Sunday, July 21, 2019

Respectability

Today we did our drive back home, and it was generally unremarkable. I'm starting to feel like maybe it would be better to fly. It'd save so much time, we'd be able to not worry about parking and tolls, but then again there is a lot of downside with price and then transportation in and out of the airport. There aren't always good options. But we made it home safe and sound.

The show last night has really stuck in my mind thinking about how they presented the characters and the story, particularly Atticus.  The big thing with Atticus is that he was kind and he was kind to them regardless of how rude or disrespectful they were to him. He felt it was important to be respectful to everyone.  This was how they portrayed him on stage as well, however the other characters gave some pushback on his philosophy towards others, especially Jem and Calpurnia.  Jem had the feeling that his dad shouldn't just take whatever they said to him, he's willing to stand up to people who want to be rude or threatening to the family. This leads to some on stage tension between Jem and Atticus.

However, I think that Calpurnia does an even better job at challenging Atticus and his world view of respect towards everyone, even those who are advocating for violent vigilantism.  In one exchange Atticus is expressing how respect is important, even when he may not agree or like what someone else is saying or how they are acting toward him.  However, Calpurnia tells him that he is willing to be respectful towards everyone, no matter how much it may disrespect someone else. This line really stuck out because it illustrates that there are causes and effects to what we do. That Calpurnia is saying is that those who are the targets of the racists attacks and actions by members of the KKK are being disrespected when hateful people are treated as rational and respected individuals. In a way it is legitimizing their opinions as if they are acceptable. When it comes to the structural racism that has endured, it helps maintain it. Characters like Mrs. Dubose expect that they will be respected, regardless of what they say or do. It gives them a certain immunity to their words and actions. By respecting them their words go unchallenged.

Ultimately, Atticus holds firm the entire play feeling that respect is owed to all and that people can be trusted to do the right thing eventually.  However, he ends up looking kind of like a naive fool. He sees the world in an almost Polllyanna kind of way, and doesn't seem to understand that the people he is dealing with are not operating in good faith. He seems unable to understand the effects of racism and white supremacy in his community. He believes that things are much further along than they really are and that mosts people are good and not racists, when in fact the reach of that systematic racism stretches far wider than may be openly visible.  While not everyone may be hooded at a klan meeting, that doesn't mean that the people he interacts with daily are interested in equality or even sympathetic towards the African-Americans in the town or county. He is blinded by his experiences, the privilege that he has as a white male in that time to be given the benefit of the doubt. He is blinded by his naïveté that respect is owed to all and that because he often receives respect that the same respect is extended to everyone. He also seems stuck in an ineffectual strategy to change the world. He believes that respect and kindness will save the world, that it's the problem is the root to the problem and by modeling that respect and kindness and extending it towards people it will somehow cause those people to change how they act.

I think this really speaks to the world that we are living in today. It is quite common on social media to every once in a while see someone repost the thing talking about how what is wrong with the world today is that people aren't kind enough. That by being polite, by holding the door for the next person, or letting that person in at the traffic merge is what will solve the situation.  As if those things are going to change the systematic nature of the actual challenges that face us. That by somehow being nice to a random stranger will result in more fair sentencing, or make the bigot change their mind about those that he hates. It's a world view that says that they have not really seen actual adversity or been on the receiving end of the hate or structural discrimination that exists. It is the solution of respect that Atticus believes will make things better, but comes from someone who is rarely disrespected.  Would it be nice if people were kind to each other? Sure. However, it's not going to change the world, and is akin to having someone tell you to "walk it off" when your bone is protruding from your body. Such suggestions seem foolish and naive.  This is especially true when it comes from those in power and have the mechanisms to make real change. By telling us that it is merely kindness that will change the world, it denies the actual challenges that exist. It says that those things are minor and that a minor solution will cure it. It also allows those who benefit from the system to never have to face or reconcile their benefits and privileges under it.

Ultimately, Atticus is right to feel that we should try to understand others, be kind and respectful when possible. However, the world is more complex than that and not everyone in it is operating in good faith. Kindness is a noble idea but much like Atticus is blind to the deep nature of the issues in the story, people today are also blinded by the same issues. We are not as far along as we would like to think, and recent events illustrate the deep nature of the challenges we actual face. Kindness and respectability are noble intentions, but in the face of bigotry and hate they are as ineffectual as broom in a gun fight.

Picture(s) of the Day: 
Picture 99
I was really bummed yesterday because I couldn't get this photo to fit on the blog. Lucky for me I had so many thoughts on the show that I got to use it for today's picture of the day, even though it's from yesterday.

No comments: