To start off, I have to say that I was not totally enthralled with the idea of another Toy Story movie. I thought that Toy Story 3 had a perfect wrap up for the franchise, and that there was no need to keep it going. They told a good story that had a beginning, middle, and end, anything else probably would just be a money grab. I guess the nice thing is that with all things like this, we can just completely ignore the things that we don't like and pretend that they didn't happen, kind of like what Pixar did with Cars 2 (I mean, Cars 3 did not seem to acknowledge anything that happened in Cars 2, rightly so because that was a real train wreck of a movie and Cars 3 was way better).
Given that I wasn't really in love with the idea of a the movie to begin with, it was an enjoyable movie for the most part. There were some good comedic moments with the new toy "forky" and the Ducky and Bunny, voiced by Keegan-Michael Key and Jordan Peele, had a really funny discussion on how they were going to acquire a key from a little old lady. They also had a dare devil motorcycle stunt toy called Duke Caboom, who was apparently voiced by Keanu Reeves that had some great moments. Throughout the movie I didn't have any points where I was bored or thought that it was taking too long, so the pacing was fine. Overally, it was an ok movie.
However, in the context of the series, I didn't love a lot of it. The first point that I didn't care for was, as I said, the fact that they felt they should do one in the first place. The last movie wrapped it up so nicely by Andy passing off his toys to Bonnie before he had one last time playing with him. It was a heartwarming, yet heartbreaking, moment that worked really well. It was a way to end the series by letting us know that the toys would be loved and continue playing with a child who would love them just as well as Andy did. You really can't ask for a better ending to a series than by letting us see a trajectory and allow us to imagine the happily ever after.
The other issue I had was that, with all the Toy Story movies, there has basically been the same external threat. Replacement and loss. Replacement by a cool new toy, being separated or lost, feeling that you will be forgotten and no longer serve a purpose. In all three of the preceding movies that was the driving force for the characters. It was the threat that they had to overcome to stay together and continue on with their lives. That's part of the reason that the ending in Toy Story 3 worked well, because they got to find their purpose again, they maintained their "family" of toys, and they got to continue being loved. This movie was really just a rehash of all of that. Woody is separated, again. Toys are worried about their purpose. There is a "villain" toy that has to be overcome because they have their own personal issues, be it the prospector, or Lotso. In this case, we end up with Gabby Gabby, who needs to get Woody's voice box because hers is defective. Without it she can't fulfill her purpose and attain the love of a child (in her case a specific child, who rejects her even after she is repaired). Again, the story was not that original.
The fact that the story was generally a rehash of the others leads me to the fact that it felt like the movie was very contrived. There was a clear end that they wanted to get to, and it felt like that at parts. It was predictable, it was heavily foreshadowed in the opening sequence between Woody and Bo Peep. You could almost feel the creators sitting around a table discussing how they get to the point that they were trying to get to. You could almost hear some writer say, "what if we did..." and that's how you ended up seeing on the screen what they were presenting to you. Now, I know that every good story needs a good storyboard so that the characters know where they are going to, however, a truly good movie isn't going to feel like it's so planned out. Really, it should feel like real characters making real choices. One such example I think is how they handled Buzz the entire movie. They needed him to be in the movie, and so they used this idea of "listening to his inner voice" which he somehow misunderstood to mean listen to his recorded catch phrases, so that they could get him to be the character to do thing things they wanted him to do. It didn't really feel like the natural way that Buzz would act or would understand.
The final issue that I think was the biggest problem for me was the ending. The opening sequence shows Woody risking himself to save RC, which he successfully does with the help of the gang. However as he's trying to return, the window is closes and Bo Peep is sold away. Luckily, the buyer forgets something and leaves the box next to the car allowing Woody to try and rescue her. However, she instead tries to talk Woody into coming with her. He, of course, can't because Andy is frantically searching for him. However, in this movie, Bonnie has kind of disregarded him, and so he doesn't feel the same connection as he did with Andy. Because of that, when he miraculously happens upon Bo, he again is faced with the opportunity to run away with her, and this time he decides to take it. I didn't enjoy this aspect of the movie, it broke the group up, and was sad. It was also clear throughout that this was the ending that they were working toward. I didn't feel like that it really fit in with the way that Woody has been in the previous three films. I also feel like it doesn't mesh well with that final ending from Toy Story 3. As they are trapped in the incinerator, the toys all link hands. They know the end has arrived, and they are going to face it together, as they have faced all things for years. They are in this together. But, they aren't in it together anymore, Woody leaves them. Woody, who has really been their leader, turns and walks away. His job as a toy is over, he's lost his pull string voice, he's lost Andy, so he's just going to live life for himself with Bo. While they gave the stepping stones to get him to that place, it was ultimately unsatisfying.
As a stand alone movie, it was decent. It had some funny parts, it was often amusing and fun to watch. However, as part of the series of films, I wasn't thrilled by it. It was too constructed, and I felt the ending was sad in a way that was disappointing rather than uplifting. Because of that, I give Toy Story 4 a "Wait for DVD" rating.
Picture(s) of the Day:
Picture 88

No comments:
Post a Comment