year, Lincoln does carry a heavier load with 7.8% of families in the district earning this amount. In comparison, Saline has only 3.1% with the same income. However, when you look at all households, the number shrinks to 7.6% at Lincoln and 5.8% in Saline.
Moving on to what is considered to be working class families (or those making less thank $35,000), you again have a heaver representation in Lincoln than Saline, with 12% of Lincoln families falling under this classification, and only 6.1% of Saline families earning similar amounts. However, again this number shrinks when you look at the community as a hole to 15% at Lincoln and 10.5% in Saline
Likewise, you see a similar shift when looking at what would be considered upper class families making over $150,000 where Saline has a much higher rate of 22.1% of families in this bracket, while Lincoln kicks in with only 6.9%.
However, that leaves us with the last group, the middle class, the class that most Americans would identify themselves as (correctly or not). This consists of the groups that make over $35,000 a year, but less than $150,000 a year. And in this Lincoln surpasses Saline, with 73.2% to 68.6%. (further dividing it, to upper middle class you end up with 48% of Saline in this category and 42% of Lincoln.)
So, what these numbers tell me is yes, indeed Lincoln does have a lower wage, however the vast majority of students fall into the same social category. While Saline has a higher upper class representation, and Lincoln a higher lower class representation, most the student fall into the same brackets. 90% of Saline students are considered middle class or higher, while 80% of Lincoln meets the same category.
These are not huge divides. Yes, there is a difference as there are more at the top for Saline and more at the bottom for Lincoln, but that group int he middle is very close together. So what are the real issues at play?
1. Mindset
The problem isn't the issues laid out, the problem is that there are too many people walking around saying "It's just Lincoln." If you keep setting the bar so low, you can never expect people to reach their full potential. If you expect everything to be shitty, and then make excuses when things ARE shitty, then you can never expect them to get better.
I don't buy this load of crap. There's no good reason I've heard that can't be overcome with some hard work, determination, and raising the level of expectations. It will be difficult for a while as people adjust, but if you don't raise the bar, no one will try to reach it.
2. Lack of vision
Everyone is so blinded by their mindset, and so discouraged by constantly being told that you can't expect more, that no one has come up with a vision except for small insignificant steps. Suggestions are shot down before they're even attempted. Expectations are so low that anything higher is said to be impossible. With that kind of negativitiy who would possible go up against the massive institution and machine when it will just crush them?
If you have no vision of what you want to be, how can you ever try to do better? It's like being blindfolded in the woods. You can't see where you are, and therefore can't make a plan of where you'd like to go to get out of the woods. You need someone to be bold enough to paint a grand picture and pull everyone along the way.
3. Laziness
I hate to say it, but I think the biggest problem is people aren't willing to put the work in to make it a great place. You see, sometimes you're called upon to go above and beyond. When the status quo is terrible, you're going to have to put more into it to get it up to snuff. However, I hear things like "I'm not paid for that" or "That's not in my contract". I'm sorry, but schools are the pillar of a community, and while I expect fair pay for a job, at the same time this is YOUR community! You have to believe in it, be willing to work at it, and build it to the level you expect.
I'm not one to compare myself to others because I know I'm a nut that will fill every last minute in my day. However, at the same time there are things that don't require as much work, and yet they are resisted. Yes, the occasional extra hour, or, perhaps some time planning. Many people do this, but at the same time, it's going to take a bit more and from EVERYONE if you want to change things. Sadly I'm just not seeing that.
In the end, I'm done with the excuses. I have a grand vision, and I will put that ambition plan out for all to see. Either you're on the bus with us, or there's no room for you. It's going to be difficult to transition, but the bar has to be raised.
No comments:
Post a Comment