Last week I had a number of blogs on schools and discussed that I felt education was in a critical failure. I then discussed troubles I've seen working in public schools, and my general grumpiness related to how things are versus how they could be. Today I was reading through some of my normal blogs when I came across this report on accountability in schools.
The study was done by The Kettering Foundation and Public Agenda, and it focused on the idea of school accountability which has been a bit of a topic since No Child Left Behind passed in the early years of the Bush Administration. The idea that schools should be more accountable is surely not a bad idea, however this report discussed how different groups view accountability and where leaders and parents both agree and diverge in their opinion of it. I will say that a lot of the information from the research didn't surprise me, but I wasn't necessarily expecting some of the views that were also presented from parents, which focused a lot on their role in the system and how they too needed to be accountable.
One thing that immediately jumped out was the statistic that only 29% have a good deal of confidence in public schools today, this is compared to the 58% that held these views in the 1970s. I think this is really an important part of the puzzle because I don't really think that the school systems have really gone in such decline since the 1970s, if anything the increased focus on schools could only increase performance. Perhaps this has more to do with the perception of schools than the reality. For years now we have heard people hammer the schools as failures, terrible, awful, not preparing students for college. What has really changed in schools since the 1970s, especially given that the argument has been "we can't do it the way we've been doing it." So, if the old way was so bad, why did so many people have confidence in schools? I'm not saying the old way was better, but I am saying the constant attacks on education, educators, and public schools I believe have pushed people to this negative perception, and I don't think it's an accurate view of the schools.
I absolutely agree that schools need to do better. I am a huge critic of our public school, I don't believe it prepares students for college properly, I don't believe it challenges students, I don't believe it provides the best education available. However I do have confidence in the system, and I do believe it can be improved. Just because I have high standards about what the school should be, doesn't mean the system itself is a failure, it merely has opportunities to improve and provide a better education. In all reality students graduate, they can read and write, they can do basic math, they are aware of science and history. They may not be perfect, but they are not completely uneducated.
One thing that immediately jumped out was the statistic that only 29% have a good deal of confidence in public schools today, this is compared to the 58% that held these views in the 1970s. I think this is really an important part of the puzzle because I don't really think that the school systems have really gone in such decline since the 1970s, if anything the increased focus on schools could only increase performance. Perhaps this has more to do with the perception of schools than the reality. For years now we have heard people hammer the schools as failures, terrible, awful, not preparing students for college. What has really changed in schools since the 1970s, especially given that the argument has been "we can't do it the way we've been doing it." So, if the old way was so bad, why did so many people have confidence in schools? I'm not saying the old way was better, but I am saying the constant attacks on education, educators, and public schools I believe have pushed people to this negative perception, and I don't think it's an accurate view of the schools.
I absolutely agree that schools need to do better. I am a huge critic of our public school, I don't believe it prepares students for college properly, I don't believe it challenges students, I don't believe it provides the best education available. However I do have confidence in the system, and I do believe it can be improved. Just because I have high standards about what the school should be, doesn't mean the system itself is a failure, it merely has opportunities to improve and provide a better education. In all reality students graduate, they can read and write, they can do basic math, they are aware of science and history. They may not be perfect, but they are not completely uneducated.
I also agree with the finding that parents feel that their role has a huge impact as well. I think that is a huge argument and wedge issue in the entire reform movement. Teachers are attacked, they are judged by how a student learns, their jobs and livelihoods are in jeopardy and a lot of the variables are outside of their control. Yes, I completely agree that an effective teacher can do great things, and an ineffective teacher should either improve, or be removed. However, this method often will lead to tension because it creates an adversarial stance because teachers feel they are being judged for things they don't have total control over, and those who do have a good portion of the control can't be held accountable. Though it seems that perhaps many parents agree with that and there is room for some bridge building. One mother in Detroit said, "I think so many people depend on the school to do everything. There's a lack of accountability... with parents... [They] feel like "I'm just going to send my kid to school from 8:00 to 4:00 every day" and let the teacher deal with it. You know what? The teacher has 30 other students."
Another mother from Detroit also commented on other items that our outside the control of a teacher, stating, "What about the rest of the stuff going on in the school? . . . I mean it depends on what they came into. How are the books? How are the—how are the—what’s the class sizes? I mean there are so many other things other than test scores."
Other parents focused on the things I talked about last week. They felt that society had a part to play in the current situation because we don't value education, but rather we value money, things, fame, rather than hard work, doing what you're supposed to do, and being a good person. One parent from New Orleans noted that he, "blame[s] the society more than the individual teachers [for not preparing
kids] because we have a culture that doesn’t honor hard work, reading, exercise, and all of those things [that] I think interact" The report summarized that, "many believe that they face an uphill battle trying to raise children in what they see as a toxic culture—one that glamorizes materialism and
self-indulgence. Many parents seem to be looking for answers and looking for allies. How can educators, parents, and other adults work together to instill the values that will help children flourish in school and beyond?"
I think this highlights the important fact that perhaps both sides of the discussion have far more in common than it seems. That perhaps the wedge that is being driven for what I feel are political purposes, is damaging to schools, teachers, parents, and students. Education can be better, and I think both sides need to find a way to communicate and build bridges. Communication is key, and from my experience one of the skills that is severely lacking, and causes a lot of damage, distrust, and lack of confidence.
Anyhow, I thought it was an interesting report and thought I would share it and my thoughts on some of the findings.
I think this highlights the important fact that perhaps both sides of the discussion have far more in common than it seems. That perhaps the wedge that is being driven for what I feel are political purposes, is damaging to schools, teachers, parents, and students. Education can be better, and I think both sides need to find a way to communicate and build bridges. Communication is key, and from my experience one of the skills that is severely lacking, and causes a lot of damage, distrust, and lack of confidence.
Anyhow, I thought it was an interesting report and thought I would share it and my thoughts on some of the findings.
2 comments:
Good info. That's really interesting how in the 70s there was a more positive outlook, and why has our perception changed so much. What kind of agenda is trying to be carried out now that wasn't in the 70s. Maybe it really could be as simple as changing society's outlook on education and teaching. Hmm.
I think it certainly has to do with society's outlook changing, but I think that has certainly been helped along. I think there are certainly a lot of political undertones to a lot of it that have helped, and I think perhaps it has had some political goals in mind. I think there are also some economic factors that may be pushing it along as well, such as the testing industry. I'm not saying that the intent is necessarily malicious, but I these groups do have agendas that aren't necessarily for the good of the students. It's very sad.
Whatever the cause, people need to get it together and get involved and speak up. I used to go to every school board meeting for Lincoln for about 5 years, generally there was no one else there but us and maybe a couple of regulars. In a district with 3,000 students you'd think more than half a dozen people would show up.
Post a Comment