A few years back all the hype was around the movie Waiting For Superman and how Charter Schools were going to be the savior of the "broken" public school system. Now, right off the bat I have to say I don't by the "broke" public school argument. I 100% believe that there are drop out factories, and schools that are "broken" but the model of a free and public education is sound. Are there issues? Yes. But do the majority of student who leave school know how to read, write, and have a basic understanding of History, Math, and Science? Yes. And furthermore, most have enough to get by in life, so I can't say that the school system is failing the majority of students.
However, it is failing some student. However I don't feel charter schools are the answer. And I guess this article is exhibit A. You see, they don't do any better than your traditional school. So that superman isn't coming, because he isn't real. Now, I will note that they point out that charters seem to do better in areas most affected by the education gap (specifically poor and minority areas). So, I'm less critical of those area, but overall I don't agree with the charter idea.
This idea that you can just go and make another school to "save" students is BS. Focus on the school, because that student is now taking funding with them to the charter, and the home district is going to go into further financial trouble. It also takes some of the best students, who are the good citizens, the role models, and the peers that can help others out of the mix.
Are there problems with school systems? Absolutely. I see it all the time and it drives me insane, but you know what the real problem is. Involvement. You don't like how it's going, then get your asses up to the school board meetings. Find replacements for the school board members, petition, campaign, demand change. No one cares. They complain that the teachers aren't doing their jobs, well the COMMUNITY isn't doing their job in making sure we have good schools.
Anyway, this just drove me nuts and I needed discuss.
No comments:
Post a Comment